Originally posted by KatG
View Post
TPTB never managed to convince me, in 10 plus years, that we were watching a realistic, normal, healthy relationship.
Due to all the uncomfortable looks, stilted silences and juvenile, fumbling attempts at conversation, I just can't imagine the pair of them ever having an intelligent, realistic, conversation. About romance or anything else, really. And I certainly can't imagine why TPTB thought we fans would think that this was a good way to show two of their lead characters.
Grown adults can be foolish in love, it's never a pretty sight, it's not cute or admirable, laudable or attractive. Why would you want to show these characters, characters you have worked long and hard on, acting like lovesick teenagers? Why keep them in limbo, unable to move forward like normal people? What on earth does it add to their characters? It makes them into caricatures and can only damage them.
And I've never seen a single scene of the silly melodrama which added to the net SG1 story. In taking screen time from the team and important plot lines, it takes so much more than it gives.
The only reason I can think is that, for some reason, the formula had to be adhered to, main man had to fit with main woman, regardless of the internal story structure, the lack of romantic chemistry, the damage to the larger SG1 story.
Still, SG1 is old news now, and I always remind myself, it could have been so much worse, S/J fizzled out like the damp squib it was. No big fireworks, just a pathetic fizz which died away to nothing.
FF
Comment