Creepiest Supernatural Episode Game

[Madwelshboy]

Bloody Mary (18) -

Scarecrow (18)

Provenance (17) +

Family Remains (12)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

No Exit (4)

Metamorphosis (2)

Playthings (1)


12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[the fifth man]

Bloody Mary (18)

Scarecrow (18)

Provenance (16) -

Family Remains (13) +

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

No Exit (4)

Metamorphosis (2)

Playthings (1)


12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Bloody Mary (18)

Scarecrow (18)

Provenance (17) +

Family Remains (13) +

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4) -

No Exit (4)

Metamorphosis (2)

Playthings (1)


12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Madwelshboy]

Scarecrow (19) +

Bloody Mary (17) -

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13) +

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4) -

No Exit (4)

Metamorphosis (2)

Playthings (1)


12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Jenova Synthesis]

Scarecrow (20) +

Bloody Mary (17)

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (4)

Metamorphosis (2)

Playthings (0) -


11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Boo]

Scarecrow (20)

Bloody Mary (18) +

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (3) -

Metamorphosis (2)

11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[queen_hathor]

Scarecrow (19) -

Bloody Mary (18)

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (7) +

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (3)

Metamorphosis (2)

11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Uh Queen, you're supposed to give one point and take one from another ep. You've lowered both. Could you please fix that? Thanks! And I'd like to ask everybody else to wait with further posts until this is resolved. Thanks as well!

[queen_hathor]

Should be OK now... not with it, sorry

[Andron]

Scarecrow (19)

Bloody Mary (19) +

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Asylum (7)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (2) -

Metamorphosis (2)

11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[LoneStar1836]

Scarecrow (20) +

Bloody Mary (19)

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (13)

Asylum (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (2)

Metamorphosis (1)-


11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[the fifth man]

Scarecrow (20)

Bloody Mary (19)

Provenance (16) -

Family Remains (14) +

Asylum (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (4)

No Exit (2)

Metamorphosis (1)


11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

[QUOTE=the fifth man;10530624]Scarecrow (20)

Bloody Mary (19)

Provenance (17) +

Family Remains (14)

Asylum (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (3) -

No Exit (2)

Metamorphosis (1)


11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Madwelshboy]

Scarecrow (21) +

Bloody Mary (18) -

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (14)

Asylum (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (3) -

No Exit (2)

Metamorphosis (1)


11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Jenova Synthesis]

Scarecrow (21)

Bloody Mary (18)

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (15) +

Asylum (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (3)

No Exit (2)

Metamorphosis (0) -


10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues