Creepiest Supernatural Episode Game

[Boo]

Bloody Mary (9) +

Provenance (7)

Scarecrow (7)

Family Remains (6)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Red Sky at Morning (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Metamorphosis (4)

Time is on My Side (4)

It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (4)

Long Distance Call (3) -


19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Bloody Mary (9)

Provenance (8) +

Scarecrow (7)

Family Remains (6)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Red Sky at Morning (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Metamorphosis (4)

Time is on My Side (4)

It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (4)

Long Distance Call (2) -


19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

I really must have been spaced out when I set this up, I could have sworn I listed 20 episodes...

[Andron]

Bloody Mary (10) +

Provenance (8)

Scarecrow (7)

Family Remains (6)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Red Sky at Morning (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Time is on My Side (4)

It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (4)

Metamorphosis (3) -

Long Distance Call (2)


19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[LoneStar1836]

Bloody Mary (10)

Provenance (8)

Scarecrow (8)+

Family Remains (6)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Red Sky at Morning (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Time is on My Side (4)

It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (3)-

Metamorphosis (3)

Long Distance Call (2)


19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Betelgeuze]

Bloody Mary (10)

Provenance (9)+

Scarecrow (8)

Family Remains (6)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Red Sky at Morning (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Time is on My Side (4)

Metamorphosis (3)

Long Distance Call (2)

It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (2)-

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[the fifth man]

Bloody Mary (10)
Provenance (9)
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7) +
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Red Sky at Morning (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Time is on My Side (3) -
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (2)
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (2)

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Bloody Mary (10)
Provenance (10) +
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4) -
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (2)
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (2)

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Betelgeuze]

Bloody Mary (10)
Provenance (11) +
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (2)
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (1)-

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[MrsB108]

Bloody Mary (10)
Provenance (10) -
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (3)+
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (1)

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Andron]

Bloody Mary (11) +
Provenance (10)
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (2) -
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (1)

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Boo]

Bloody Mary (12) +
Provenance (10)
Scarecrow (8)
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (1) -
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (1)

19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[LoneStar1836]

Bloody Mary (12)
Provenance (10)
Scarecrow (9)+
Family Remains (7)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Time is on My Side (3)
Metamorphosis (3)
Long Distance Call (1)
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester (0)-

18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Jenova Synthesis]

Bloody Mary (12)

Provenance (10)

Scarecrow (10) +

Family Remains (7)

The Kids are Alright (6)

Wendigo (5)

Dead in the Water (5)

Hookman (5)

Asylum (5)

Something Wicked (5)

No Exit (5)

Playthings (5)

Jump the Shark (5)

Red Sky at Morning (4)

Time is on My Side (3)

Metamorphosis (3)

Long Distance Call (0) -


17th place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[the fifth man]

Bloody Mary (12)
Provenance (10)
Scarecrow (10)
Family Remains (8) +
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (5)
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Metamorphosis (3)
Time is on My Side (2) -

17th place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Betelgeuze]

Bloody Mary (12)
Provenance (11)+
Scarecrow (10)
Family Remains (8)
The Kids are Alright (6)
Wendigo (5)
Dead in the Water (5)
Hookman (5)
Asylum (5)
Something Wicked (5)
No Exit (5)
Playthings (5)
Jump the Shark (4)-
Red Sky at Morning (4)
Metamorphosis (3)
Time is on My Side (2)

17th place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues