Rite of Passage
Josi, alas I still can't green you, but great analysis.
Generally
Again, its one of those episodes that I was very meh about when I first watched (despite the fact that I liked them bringing back Cassie) but really enjoy on rewatching.
SG1's relationship with Cassie: I'm not sure I completely agree with the assessment that Daniel and Teal'c aren't as close to Cassie as Sam and Jack, although I concede the episode shows more scenes with Jack and Sam with Cassie than either Daniel or Teal'c. I think we just didn't see the scenes where the others interact with Cassie. Daniel is certainly lined up with Sam and Jack on the "what to do" front and won't countenance sacrificing Cassie for Nirrti. And I think the moment with Janet hints that they have something of a friendship beyond the walls of the SGC and by extension, that it's likely Daniel will also have something of a relationship with Cassie. Teal'c, I think, is the most objective in his stance, but I do tend to put this down to the different cultural take he has a Jaffa - not because he cares for Cassie any less than the others.
Sam and Jack
Again, I don't see RoP as shippy. But I think they gravitate to each other (like magnets!) over the situation with Cassie and are personally in synch with their focus on saving her. I would agree that Jack is concerned for Sam as well as for Cassie himself; that he does send her back from Hanka so she can be with Cassie. And I would agree that there are nice hints about how Sam sees Jack - that she recognises his intelligence and his ability to see through the crap to the heart of the matter, recognises his humour is a defence mechanism.
It is a great set-up for the final resolution with Nirrti in Metamorphosis because their decision here will definitely come back to bite them.
Josi, alas I still can't green you, but great analysis.
Generally
Again, its one of those episodes that I was very meh about when I first watched (despite the fact that I liked them bringing back Cassie) but really enjoy on rewatching.
SG1's relationship with Cassie: I'm not sure I completely agree with the assessment that Daniel and Teal'c aren't as close to Cassie as Sam and Jack, although I concede the episode shows more scenes with Jack and Sam with Cassie than either Daniel or Teal'c. I think we just didn't see the scenes where the others interact with Cassie. Daniel is certainly lined up with Sam and Jack on the "what to do" front and won't countenance sacrificing Cassie for Nirrti. And I think the moment with Janet hints that they have something of a friendship beyond the walls of the SGC and by extension, that it's likely Daniel will also have something of a relationship with Cassie. Teal'c, I think, is the most objective in his stance, but I do tend to put this down to the different cultural take he has a Jaffa - not because he cares for Cassie any less than the others.
Sam and Jack
Again, I don't see RoP as shippy. But I think they gravitate to each other (like magnets!) over the situation with Cassie and are personally in synch with their focus on saving her. I would agree that Jack is concerned for Sam as well as for Cassie himself; that he does send her back from Hanka so she can be with Cassie. And I would agree that there are nice hints about how Sam sees Jack - that she recognises his intelligence and his ability to see through the crap to the heart of the matter, recognises his humour is a defence mechanism.
It is a great set-up for the final resolution with Nirrti in Metamorphosis because their decision here will definitely come back to bite them.
Comment