Lt. Matthew Scott /Brian.J.Smith Thunk/Discussion/Appreciation

[Madwelshboy]

Not obsessed.. Dedicated!

Heehee, exactly!

Somethings going on here!

[Atlantean2005]

Somethings going on here!

NO idea whatsoever as to what you may be referring to!

[Mr.MacGadget]

Somethings going on here!

Hmmm... yeah... what??? LOL

NO idea whatsoever as to what you may be referring to!

Exactly #2!

LOL

[Madwelshboy]

NO idea whatsoever as to what you may be referring to!

Hmmm... yeah... what??? LOL



Exactly #2!

LOL

You know what im talking about

[Mr.MacGadget]

You know what im talking about

I guess you do know that none of us gonna say anything about this, right? ... Whatever you talking about of course

[Madwelshboy]

I guess you do know that none of us gonna say anything about this, right? ... Whatever you talking about of course

Well i'd hope not!

[Mr.MacGadget]

Well i'd hope not!

Then why did you start it, Mad Boy?? LOL

[Mr.MacGadget]

Spoiler:

[Atlantean2005]

Yeah, Mad, you started it!!

[Mr.MacGadget]

Yeah, Mad, you started it!!

Exactly #3... Yeah I know, my 'Exactly' is probably boring by now ... It is for me.

Spoiler:

[Mr.MacGadget]

Spoiler:

[Pandora's_Box]

Dramatic + Character driven = Bring in the sex scenes?

Maybe in this case it does. Dramas often delve into human emotion and interactions. Character-driven pieces very often explore relationships, romantic and otherwise, and where there's romance there's sex. Hell, there doesn't even need to be romance; just two consenting adults with some sort of connection.

And I turn that question back to you: Really? Are they in high school? As soon as they get bored, they shirk their duties and have sex in supply closets?

Oh, I'm pretty sure you don't have to be a high schooler to shirk duties for sex in supply closets. In fact, I'm pretty sure there are less high schoolers than adults doing that exact thing.

An unfortunate choice, IMO.

Mileage varies.

And I question the wisdom in this move. Edgier = More sex scenes?

For some.

Look, it's not to everyone's tastes and that's fine. I may think it's funny that there's such a big deal being made over this 15-30 second sex scene when a whole lot more morally reprehensible things have happened on SG-1 and SGA with hardly a whimper being heard from the fanbase. Even SGU dealt with an interesting moral dilemma early on and I've yet to hear anyone comment on it or question the writers' decisions or even discuss the matter.

So we can debate this 'till we're both blue in the face, but I doubt we'll ever come to a consensus. I'm convinced that on a dramatic, science fiction television, the occasional sex scene is not out place. I'm not looking for this to become light pornography, but neither am I interested in some unrealistic portrayal of adult relationships where all these people do is "make out."

You didn't like it and don't agree with it shown. That's your prerogative and I respect that.

Now is it possible to discuss something other than sex?

[Mr.MacGadget]

Spoiler:

[Mr.MacGadget]

Spoiler:

[Mr.MacGadget]

Spoiler: