Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[Linda06]

Good luck.

I'll need it...My plans are never successful

[Pegasus_SGA]

S&R, The Queen, The Prodigal, what's the fourth?

I was wondering the same thing. I'd say those were prominant Teyla eps in which she was either the focus in a B or A line story... so 4 down 16 to go. In all the other eps did she play a 'B' role? Possibly BT? The Prodigal however even though Michael was after Teyla for me that was more of a team ep and not Teyla centric.

Keller had minimum roles in those eps.

The Seed? um no she was unconscious for the most part. The Shrine had some interesting Keller moments (obviously the last scene) but also team-Rodney (especially Shep) and of course Jeannie-Rodney. Tracker was a R/K/R ep imo. FC and TLT were team eps + Woosley and Keller. Brain Storm was a McKeller ep. Identity was a Keller ep, I enjoyed the actress who played Neeva

The Seed while a team ep was Keller centric. She was the victim, it was about them saving her so she was the focus, the driving force. Teyla was hardly in that ep at all.

The Shrine was McKay centric, but also Keller centric... her talking to him on the video feed, her caring for him, her liaising with the team, her arguing with the team, her going in the jumper and dealing with the brain scans, the surgery, the watching the video playback. Although a McKay ep, it was predominantly McKay and Keller. Some of the team had some great bits, but sorry this was McKay/Keller.

Tracker. Keller again the victim, Keller again was the main focus of the story. No Teyla.

Identity... Keller/McKay centric

Brainstorm.. Keller/McKay centric

That's 5 eps where Keller is the main focus of an episode or is the victim.

Shep didn't have an ep (yet) but had some great scenes so far imo

Exactly!!!! No Shep ep and we're 18 episodes in, doesn't that seem a bit unjust? 5 eps for Keller and none so far for Shep? it's no wonder i'm not enjoying this season... oops wrong thread. But to keep on topic. Shirtless Shep was priceless.

[Linda06]

I was wondering the same thing. I'd say those were prominant Teyla eps in which she was either the focus in a B or A line story... so 4 down 16 to go. In all the other eps did she play a 'B' role? Possibly BT? The Prodigal however even though Michael was after Teyla for me that was more of a team ep and not Teyla centric.

Keller had minimum roles in those eps.





The Seed while a team ep was Keller centric. She was the victim, it was about them saving her so she was the focus, the driving force. Teyla was hardly in that ep at all.

The Shrine was McKay centric, but also Keller centric... her talking to him on the video feed, her caring for him, her liaising with the team, her arguing with the team, her going in the jumper and dealing with the brain scans, the surgery, the watching the video playback. Although a McKay ep, it was predominantly McKay and Keller. Some of the team had some great bits, but sorry this was McKay/Keller.

Tracker. Keller again the victim, Keller again was the main focus of the story. No Teyla.

Identity... Keller/McKay centric

Brainstorm.. Keller/McKay centric

That's 5 eps where Keller is the main focus of an episode or is the victim.




Exactly!!!! No Shep ep and we're 18 episodes in, doesn't that seem a bit unjust? 5 eps for Keller and none so far for Shep? it's no wonder i'm not enjoying this season... oops wrong thread. But to keep on topic. Shirtless Shep was priceless.

Shep??? Shep???? What is a Shep???

*runs off*

[Pegasus_SGA]

Shep??? Shep???? What is a Shep???

*runs off*

Well I did hear a rumour that he was the lead of some SciFi show, but for the life of me i've not been seeing much of him... I wonder instead of being Mr Fantastic, he's turned into Mr Invisible?

Thing for me is I so want to love this season as it's the last, and I am looking forward to EatG and Vegas. I was hoping Shep would have lots to do in the mid two parter, I really did, but the only thing good in that two parter is the wonderful shirtless sheppy scene. And please Shep and Radek on the Travelers ship he had approximately 3 minutes screen time in that ep, and about 5 minutes in the First contact. Even my beloved remnants there were 3 stories.. oh i'm becoming bitter and twisted.

Bring on the wonderful Vegas *crossed fingers and toes Jonas style*

[Linda06]

Well I did hear a rumour that he was the lead of some SciFi show, but for the life of me i've not been seeing much of him... I wonder instead of being Mr Fantastic, he's turned into Mr Invisible?

Thing for me is I so want to love this season as it's the last, and I am looking forward to EatG and Vegas. I was hoping Shep would have lots to do in the mid two parter, I really did, but the only thing good in that two parter is the wonderful shirtless sheppy scene. And please Shep and Radek on the Travelers ship he had approximately 3 minutes screen time in that ep, and about 5 minutes in the First contact. Even my beloved remnants there were 3 stories.. oh i'm becoming bitter and twisted.

Bring on the wonderful Vegas *crossed fingers and toes Jonas style*

Oh that's funny...Teyla is the invisible woman..>Don't they make a great couple

Ooooohhhhh am I rubbing off on you

[Pegasus_SGA]

Oh that's funny...Teyla is the invisible woman..>Don't they make a great couple

Ooooohhhhh am I rubbing off on you

Noooooooo shipping!!! Lalalalalalalalalalala Nooooooooooooooooooooooo not listening.

