He seemed like an alright character to me. I think they (TPTB) just didn't know what to do, so they tossed him out and used a plot device that worked (strong, brutish, athletic alien male who has tons of rage at the galaxy due to oppression). Examples would be Teal'c (realized for a while the Goa'uld were not gods), Bratac (for the same reason), and a female example would be Teyla (a woman who's people, along with the rest of the Pegasus galaxy, have been preyed upon by the Wraith for over 10,000 years).
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Will Ford return this season?
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Originally posted by monkey_man132 View PostNo hes dead. He can't fly a dart so he couldn't escape. If he could fly a dart he wouldn't have needed to Sheppard's help to fly it.Originally posted by monkey_man132 View PostThe Daedalus would have said, "there is a dart escaping to the planet's Stargate".Originally posted by monkey_man132 View PostSorry hopeful people, he is dead. Space dust. Gone. Nada.Originally posted by monkey_man132 View PostIf he magically comes back to life, like Carson will, I swear to god I will stop watching SGA.
Comment
-
Originally posted by monkey_man132 View PostNo hes dead. He can't fly a dart so he couldn't escape. If he could fly a dart he wouldn't have needed to Sheppard's help to fly it. The Daedalus would have said, "there is a dart escaping to the planet's Stargate".
Sorry hopeful people, he is dead. Space dust. Gone. Nada.
If he magically comes back to life, like Carson will, I swear to god I will stop watching SGA.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Major Tyler View PostIt's been clearly demonstrated that large explosions disrupt Terran sensors, and two exploding Hive Ships is pretty big.
Comment
-
again that wouldnt be hard, you forget it's sci fi, you could say anything.... it was damaged and only appeared as wreckage or it had a cloak and is a new type of fighter the wraith were experimenting with...
WHO KNOWS?
It wouldnt take much to write him in... thats all it takes... whether they do or not is the issue
Comment
-
Well if I were a writer, I'm sure I'd find it a lot easier to write Ford back into Atlantis than Carson. The 'he must be dead (insert explanation)' argument just doesn't hold water, I bet if you gave the writers and hour they could probably come up with 10 different ways he could have escaped.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ColCaldwell View PostWhen Weir asked if they looked for Sheppard, the Tech said the Daedalus stated "there was nothing to look for." So if they were looking, they would have picked up on a Dart being flown out.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Major Tyler View PostThere's a difference between piloting a Dart and knowing enough to make it go in a straight line. He could easily have snagged a dart and headed for the planet's surface. He wouldn't have even needed to even land because he could have used the ship's escape transporter.
Originally posted by Major Tyler View PostWould they? It's been clearly demonstrated that large explosions disrupt Terran sensors, and two exploding Hive Ships is pretty big.And you alone will make that determination for everyone?
Originally posted by Major Tyler View PostI can think of a few people who wouldn't mind that.Last edited by monkey_man132; 04 June 2007, 05:07 PM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Amakusa View PostI just love how people are so eager to shoot down this character coming back from the dead and not the other one.
Comment
Comment