Warning Contains Major Spoilers: Who will not Survive Enemy at the Gate?

[Falcon Horus]

Do I sense sarcasm in your voice?

Sarcasm has been omnipresent, yes... so yeah, I guess there is some.

were you talking about Weir?

I was thinking about her - but any of these candidates can bite the dust off-screen. Ford did.

[Jumper_One]

I was thinking about her - but any of these candidates can bite the dust off-screen. Ford did.

as did Weir, sorta... btw (Atlantis movies spoiler)

Spoiler:

q-ball-er writes: “do u think that there is hope for Weir popping up in any movies…at all??”

Answer: Sorry. Weir’s journey has ended.

http://josephmallozzi.wordpress.com/...ine-repellant/

[Falcon Horus]

as did Weir, sorta... btw (Atlantis movies spoiler)

Spoiler:

http://josephmallozzi.wordpress.com/...ine-repellant/

See, it's their best writing - they do far more in off-screen writing than actual on-screen writing. It's worthy of a nomination - if there was such an award, TPTW would win it year after year.

[Jumper_One]

See, it's their best writing - they do far more in off-screen writing than actual on-screen writing. It's worthy of a nomination - if there was such an award, TPTW would win it year after year.

they never killed off an important character off-screen

[Killdeer]

they never killed off an important character off-screen

Eh??? Elizabeth? This Mortal Coil?

[Falcon Horus]

they never killed off an important character off-screen

Yes, they...

Eh??? Elizabeth? This Mortal Coil?

...did.

[jelgate]

Eh????* Elizabeth??* This Mortal Coil?

But Weir wasn't really dead

[Falcon Horus]

But Weir wasn't really dead

The one of flesh and blood was... right? You know the original, not the copy.

[DrJenniferDex]

She's gone now. According to JM, Weir will not be showing up again.

[Killdeer]

But Weir wasn't really dead

?? I thought JM said they decided that she died after Lifeline. It was in one of his blogs right after GitM aired.

[Jumper_One]

Eh??? Elizabeth? This Mortal Coil?

Yes, they...



...did.

that wasn't our Weir

?? I thought JM said they decided that she died after Lifeline. It was in one of his blogs right after GitM aired.

this?

Marielabbott writes: “I understand now the comment on your blog awhile back that if you ask a different producer, you will likely get a different answer to the question of whether or not Weir was alive or dead. You tried to leave some of that ambiguity in the episode. Do you think Weir is alive or dead?”

Answer: To be honest, a year ago I held that the real Elizabeth Weir was still alive. Paul felt that the replicators would have had no reason to keep her around and insisted that Oberoth would have ordered her killed after Lifeline. I disagreed. Why kill her when you can keep her in stasis and possibly make use of her at a later date? Since the production of Ghost in the Machine however, I’ve come around to accept the logic of Paul’s argument.

http://josephmallozzi.wordpress.com/...se-of-the-day/

[Killdeer]

that wasn't our Weir

I wasn't referring to the copy we saw in TMC. I was referring to the fact that in TMC the repliKeller tells the WeirClone that Elizabeth was killed - offscreen.

And yes, that is the JM quote I was thinking of.

[Reiko]

they never killed off an important character off-screen

They've done it already.

She's gone now. According to JM, Weir will not be showing up again.

I don't care what JM says. And I WILL fight for her, dammit.

[jelgate]

Me thinks it will be a losing fight

[DrJenniferDex]

With you on that one, Jelgate.