[Guest]

I'll need it...My plans are never successful

That you will.

[Jumper_One]

I've been trying to annoy them for the past year and quite frankly I'm better at it then you

ya think?

Maybe so but it was still centred around Keller I'm just using you guys logic

my logic? by that definition TLT was a Rodney and Daniel ep because everybody was trying to rescue them.

I didn't think he done all that much in The Shrine *shrugs(*

visiting the Shrine was his idea

Um I was talking about the eps where they were the focus or had prominant parts in the eps DV was the team together all doing their bit As was outsiders and Infection Identity, well i'm not sure what that was supposed to be

I thought you hadn't watched Identity?

Not in my little world

right

So you agree that Carson should have stayed recurring then You know how much I love Carson but even I have to admit that

absolutely! I also believe Keller should've been a recurring character, I mean Janet wasn't a regular and she was great!

You know I don't whump Shep

you don't? LOL oops

I don't know but I was positive I heard something along those lines

apparently not

Well I don't know how much screentime she's had but it feels like I saw more of her in S4

feels =/= actual screentime

I was wondering the same thing. I'd say those were prominant Teyla eps in which she was either the focus in a B or A line story... so 4 down 16 to go. In all the other eps did she play a 'B' role? Possibly BT? The Prodigal however even though Michael was after Teyla for me that was more of a team ep and not Teyla centric.

Keller had minimum roles in those eps.

Teyla's definitely had a B storyline in BT

The Seed while a team ep was Keller centric. She was the victim, it was about them saving her so she was the focus, the driving force. Teyla was hardly in that ep at all.

as was Keller. you said it yourself, The Seed was a team ep

The Shrine was McKay centric, but also Keller centric... her talking to him on the video feed, her caring for him, her liaising with the team, her arguing with the team, her going in the jumper and dealing with the brain scans, the surgery, the watching the video playback. Although a McKay ep, it was predominantly McKay and Keller. Some of the team had some great bits, but sorry this was McKay/Keller.

nah sorry, no way The Shrine was a McKeller ep. a Rodney ep, yes. Keller was important (not letting them go to the Shrine, performing the surgery, watching the vid) but that's it. what about Rodney's scenes with Jeannie and Shep, the discussion in Woolsey's office etc?

Tracker. Keller again the victim, Keller again was the main focus of the story. No Teyla.

the love triangle was the main focus of Tracker imo

Identity... Keller/McKay centric

maybe a little, definitely Keller centric

Brainstorm.. Keller/McKay centric


That's 5 eps where Keller is the main focus of an episode or is the victim.[/B]

yup

Exactly!!!! No Shep ep and we're 18 episodes in, doesn't that seem a bit unjust? 5 eps for Keller and none so far for Shep? it's no wonder i'm not enjoying this season... oops wrong thread. But to keep on topic. Shirtless Shep was priceless.

agreed, we need a Shep centric ep

[Linda06]

Noooooooo shipping!!! Lalalalalalalalalalala Nooooooooooooooooooooooo not listening.

*in a very bad singing voice* JOHN AND TEYLA SITTING IN A TREE...K.I.S.S.I.N.G.....

hehe

[Linda06]

I thought you hadn't watched Identity?

I watched it last night....I really wish I hadn't

right

I love my little denial bubble

absolutely! I also believe Keller should've been a recurring character, I mean Janet wasn't a regular and she was great!

*bows to the legend that is Janet*

you don't? LOL oops

No, I whump Teyla and then Shep's all angsty and then he can comfort her

apparently not

huh....I'm almost positive it wasn't a dream

feels =/= actual screentime

Well i'm a very sensitive creature ya know

as was Keller. you said it yourself, The Seed was a team ep

That Keller was the focus off

nah sorry, no way The Shrine was a McKeller ep. a Rodney ep, yes. Keller was important (not letting them go to the Shrine, performing the surgery, watching the vid) but that's it. what about Rodney's scenes with Jeannie and Shep, the discussion in Woolsey's office etc?

The shrine was a Rodney/Keller ep with McKeller in there too The others had supporting roles

the love triangle was the main focus of Tracker imo

With alot of the focus on Keller kidnapped in the woods again!

[Guest]

Who's strangling a cat?

*in a very bad singing voice* JOHN JENNIFER AND TEYLA SITTING IN A TREE...K.I.S.S.I.N.G.....

hehe

That's better.

They make a cute couple.

[jelgate]

*in a very bad singing voice* JOHN AND TEYLA SITTING IN A TREE...K.I.S.S.I.N.G.....hehe

Long live Cloneller

[Pandora's_Box]

So............

After the huge misstep (in my opinion) that was Identity, can Vegas and Enemy at the Gate live up to expectations?

[Linda06]

Who's strangling a cat?





That's better.

They make a cute couple.

Oh Peg is gonna hurt you real bad

Long live Cloneller

[jelgate]

So............After the huge misstep (in my opinion) that was Identity, can Vegas and Enemy at the Gate live up to expectations?

Vegas No
Enemey at the Gate Yes