Creepiest Supernatural Episode Game

[the fifth man]

Scarecrow (41) -

Bloody Mary (36)

Provenance (15)

Family Remains (2) +


5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Scarecrow (41)

Bloody Mary (36)

Provenance (16) +

Family Remains (1) -


5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Betelgeuze]

Scarecrow (40)-

Bloody Mary (36)

Provenance (17) +

Family Remains (1)


5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Jenova Synthesis]

Scarecrow (41) +

Bloody Mary (36)

Provenance (17)

Family Remains (0) -


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Boo]

Scarecrow (41)

Bloody Mary (37) +

Provenance (16) -


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Madwelshboy]

Scarecrow (42) +

Bloody Mary (36) -

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Andron]

Scarecrow (41) -

Bloody Mary (37) +

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[LoneStar1836]

Scarecrow (42) +

Bloody Mary (36) -

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[the fifth man]

Scarecrow (43) +

Bloody Mary (36)

Provenance (15) -


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[starg8fans]

Scarecrow (43)

Bloody Mary (35) -

Provenance (16) +


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Madwelshboy]

Scarecrow (44) +

Bloody Mary (34) -

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Andron]

Scarecrow (43) -

Bloody Mary (35) +

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Betelgeuze]

Scarecrow (42) -

Bloody Mary (35)

Provenance (17)+


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[Boo]

Scarecrow (42)

Bloody Mary (36) +

Provenance (16) -


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues

[LoneStar1836]

Scarecrow (43)+

Bloody Mary (35) -

Provenance (16)


4th Place - Family Remains
5th Place - The Kids are Alright
6th Place - Asylum
7th Place - Wendigo
8th Place - Dead in the Water
9th Place - No Exit
10th Place - Metamorphosis
11th Place - Playthings
12th Place - Hookman
13th Place - Something Wicked
14th Place - Jump the Shark
15th Place - Red Sky at Morning
16th Place - Time is on My Side
17th Place - Long Distance Call
18th Place - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
19th Place - Folsom Prison Blues