Another Non-shippy ep but I’m going to post it anyway just to get caught up.
One False Step
Favorite Scene- Daniel playing airplane
Favorite Quote-
Teal’c: Do you not believe we are responsible, O’Neill?
Jack: Yes, I do… not…
Does anyone like this ep? GW comments and ratings pan this as one of the worst Stargate eps there is.
One fun thing about a rewatch is getting something out of the episodes that you don’t like on the first couple of tries. Reading other people’s comments really helps me with that! So I really gave it my best shot but this episode just doesn’t work for me on any level. I’ve always I thought it was the cheesy costumes or stereotypical Jack and Daniel- but I think there’s more to it than that.
It seems to me that Stargate episodes all have a purpose- part of a story arc, eye candy, or social/technological commentary. The best ones have all three. I think this episode has none of those. It is a useless episode and the first one I have seen thus far in Stargate, and that’s why I don’t like it. Are there any others like this?
A nice little bit of continuity here with Carter cutting her hand, because that’s a key part of 1969. I don’t get a single other thing out of this ep. Is there something more? I keep wondering but if there is I don’t see it. They’d have been better off if they’d had her cut her hand on a sardine lid in another episode, IMHO.
Implications for Sam and Jack: None that I can see. In fact, in my opinion there are no implications for anything or anyone and I think that’s why this ep fails so completely.
One False Step
Favorite Scene- Daniel playing airplane
Favorite Quote-
Teal’c: Do you not believe we are responsible, O’Neill?
Jack: Yes, I do… not…
Thanks, Achaja!
Does anyone like this ep? GW comments and ratings pan this as one of the worst Stargate eps there is.
One fun thing about a rewatch is getting something out of the episodes that you don’t like on the first couple of tries. Reading other people’s comments really helps me with that! So I really gave it my best shot but this episode just doesn’t work for me on any level. I’ve always I thought it was the cheesy costumes or stereotypical Jack and Daniel- but I think there’s more to it than that.
It seems to me that Stargate episodes all have a purpose- part of a story arc, eye candy, or social/technological commentary. The best ones have all three. I think this episode has none of those. It is a useless episode and the first one I have seen thus far in Stargate, and that’s why I don’t like it. Are there any others like this?
A nice little bit of continuity here with Carter cutting her hand, because that’s a key part of 1969. I don’t get a single other thing out of this ep. Is there something more? I keep wondering but if there is I don’t see it. They’d have been better off if they’d had her cut her hand on a sardine lid in another episode, IMHO.
Spoiler:
Implications for Sam and Jack: None that I can see. In fact, in my opinion there are no implications for anything or anyone and I think that’s why this ep fails so completely.
Comment