The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Vale_Sg1]

intresting enough i acutally liked the weir's new storyline which is a shock sense i normally can't stand her.

I'm sure the pro folks will be happy to hear that.

I just hope they don't go down the evil replicarter route with weir.That would just suck. i can't wait for sheppard and his team to meet up with her again.

Technically, it would be Repliweir. I think we're all - more or less painfully - aware that Carter is not Weir.

Aside from that i'm glad she's gone.I loved the weir in lost city so much that when i saw torri as the new weir i completely hated her.It seemed like such a cop out to me to get another actress to play an already casted role. Atlantis' weir was never weir for me so i'm glad she's out.

There are several rumors around about that, but I think Jessica was cast only temporarily (or so was tptb's version of things at the time). I also seem to recall that Torri was actually offered the job, according to what I've read on GW.

+

[FoolishPleasure]

Exactly - we're the only fans who want the demise. According to JM that is.

I'm one who doesn't really want the show to die, but I vent in the anti-thread because there have been too many changes and it isn't the show I used to know. If Weir had been "changed" but stayed a reg, that would have been great, even with Carter coming in as recurring. Beckett never should have been touched at all. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the character and no need to "stir things up".

I see posters in JM's blog raving about Carter, and they want more of Dr. Lee (who would just take away from Zelenka), and "when is Daniel and/or Jack coming to SGA?" Ugh. Maybe TPTB should have just cancelled SGA and kept SG1 around.

[Suzotchka]

I see posters in JM's blog raving about Carter, and they want more of Dr. Lee (who would just take away from Zelenka), and "when is Daniel and/or Jack coming to SGA?" Ugh. Maybe TPTB should have just cancelled SGA and kept SG1 around.

Sure seems to me that SGA was canceled - not SG-1.

[parisindy]

Happy Thanksgiving all!

don't have time to read everything at the moment so i'll be back in a bit.... but have we heard the ratings for the last fiasco yet?

i will read that article when i get back

Great post, that's the exact same viewpoint I have. I enjoy the character interaction and how their relationships grow. Not necessarily shippy stuff- I can take off the shipper glasses sometimes!- I enjoy seeing *friendship* and characters that care about each other. It was so much a part of SG-1. Those dynamics makes the show a nice place to be.

Then after making us 'emotionally invested' [love that term] in the characters, they go all 'Heroes' on us. One person being felled after another. And now I'm not bothering to pay much attention to any of the new characters, because who knows how long *they'll* last, and I've lost interest in Ronon/Teyla because so far, nothing much has been done with them over the past two seasons.

aww thanks you are too kind lol...i've been whining for a while i have practice lol but yeah thats totally... i loved them all... ((((((((((hugs)))))))

Spoiler:

and though i'm not watching this season i got to say the angle they went with teyla's pregnancy is totally bad... i can't help think its going to go bad... there are so many better ways they could have dealt with the pregnancy

Spoiler:

Sure, Teyla's pregnancy will be interesting in terms of seeing how they develop it- it'll be the first real arc they have to do, with real consequences and character growth and implications for the rest of the series. Unless they kill off the kid/father, they have to deal with all these different factors and the reset button isn't an option if they want to have *any* credibility left.

[/QUOTE]

Spoiler:

and though i'm not watching this season i got to say the angle they went with teyla's pregnancy is totally bad... i can't help think its going to go bad... there are so many better ways they could have dealt with the pregnancy

Reviews for Adrift and Lifeline:

http://scifi.about.com/od/stargate/a/sga_s4premiere.htm

I haven't caught up with all the posts, so someone may have already put up this link, but it does show reviewers have the same problems with the "new, improved" SGA that we have.

cool thanks!

Do we have this song on our CD's?

Dazed & Confused by Led Zeppelin

LOL good one!

and McBarr can i get a recap off both discs? i want to make them later

oh and thanks Tame you're a good egg

[Vale_Sg1]

I'm one who doesn't really want the show to die, but I vent in the anti-thread because there have been too many changes and it isn't the show I used to know. If Weir had been "changed" but stayed a reg, that would have been great, even with Carter coming in as recurring. Beckett never should have been touched at all. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the character and no need to "stir things up".

I absolutely agree. I don't have anything about Carter per se, even if my interest for the character had kind of faded after S7 of SG1, but I wouldn't have minded to see her as a ship commander. As a matter of fact, I would have been pleased to see some reminder of SG1 in SGA. A reminder, not SG1 taking over the whole bloody show.

I see posters in JM's blog raving about Carter, and they want more of Dr. Lee (who would just take away from Zelenka), and "when is Daniel and/or Jack coming to SGA?" Ugh. Maybe TPTB should have just cancelled SGA and kept SG1 around.

*sighs* JM doesn't realize that trading the old SGA fans with "imported" SG1 fans is not the bargain of the century. I used to have such people on my LJ f-list, and I had to cringe when all of a sudden SGA (which they weren't so enthusiastic about before) became their show and meta posts and reviews started to appear on their LJs. Most of the times including misspelled actor / character names.

