Hey Mods!! How about making this thread a sticky??
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Bring Vala over to Stargate Atlantis Thread.
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
that would be THE WORST MOVE EVER if there was no Daniel.Originally posted by cowpants...you did it. I can't believe you actually did it. I am quite frankly astounded that you did it.
Thanks to you, I now want several mods to start mating with each other. I wanting to see what Moderator procreation will have in store for us.
And I thought that no one could get me to want this.
Congrats Mapp, you are officially the single most disturbed individual on GW.
-
I wouldn't be particularly in favour of this, especially with Carter on the way. I think it would work out OK though if she wasn't, I'd definatly be for it if they could somehow replace Teyla with Vala, she's a much better character (imo) than any of the other female characters in Atlantis, I'd like to see how she'd deal with the Genii...
Comment
-
errr NO! weve already got sam coming over (unfortunately IMO) we dont need anymore sg1 people thanks.
Plus what possible valid reason would there be to bring her over? (apart from it being another way to keep sg1 alive)
what would her motivations be to come over?
Vala is only on the show because of her connection with daniel and now his team, why would she leave all that to come to a galaxy that has nothing to do with her to be with people who mean nothing to her and who she barely knows?
Just no...bad idea imo!
Comment
-
i'm not a fan of vala, so i'd really, really prefer to not have her transplanted into atlantis. and the funny thing is, i've never watched one episode of atlantis and am only starting because of sam/amanda coming over.
i just feel that the way vala has been written from the get-go, she's just too all over the place and a scene hogger.
i don't know the way the atlantis characters are or how they relate to one another, but, for me, writing vala 'out there' forces the writers to write the rest of the characters 'out of character'.
since i'm just going to try atlantis now (when sam starts), i'd... i just don't care for the character. i'm sorry.
sallysally
sigpic
Comment
-
Vala would have a field-day in Atlantis. The way she reacted in The Pegasus Project. She'd probably wander off into the as of yet unexplored area's of the city and get herself killed in the process.
But no thanks. Vala can stay right where she is, and for the moment I still love her there.Heightmeyer's Lemming -- still the coolest Lemming of the forum
Proper Stargate Rewatch -- season 10 of SG-1
Comment
-
Originally posted by Falcon Horus View PostVala would have a field-day in Atlantis. The way she reacted in The Pegasus Project. She'd probably wander off into the as of yet unexplored area's of the city and get herself killed in the process.
But no thanks. Vala can stay right where she is, and for the moment I still love her there.Grammar, Logic, Rhetoric.
Comment
Comment