'Incursion, Part 1' (119) General Discussion

[MattSilver 3k]

Ellie's still around lads, let's not get comfortable with a Young-loving utopia.

United we stand!

[xxxevilgrinxxx]

Ellie's still around lads, let's not get comfortable with a Young-loving utopia.

United we stand!

I think Ellie protests too much. I smell secret Young-lust in the air

[MattSilver 3k]

I think Ellie protests too much. I smell secret Young-lust in the air

Oh God I hope not. I like some enemies opponents to be clear-cut evil, you know, like zombies. Ellie is a zombie. A zombie we keep chained to her room for a while because we don't want to put her out of her misery. 'Cause we care.

[jelgate]

Young is damed if he does and damned if he doesn't because he makes thos decision where both outcomes are quesstionable but they still have to be made

[xxxevilgrinxxx]

Young is damed if he does and damned if he doesn't because he makes thos decision where both outcomes are quesstionable but they still have to be made

I've run out of green, but I'd green you for that
I think most leaders have to face the same sort of thing; they're not going to please everyone, especially when things are tough

[MattSilver 3k]

Except if they're Rush. Ellie would like him tough.

Oh God I'm an awful person.

[Kaiphantom]

Young is damed if he does and damned if he doesn't because he makes thos decision where both outcomes are quesstionable but they still have to be made

No, don't. Just... don't. No matter how many times you repeat this, it is simply not true. If Young had vented the atmosphere and killed Telford, no one would be "damning him." Well, maybe one or two, but the vast majority would agree he did what he had to.

So please stop.

[xxxevilgrinxxx]

No, don't. Just... don't. No matter how many times you repeat this, it is simply not true. If Young had vented the atmosphere and killed Telford, no one would be "damning him." Well, maybe one or two, but the vast majority would agree he did what he had to.

So please stop.

except that we've already seen that trying to erase Telford's brainwashing resulted in a storm of posts about how wrong that was. Add to that that there was no way for Young to know it wasn't Rush he was also killing if he vented the room, so there'd be a big stink there too. So. No, no need to stop. It's a valid point.

[Replicator Todd]

I'm getting to the point to where at least like every character in SGU, with the exception of Camille and Scott, who I dislike....but may be very likely to change. I like Telford now, I really didn't think too much of him for the past 17 episodes. The last episode changed my opinion.

[EllieVee]

glad everyone likes Young again, coz people were really mean to him.

What do you mean 'again'?

[kwlafayette]

Just watching the episode again. What happened to Eli's radio? Did he not take it with him when he an Chloe ran away? Seems like something you would want to have with you. If he does have it, is Destiny big enough to get out of radio range?

[Duneknight]

i just watched it again as well, i liked the scene when LA first pop outta the gate. best scene probably was the argument between Rush and Young. btw am i the only one who finds Kiva being the subtlest villain to appear in stargate? shes not eccentric at all. was she done that way to contrast Rush?

[Kayzersoze]

Man ... people sure are spending a lot of time picking at plot holes.

Somebody find me a movie or TV show without plot holes. Something with substance I'm talkin ... not 2.5 Men or Lost.

[EllieVee]

Man ... people sure are spending a lot of time picking at plot holes.

Somebody find me a movie or TV show without plot holes. Something with substance I'm talkin ... not 2.5 Men or Lost.

The Usual Suspects, I suggest is a movie without plot holes.

[Lt.Colonel John Sheppard]

OT here but was according to LDP's twitter he's filming Season 2 episodes so which means we'll be seeing Colonel David Telford in season two.