[mcbarr]

and McBarr can i get a recap off both discs? i want to make them later

The Stinky Sock Mix - Volume 1

1. Queen - Another One Bites The Dust
2. KC & The Sunshine Band - Shake Your Booty
3. Twisted Sisters - We're Not Gonna Take It
4. Village People - YMCA
5. Europe - The Final Countdown
6. U2 - Sunday Bloody Sunday
7. The Who - Won't Get Fooled Again
8. REM - It's The End Of The World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine)
9. Tina Turner - We Don't Need Another Hero
10. Harvey Danger - Flagpole Sitta
11. Kaiser Chiefs - Every Day I Love You Less And Less
12. Electrasy- Cosmic Castaway
13. The Offspring - Why Don't You Get A Job
14. Pink Floyd - Another Brick In The Wall
15. Metallica - King Nothing
16. Sinead O'Connor - Fire On Babylon
17. The Cranberries - Zombie
18. Scissor Sisters - I Don't Feel Like Dancing
19. Bee Gees - Stayin' Alive
20. Within Temptation - What Have You Done

The Stinky Sock Mix - Volume 2

1. Queen - We Will Rock You
2. AC/DC - Highway To Hell
3. Chris Rea - The Road To Hell
4. Eric Clapton - I Shot The Sheriff
5. Toby Keith & Willie Nelson - Beer For My Horses
6. Avril Lavigne - Spongebob Squarepants Theme
7. Bruce Springsteen - Murder Incorporated
8. Offspring - Pretty Fly For A White Guy
9. Guns N' Roses - Civil War
10. BTO - You Ain't Seen Nothing Yet
11. Styx - Renegade
12. Soundgarden - Fell On Black Days
13. The Beatles - Yesterday
14. Talking Heads - Road To Nowhere
15. Radiohead - Creep
16. Shades Apart - Know It All
17. Three Days Grace - I Hate Everything About You
18. Men At Work - It's A Mistake
19. Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
20. Led Zeppelin - Dazed And Confused

Anti-Album #2 finished.

[Suzotchka]

See, for me, as an SG-1 fan - I felt like S9 & S10 weren't really written for the SG-1 fans. I felt those seasons were horrible. And now as an SGA fan, I feel like S4 isn't being written for the SGA fan.

[mcbarr]

See, for me, as an SG-1 fan - I felt like S9 & S10 weren't really written for the SG-1 fans. I felt those seasons were horrible. And now as an SGA fan, I feel like S4 isn't being written for the SGA fan.

That's because TPTB think Stargate fans will accept any-thing written by them. The declining SG-1/SGA ratings keep proving them wrong, though.

[Suzotchka]

That's because TPTB think Stargate fans will accept any-thing written by them. The declining SG-1/SGA ratings keep proving them wrong, though.

Who has that picture of the cart with "Stargate" name on it? You know the one I'm talking about???

[Suzotchka]

This is what happens when a bad mood turns into a bad joke. Inspired by Suz's post above.

Forget it - I found it!

[Vale_Sg1]

Forget it - I found it!

Dear God, this was one of my favorites when I was a lurker!!! I almost registered that day just to comment on it!!!

[mcbarr]

This is what happens when a bad mood turns into a bad joke. Inspired by Suz's post above.

Forget it - I found it!

FH kicks butt!

[dana]

Hi guys, *delurks*
Anuna told me to post it, so I'm posting it. New song to the anti-mix.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=nHM5Eb99vy4

Lyrics:

Spoiler:

Special
You think you're special
You do
I can see it in your eyes
I can see it when you laugh at me
Look down on me
You walk around on me
Just one more fight
About your leadership
And I will straight up
Leave your ****
Cause I've had enough of this
And now I'm pissed

Yeah
This time I'm 'a let it all come out
This time I'm 'a stand up and shout
I'm 'a do things my way
It's my way
My way, or the highway

Check out, check check... out my melody

Just one more fight
About a lot of things
And I will give up everything
To be on my own again
Free again

Yeah

This time I'm 'a let it all come out
This time I'm 'a stand up and shout
I'm 'a do things my way

It's my way
My way, or the highway

Some day you'll see things my way
Cause you never know
No, you never know
When you gonna go

Check out, check check... out my melody

Just one more fight
And I'll be history
Yes I will straight up
Leave your ****
And you'll be the one who's left
Missing me

Yeah

This time I'm 'a let it all come out
This time I'm 'a stand up and shout
I'm 'a do things my way
It's my way
My way, or the highway

Some day you'll see things my way
Cause you never know
Where, you never know
When you gonna go


Some day you'll see things my way
Cause you never know
where, you never know..

[PG15]

I used to love that song.

[dana]

I used to love that song.

Me too...I first heard it in primary school. Is that song that old already?