worst season 5 SGA episode

[Ikaros]

"Whispers" was the worst sga season 5 episode and one of the show's worst.
I really can't decide if it's "Whispers" or "Iressistable" the worst episode EVER.

[nx01a]

Lucius wins [or loses] hands down as the worst ever episode. Teyla and Elizabeth and every woman on Atlantis [not to mention Carson] effectively date raped? Sad.

[Ikaros]

sory , but i mised the "rape" part, or i don't rememper it....
Unless you mean the "would you be my wife?" part. That's hardly a rape.
But it was a rediculus episode.

[nx01a]

I mean the effect of the drug, how they were all over him. The 'date' rape' allusion was brought up elsewhere discussing the episode re: his 'wives' and the nonconsent aspect of the drug's influence on everyone, willing to give him 'everything' he wanted.

[Ikaros]

people have "naughty" minds .....Lucius had one naughty mind to, but nothing was really mentioned.

[nx01a]

When I think 'wives', I think... Ok, back on topic.
Whispers! Worst of the season.

[Mitchell82]

Ah yes, I thought so. I even wanted to add something like that in my post, but the word 'sarcastic' didn't come to my mind. And I was afraid the sentence 'are you serious' could have been a bit ambiguous. It's not so easy in a forum.

You are right. However, I didn't like it. And I really don't know why. No special reason. Just my first feeling. Maybe this is the kind of episode which I'll enjoy when I watch it a few times more. That happens sometimes.

Sometimes that is the case.

[Mitchell82]

Lucius wins [or loses] hands down as the worst ever episode. Teyla and Elizabeth and every woman on Atlantis [not to mention Carson] effectively date raped? Sad.

Oh no not this argument again.

Spoiler:

[Orion Antreas]

'Tracker' is definitely first for me. I am sorry, but some reason I fell asleep for the episode. I remember commenting in the 'Tracker' General Discussion thread about it. I have never fallen asleep for a Stargate episode. (That includes SG-1 and Atlantis.) Oddly though, I did with 'Tracker.' It couldn't keep me entertained.

It could be though that I was a bit tired that night, but I was tired tonight for 'Vegas,' yet loved it and watched every line of it.

Here's a list of the top 5 for me of Season Five's worst/bad episodes for me. (Worst: Top)

1.) Tracker
2.) Broken Ties
3.) Whispers
4.) The Seed
5.) Brain Storm

[fumblesmcstupid]

The line between date rape and what Lucious did is verrry close, so just cause you don't think that it is not a big deal others do!

[Willow'sCat]

Just remember that is your opinion. Many loved it.

Alright; I used IMHO is that not clear enough for you?!

Also this is a thread to post the worst episode, so seriously why do you feel the need to go about saying why this, that or the other isn't bad in your opinion?

Go start a thread for the best ep if you feel you must only hear good things about SGA. "Cause to me that is how your responses to people's genuine concerns with episodes are coming across, like you are the keeper of all that is correct with SGA, like your opinion is the only one here that matters.

Seriously, go start a shiny happy thread for best eps.

[jelgate]

I might retract my earlier post and say Vegas is the worst of S5

[Ashimjara]

The Seed - due to Keller's unbelievably super quick recovery from the major event that had just happened to her.

Oh and inquisition.

Thankfully I don't think Lucius is in any of series 5, hopefully he won't be in the SGA film either.

[Ikaros]

I'd forgoten about Inquisition ! Bad episode to.

[Pajus]

Worst physics in S5? I haven't seen EatG yet, so the prize (thus far) goes to Brain Storm, followed by First Contact and Whispers