Speculation about the planet. Who made it, will they return.

[Sami_]

Anyway an Earth like planet is a fluke of nature. Being placed in the green zone, the size/gravity, the pivot (for seasons) is really a fluke of nature. Aliens probably meddled with our own Earth. A whole different debate.

So many people go with this line of reasoning when trying to convince others of divine/alien intervention to explain the earths creation. The simple truth is that if the earth wasn't in the green zone, if it had a different size/gravity/pivot then life would have evolved completely differently.

The conditions needed for life as we know it are rare but I'd hardly call it a fluke of nature.

[thekillman]

if our planet wasnt this way we wouldn't be around to observe that.

From current planet forming theory it has to start as a big fireball to melt the materials down to their atoms so that the Iron sinks into the center to form the core. And I'm no expert, so when the SGU reference was made regarding a ball of molten rock, I don't know if the core has been form yet or not. If the core has not been formed yet then it needs to stay hot to be able to form.

But yeah, pulling in comets and astroids to cool the planet surface or layer on materials for life is pretty smart. Anyway an Earth like planet is a fluke of nature. Being placed in the green zone, the size/gravity, the pivot (for seasons) is really a fluke of nature. Aliens probably meddled with our own Earth. A whole different debate.

earth's core is still largely molten. and besides, our planet was entirely molten, which means it was several thousand degrees here. if you want a useful planet, you'd want the inner and outer core to be liquid resp. solid, then you'd need a mantle and a crust. but you don't need a fully molten planet for a core to form, and besides, if the aliens wanted to make one fast, they'd hyperspace the heaviest asteroids into place first.

[kymeric]

Unlikely to happenn but imagine if the obelisk has a time dilation device in it, those 11 people they left behind would become an village or a town with a much larger population if they bump into it again
They did say in the show that the planet is suppose to be a molten rock for it's age, I'm guess one possibility is someone sped up the planet's development through time dilation.

11 people isnt enough for a gene pool. They would be all retarded within 3 generations, then dead from awful cancers with 4-6 generations.

[ukguy30]

well guys come on all this speculation's and none of u have evan come close to a good specultion apart from one or two first the anceint did not have the technology to create planets stars and the nox have not left the milky way, there are only two possablieitys.
one the asgard would have the power but for the last 30,000 years they've focused all there knowlege on the cloning problems, the ancients died out/ acended , the nox still live simple.

however it is poss that the furlings (who have not yet been seen) may have built it if u think about it they meet the ancients and became one of the four races then they all split up and whent different paths.

could the furlings have done what the ancients did and traveled to other galaxies (it is the logical thing once humans have mapped the milky way we will then go on to to the rest of the 30 galaxies in the local cluster) so the furlings could have gone to that galaxy after the gate seeding ships left and made the planet and star.

Now the only other possability is a new Race far older and more powerfull (and not the aliens u've seen already in SGU) these aliens would have a great respect for our team but veiw them like the asgard veiwed humans originally.

now my ideas do have a good sound base