Originally posted by Girlbot
View Post
Since I have kept myself totally spoiler free for SGU, I had no idea what "Time" was about, and when I saw her get Whacked it was perfect.
Quite frankly I loved Keller! And Chloe is no Keller....
-
I Knew anti Chloe's would love that scene!
Quite frankly I loved Keller! And Chloe is no Keller.... -
I really didn't follow Atlantis, the wraith scared me off early on. But I watched some of it when McKay and Keller got together *shudders*.Originally posted by aretood2 View Postno means no, and so does pepper spraySig by The CarpentersigpicComment
-
It did seem forced, But I guess that's why people see Chloe/scott like a keller/Mckay.Originally posted by Girlbot View PostComment
-
Yeah, I don't get the chloe/Scott thing myself.Originally posted by aretood2 View Postno means no, and so does pepper spraySig by The CarpentersigpicComment
-
Jack, Daniel, Sheppard, MacKay, Carson etc etc etc. They can all be classed, in some way, as a Mary Sue. But people just don't like doing it.Originally posted by KEK View PostDisclaimer: All opinions stated within this post are relevant to the author herself, and do not in any way represent the opinions of God, Country, The Powers That Be or Greater Fandom.
Any resemblance to aforementioned opinions are purely coincidental.Comment
-
-
It was desperation. It wasn't a bad idea just terrible executionOriginally posted by Girlbot View PostOriginally posted by aretood2Comment
-
Oh...yeah.....execution.......good word.....can we execute Chloe?Originally posted by jelgate View Post
Seriously, how do you think they could correct it.no means no, and so does pepper spraySig by The CarpentersigpicComment
-
It can't be corrected. The ship has been made. The best you can hope for is they make the ship itself more realasticOriginally posted by Girlbot View PostOriginally posted by aretood2Comment
-
There is nothing about Daniel's move from an academic to an almost super soldier that is not Mary Sue.Originally posted by aretood2 View Post
Jack is to a much lessor extent, much lessor extent... and I'll honestly say it has more to do with his backstory then anything else. So while I included him there, in no way is he a prime example of it
.
Disclaimer: All opinions stated within this post are relevant to the author herself, and do not in any way represent the opinions of God, Country, The Powers That Be or Greater Fandom.
Any resemblance to aforementioned opinions are purely coincidental.Comment
-
Daniel had years of experience in SG-1 before he started to carry real guns. I'd call that real life training, not Mary sue.Originally posted by Deevil View PostThere is nothing about Daniel's move from an academic to an almost super soldier that is not Mary Sue.
Jack is to a much lessor extent, much lessor extent... and I'll honestly say it has more to do with his backstory then anything else. So while I included him there, in no way is he a prime example of it.Comment
-
Personally I would rather they sink the ship .Originally posted by jelgate View Post
Can't he just tire of her, and move on. That would mean a huge psychological drama for Chloe, and then she may have some usefulness as a stalker for Scott. Give her something to do.no means no, and so does pepper spraySig by The CarpentersigpicComment
-
Super Solider Daniel made no sense what so ever, so you could call it a Mary Sue.Originally posted by aretood2 View Post
My point was, calling all the female characters Mary Sue's (as always happens) ignores that the same can be said for the male characters. I find that division amusing.
After all, I don't think all the female characters are Mary Sue's, and I don't think it about the males either. Just offering reasons they could be.Disclaimer: All opinions stated within this post are relevant to the author herself, and do not in any way represent the opinions of God, Country, The Powers That Be or Greater Fandom.
Any resemblance to aforementioned opinions are purely coincidental.Comment
-
I hope not. That sounds like a terrible storyline and a step back for the characterOriginally posted by Girlbot View PostOriginally posted by aretood2Comment
-
not a step back, just another aspect of her personality. I am just not liking the Chloe character. Hope it gets better in the second halfOriginally posted by jelgate View Postno means no, and so does pepper spraySig by The CarpentersigpicComment
Comment