SG-1: Season 10 Tournament

[Ladyinred]

The Pegasus Project

In case you didn't notice, this episode didn't make it to the last round

[Ladyinred]

Hard decision, but I guess it's gonna be:

Unending

[dipsofjazz]

The Quest, Part 2

[poundpuppy29]

The Quest Part 2
This was hard because I loved Unending but the Quest Part 2 is more important to the movies

[marbleC]

The Quest, Part 2

[LoneStar1836]

Well that's an easy choice....

The Quest, Part 2

...ftw.

[Anubis69]

Quest part 2.

ALWAYS!

[jz9]

In case you didn't notice, this episode didn't make it to the last round

Thanks!


Unending

[Celsius]

Quest, part 2

[Naonak]

Unending

[Ronja]

The Quest II to WIN!

[Stef]

And the winner is.......wait for it........wait for it........

The Quest, Part 2

Final Results:
The Quest, Part 2 -- 15
Unending -- 5

Thanks to everyone who played!

FINAL RANKINGS:

1st Place: The Quest, Part 2
2nd Place: Unending
3rd Place: The Pegasus Project
4th Place: The Shroud
5th Place: Memento Mori
6th Place: Line In the Sand
7th Place: Dominion
8th Place: 200
9th Place: Flesh & Blood
10th Place: Bad Guys
11th Place: The Quest, Part 1
12th Place: Counterstrike
13th Place: The Road Not Taken
14th Place: Company of Thieves
15th Place: Morpheus
16th Place: Insiders
17th Place: Talion
18th Place: Uninvited
19th Place: Bounty
20th Place: Family Ties

And like I did for S9, I'm opening up the floor for people to post their own S10 rankings Would you have chosen a different winner?

-Stef

[the fifth man]

Great tournament everyone. I'm relatively happy with the winner being The Quest, Part 2.

One change for sure though - Talion would have ranked much higher than it did.

[nebulan]

Cool, that was fun! What's next?

Hmm....

1st: 200!
2nd: Dominion
3rd: The Quest, Part 1
4th: The Shroud
5th: Line In the Sand
6th: Bad Guys
7th: Uninvited
8th: Insiders
9th: Pegasus Project
10th: Bounty
11th: Quest 2
12th: Flesh & Blood
13th: Counterstrike
14th: Road not taken
15th: Momento Mori
16th: Unending
17th: Company of Thieves
18th: Family Ties
19th: Morpheus
20th: Talion (gah! sorry the fifth man, I thought it was a horrible regression for teal'c )

[Stef]

You know, while I have Talion listed as pretty low, I don't dislike the episode. It's just that I'm not a huge Teal'c fan so his stories are naturally lower ranking then say ones about Vala or Cam or Daniel. But I think it's my favorite Teal'c-centric episode...and I for one kind of liked the violence of it. It was very un-SG-1 like.

Here are my rankings...some correspond to the tournaments results...others, not so much (see: Uninvited)

1. Memento Mori
2. Bad Guys
3. The Quest, Pt.2
4. 200
5. Line in the Sand
6. Dominion
7. Unending
8. Flesh & Blood
9. Uninvited
10. The Shroud
11. Morpheus
(It wins points mostly for the Vala stuff)
12. Bounty
13. Insiders
14. Counterstrike
(I always forget this one )
15. The Pegasus Project
(A technically strong episode but it never really does anything for me)
16. The Quest, Pt. 1
(I have SERIOUS issues with Vala in this episode)
17. Talion
18. Company of Thieves
19. The Road Not Taken
(To me, this is the one episode that was a let-down not because of the writing or acting, but because of the idea. One of the great things about SF is that it takes RL issues and takes them out of the RL contexts...but this episode didn't do that - it just felt like any other show trying to make a political statement )
20. Family Ties
(Just a complete waste of a Vala backstory...it had so many individual scenes that I liked...but it was a completely disappointing whole)

-Stef