Threads
Josi, I wish I could green you but I can't - that was an awesome review!
Generally
I don't have much to add to Josi's comments. I have to admit that I love Threads as an episode because in many ways it is the finale of the S1-S8 version of the TV series in that it ties up all major storylines and brings the characters full circle in terms of their character arcs.
Teal'c - I love that Teal'c is named Teal'c of the Tau'ri in Threads - making the distinction between Teal'c of Chulak who was the First Prime of Apophis and the Jaffa he has since become in rebelling against Apophis and leading his people to freedom. But there is that sense that the Jaffa have a long way to go to rebuild and become a functioning government.
Daniel - I love that Daniel is still being Daniel and talking people into doing what is right. In the movie he does it with Jack, here he does it with Oma. Moreover, he learns fully why he returned from Ascension and confirms that his place is not among the Ascended.
Sam and Jack
Sam and Jacob: Actually, for me much of Sam's journey is the one she makes with her Dad. Because it's a compare and contrast with the last time Jacob knew he was dying in Secrets. Then, all he wanted was for his daughter to be happy - and that hasn't changed. What has changed is how Jacob approaches the situation. Then, he interfered and tried to force her into a job he believed was her dream - his focus was on her professional happiness and his MO was force. Here, Jacob's entire approach to Pete is one of understanding that deep down he wasn't the right person for Sam and that he didn't make her happy no matter what she said out loud. While he does interfere a little (deliberately raising the subject of the flowers), he otherwise tries the softly-softly approach; he is non-commital when they discuss Pete in the mess and only tries persuasion to make Sam see that she shouldn't let things (the Air Force) stand in her way; she can still be happy and have everything she wants. His concern is for her personal happiness on all levels. Undoubtedly some of that is to do with Sam's personal journey from being mainly career focused when we meet her to her exploring her personal life over S7/8.
Sam and Pete: I think throughout it's clear that she's pretending everything is fine when it's not. And the break-up conversation shows that Pete was aware on some level that something was wrong (that she had doubts or baggage that prevented her from moving forward) but that he had hoped her agreement to be married had signalled the end of that. Personally, I think Pete acts very kindly in the break-up because he has to be hurting a lot. And I think Sam feels incredibly guilty and wishes he wasn't so kind. I do actually think the moment she sees the house it's over for her. For me, she's been having doubts since RepliCarter forced some blunt truths on her, the knowledge that her father doesn't wholly approve of Pete, her own reticence in getting involved with organising her wedding...I think the house is the proverbial straw. So by the time she ends up in Jack's back-yard, I think Sam had already concluded she was making a mistake marrying Pete. For me, Sam went there to say: I'm not marrying Pete, I still love you and I need to know how you feel about me.
Jack and Kerry: I don't think the regs apply since Kerry is still effectively a CIA agent and is performing a joint investigation into the Trust/Russia/Kinsey situation. While Jack is ostensibly one of Kerry's stakeholders, he's not formally her boss and their agreement that their relationship won't affect the job presumably took care of any conflict in that regard for both of them. I do think Jack keeps it secret both because he doesn't want to be the topic of gossip and because he doesn't want Sam in particular to know. On a friendship level he could have informed Sam when Sam spots Kerry in his office because just as a friend of 7 years plus it could be argued that Sam didn't deserve to be lumped in with the rest of the SGC. Kerry shows class in dumping Jack when she realises where his heart truly lies and shows security in herself as a person in determining that she deserves better than to be someone's second choice.
Sam and Jack: Yes, I love the always scene and for me it's the scene that says both of them have stopped hiding behind their fears and have acknowledged openly for the first time since D&C that they love each other; and I love that they go fishing at the end. For me, the implicit message in Threads is that they love each other and will find a way to get together.
Josi, I wish I could green you but I can't - that was an awesome review!
Generally
I don't have much to add to Josi's comments. I have to admit that I love Threads as an episode because in many ways it is the finale of the S1-S8 version of the TV series in that it ties up all major storylines and brings the characters full circle in terms of their character arcs.
Teal'c - I love that Teal'c is named Teal'c of the Tau'ri in Threads - making the distinction between Teal'c of Chulak who was the First Prime of Apophis and the Jaffa he has since become in rebelling against Apophis and leading his people to freedom. But there is that sense that the Jaffa have a long way to go to rebuild and become a functioning government.
Daniel - I love that Daniel is still being Daniel and talking people into doing what is right. In the movie he does it with Jack, here he does it with Oma. Moreover, he learns fully why he returned from Ascension and confirms that his place is not among the Ascended.
Sam and Jack
Sam and Jacob: Actually, for me much of Sam's journey is the one she makes with her Dad. Because it's a compare and contrast with the last time Jacob knew he was dying in Secrets. Then, all he wanted was for his daughter to be happy - and that hasn't changed. What has changed is how Jacob approaches the situation. Then, he interfered and tried to force her into a job he believed was her dream - his focus was on her professional happiness and his MO was force. Here, Jacob's entire approach to Pete is one of understanding that deep down he wasn't the right person for Sam and that he didn't make her happy no matter what she said out loud. While he does interfere a little (deliberately raising the subject of the flowers), he otherwise tries the softly-softly approach; he is non-commital when they discuss Pete in the mess and only tries persuasion to make Sam see that she shouldn't let things (the Air Force) stand in her way; she can still be happy and have everything she wants. His concern is for her personal happiness on all levels. Undoubtedly some of that is to do with Sam's personal journey from being mainly career focused when we meet her to her exploring her personal life over S7/8.
Sam and Pete: I think throughout it's clear that she's pretending everything is fine when it's not. And the break-up conversation shows that Pete was aware on some level that something was wrong (that she had doubts or baggage that prevented her from moving forward) but that he had hoped her agreement to be married had signalled the end of that. Personally, I think Pete acts very kindly in the break-up because he has to be hurting a lot. And I think Sam feels incredibly guilty and wishes he wasn't so kind. I do actually think the moment she sees the house it's over for her. For me, she's been having doubts since RepliCarter forced some blunt truths on her, the knowledge that her father doesn't wholly approve of Pete, her own reticence in getting involved with organising her wedding...I think the house is the proverbial straw. So by the time she ends up in Jack's back-yard, I think Sam had already concluded she was making a mistake marrying Pete. For me, Sam went there to say: I'm not marrying Pete, I still love you and I need to know how you feel about me.
Jack and Kerry: I don't think the regs apply since Kerry is still effectively a CIA agent and is performing a joint investigation into the Trust/Russia/Kinsey situation. While Jack is ostensibly one of Kerry's stakeholders, he's not formally her boss and their agreement that their relationship won't affect the job presumably took care of any conflict in that regard for both of them. I do think Jack keeps it secret both because he doesn't want to be the topic of gossip and because he doesn't want Sam in particular to know. On a friendship level he could have informed Sam when Sam spots Kerry in his office because just as a friend of 7 years plus it could be argued that Sam didn't deserve to be lumped in with the rest of the SGC. Kerry shows class in dumping Jack when she realises where his heart truly lies and shows security in herself as a person in determining that she deserves better than to be someone's second choice.
Sam and Jack: Yes, I love the always scene and for me it's the scene that says both of them have stopped hiding behind their fears and have acknowledged openly for the first time since D&C that they love each other; and I love that they go fishing at the end. For me, the implicit message in Threads is that they love each other and will find a way to get together.
Comment