Originally posted by Linzi
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
John Sheppard Whump
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Alipeeps View PostOh I know what you mean - and it would be the same if it were any character (apart from Sheppy of course, I could live with an ep almost entirely focused on Shep! )
As much as I do enjoy the other characters on SGA, I am not interested enough in them to enjoy an episode that focuses greatly on them to the exclusion of others; even McKay, who is probably my 2nd fave. I mean, I really did enjoy GUP and liked the episode (and very much liked Sheppy's moments in it) but I did miss the rest of the cast and the interaction etc... part of what I enjoy about the characters is how they interact with each other.
All the scifi mags I've read have rated the first half of season 3 very differently. Some have adored CG, only one reviewer disliked it. One reviewer found Sateda boring!!!! Well, I obviously disagree with both of those reviewers! It's really strange how different people's opinions are. I think CG is probably the most generally popular episode of Season 3, judging from polls and friend's opinions. But, who knows?sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by Gate Geek View PostGood afternoon whumpers!!
SQUEE!!! Josie's back!! I really missed ya girl! Hey, I like the avatar. Very cool!!!
So, what did I miss? I saw lots of spoler tags so you all must be excited about something....
Glad you like the av, it's a crop of a 120x120 piece of pixel art avatar, I'm kind of proud of it as it's the first piece of pixel art I've done that I really like, I'm already working on a design for an animated Christmas av because it's going to to take me that long to get it right.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Linzi View PostAgreed! I like them all interacting together. With loads of Sheppard/McKay banter and excessive Sheppy whump!!!
All the scifi mags I've read have rated the first half of season 3 very differently. Some have adored CG, only one reviewer disliked it. One reviewer found Sateda boring!!!! Well, I obviously disagree with both of those reviewers! It's really strange how different people's opinions are. I think CG is probably the most generally popular episode of Season 3, judging from polls and friend's opinions. But, who knows?
Joe said his fave eps were CG and Phantoms so maybe he's becoming more comfortable with the whump!!! And he also said the writers blew it in season 2 with the Shep/McKay stuff so they're back to writing it in and he thinks season 3 is the best yet. So maybe he's coming around to the whumpers' side!
Comment
-
Originally posted by Josie View PostWe were discussing episodes that had already aired mostly as I've only just caught up.
Glad you like the av, it's a crop of a 120x120 piece of pixel art avatar, I'm kind of proud of it as it's the first piece of pixel art I've done that I really like, I'm already working on a design for an animated Christmas av because it's going to to take me that long to get it right.
sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by Salty View PostJoe said his fave eps were CG and Phantoms so maybe he's becoming more comfortable with the whump!!! And he also said the writers blew it in season 2 with the Shep/McKay stuff so they're back to writing it in and he thinks season 3 is the best yet. So maybe he's coming around to the whumpers' side!
Him coming around to the whumper's side...that will be the day *lol*
Comment
Comment