VOTE! How would you rate 'Visitation?'

[Dii-Reno]

I gave it an 8 because it did keep me interested. I also enjoyed seeing the hydroponics bay operational. I've been waiting to see that for several weeks now. It still left the nebula dream and the baby up in the air. I don't see how the writers are going to explain it now that there's proof everyone on Eden was starving and suffering from hypothermia when the LA was attacking.

[thekillman]

a 7.

i reserve 8 for very good episodes, and 9's for extremely good episodes. there are only a handful of episodes in SG total that IMO deserve a 10. and SGU's got none.

10's: Fifth Race, Full Circle, WOO, Lost City, Heroes, Rising, The Siege.


SGU IMO deserves a 9 for Time and Space

[icsteffi]

8. Definitely not one that any newcomer would be interested in. Would have been a 7 if not for T.J.'s awesome performance.

Spoiler:

Broke my heart too to not see a baby in one of their arms.

[Old Dood]

Hmmm...It will not let me vote. ???

Anyways I believe this episode will 'Get Better' down the road.
It is set up to pave a way for a new 'Arc' that will add to the story.

Some episodes are not as exciting as others but I have not found a 'Bad Episode' yet...
I truly enjoy this show.

[mi_guard]

7
There are things I definitely loved, but overall it wasn't one of my favorites of the season thus far. Chloe/Greer stuff was awesome though.

I can second this. Gave a 7.

[garhkal]

I give it a 7. It was interesting but definitely not very exciting.

A 6 or 7. I'm leaning more towards 7.

I am leaning more to the 6 side.. but otherwise i agree.. No where as interesting or suspenseful as the prior 3 eps..

[Oreol]

Just above average for me. I love no-earth-episodes, but this one simply cannot be compared to the three stellar eps that preceded it. Also it's obvious they were saving bucks for the next ep, promised to be a visual effects extravaganza.

[Pharaoh Atem]

will no 0's so that's goodf

[Benr96]

it was good , it had good acting, the story was good, it set up for a later episode, but it wasn't the most exciting and i would of like to see a few more guns , we cant forget its still basically a military base.i rated 9/10

[Benr96]

I am leaning more to the 6 side.. but otherwise i agree.. No where as interesting or suspenseful as the prior 3 eps..

you shouldn't rate it on comparison to the other eps rate it by itself (i'm noty saying thats what you did but it sound kind of like you did)

[YoshiKart64]

I gave it an 8. Ultimately I really liked the mystery that went through the episode - how are these people here? Are they really the people we left behind? Did the alien race help them and is it even capable of that?

It was a good solid mystery. What I didn't like was the Chloe and Matt scenes. Chloe just isn't all that interesting and I'm honestly starting to think that the acting isn't so good there.

What I did like - The crew working together with a little bit of humour. I didn't think this was needed before but it certainly adds a lot to the show, so count me wrong there. I also loved the Greer development, he stole every scene he was in.


Basically I thought this continued the streak of great episodes that started with Trial and Error; the show is really firing on all cylinders now and I can't wait for the mid-season finale. I just have to hope it gets renewed (crosses fingers).

[Ashizuri]

I gave it a 7.

I liked it, and it was hilarious at times, but I would have liked to see more build-up of the people dying (and more variations than one girl smashed by a tree and the rest exposure) and the crew not being able to figure it out. I think it was the closest I'll ever get to stargate horror so I wanted a bit more out of it.

The B side was probably the best use of Chloe in a LONG time. I'm really beginning to think that Chloe, as a character, has just been paired up with the wrong players so far. I say less scenes with BJS and more with JWS.

I second this!

[kitkat3ny]

10

[shantar]

I'd give it a nine. I thought this episdoe packed an emotional punch (TJ/baby and Chloe's transformation) and really liked the interaction between Scott/Greer/Chloe. After the first viewing, I immediately re-watched several of the scenes -- the first time I have done that this season.

[RamblerReb]

Poor. Started off with a fairly interesting premise, wound up a crashing bore with no payoff.