Originally posted by trupi
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Sam Carter/Jack O'Neill Ship Appreciation Thread
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Originally posted by LizloveOK thanks!
Now I think you can have relationships between 2 officers if they don't work for the same people? Right?
So, Jack being head of Homeworld Security is still Sam's superior?
If Sam had to report directly to the President or someone that has nothing to do with HS would that still mean she's in Jack's direct chain of command and can't have a relationship with him?
You following?
Sam -> Landry -> Hammond -> President Hayes
instead of
Sam -> Landry -> Jack -> Hammond -> President Hayes
or whatever it is now, the regs wouldn't apply?
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
-
Originally posted by trupiWell just checked British airways. Round trip for me and my husband is 2900 US. One flight goes to London and then we fly the rest to Bristol which gets in at 2pm Friday. We still would have to take a cab ride to Wells(hour +). Then the hotels would cost around 160 US per night. Didn't check food cost and whatever but I figure all in alll 5000US plus. For 4 days in England (two just for traveling) and for 4 hours with RDA and AT?
Comment
-
Originally posted by shelsfcIt's such a pity that two people in that situation would find it so difficult to have a relationship - I mean, I understand why the regs are there, but it still seems unfair. I'd like to think Sam and Jack's years of saving the planet will have bought them some brownie points!
Maybe Sam could have been given a position (Science Officer or something) that would have her reporting directly to Hammond on base and to Jack only when they were offworld and that, provided there were no problems arising from their involvment, they would be able to have a relationship while on the same team.
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
-
Originally posted by ReganXDo you mean that if the chain of command was
Sam -> Landry -> Hammond -> President Hayes
instead of
Sam -> Landry -> Jack -> Hammond -> President Hayes
or whatever it is now, the regs wouldn't apply?
Comment
-
Originally posted by LizloveYeah something like that. Another solution would be that she still had to report to Area 51. But I don't know if Area 51 is part of Jack's job or not.
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
-
Originally posted by ReganXI wonder if an arrangement would have been made, given everything they have done for the planet, if one of them had broached the subject.
Maybe Sam could have been given a position (Science Officer or something) that would have her reporting directly to Hammond on base and to Jack only when they were offworld and that, provided there were no problems arising from their involvment, they would be able to have a relationship while on the same team.
The best is that she would always report to Hammond. But Hammond being a good comanding officer wouldn't let them on the same team. Even if he personally knew there wouldn't be a problem with them on the same team. It would be looked bad upon by the higher ups. And it would be taken as favouritism from those on base.
Comment
-
Originally posted by LizloveHaving her reporting to Jack while off-world wouldn't be a good idea. Their feelings could still come between them if it's a life/death situation.
The best is that she would always report to Hammond. But Hammond being a good comanding officer wouldn't let them on the same team. Even if he personally knew there wouldn't be a problem with them on the same team. It would be looked bad upon by the higher ups. And it would be taken as favouritism from those on base.
Serving on the same team would still be a sticky point, but really the whole team would have been separated long ago in real life because they are all closer than the regs would like. A wary eye would have to be kept on how they were getting on, to make sure that Sam and Jack weren't concentrating on the other's safety at the expense of Daniel and Teal'c's, with the understanding that they would be separated if their relationship began to pose a problem.
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
-
I think that even if they were allowed to persue a relationship, it wouldn't really affect their work on SG-1. Their feelings would still be the same, only now everyone would know about it. They haven't let it get in the way before, and I don't think they would after starting something together.
I just wish they could be together and be happy-no ifs, ands, or buts!
Comment
-
Originally posted by ReganXIt would be impossible for Sam to serve on SG-1 with Jack without having to report to him while offworld, but if Hammond was handling her performance evaluations, any recommendations for commedations, promotions or any reprimands, Jack wouldn't be able favour her or protect her as far as they went.
Serving on the same team would still be a sticky point, but really the whole team would have been separated long ago in real life because they are all closer than the regs would like. A wary eye would have to be kept on how they were getting on, to make sure that Sam and Jack weren't concentrating on the other's safety at the expense of Daniel and Teal'c's, with the understanding that they would be separated if their relationship began to pose a problem.
The only way I could see them together is if one of them retire. Jack could lead the SGC as a civilian but there still would be the whole favouritism by some people. Now if Sam retires I know they wouldn't let her go like that and certainly offer her a job as a scientist maybe the head scientist. And if she's the head scientist then she reports to those at Area 51 anyway. I think.
Of course she wouldn't go off-world anymore.
Comment
-
Originally posted by LizloveThey're close but I think Hammond understands that their closeness helped them a lot. He lets Sam and Jack on the same team because he knows they never acted upon their feelings and never will as long as the regulations would stand.
The only way I could see them together is if one of them retire. Jack could lead the SGC as a civilian but there still would be the whole favouritism by some people. Now if Sam retires I know they wouldn't let her go like that and certainly offer her a job as a scientist maybe the head scientist. And if she's the head scientist then she reports to those at Area 51 anyway. I think.
Of course she wouldn't go off-world anymore.
Even having military Sam on another team mightn't have been a solution - Jack would still have been 2IC of the whole SGC.
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
-
Originally posted by LizloveThey're close but I think Hammond understands that their closeness helped them a lot. He lets Sam and Jack on the same team because he knows they never acted upon their feelings and never will as long as the regulations would stand.
The only way I could see them together is if one of them retire. Jack could lead the SGC as a civilian but there still would be the whole favouritism by some people. Now if Sam retires I know they wouldn't let her go like that and certainly offer her a job as a scientist maybe the head scientist. And if she's the head scientist then she reports to those at Area 51 anyway. I think.
Of course she wouldn't go off-world anymore.
Comment
-
Originally posted by AllGoodThings...I really like this idea! But why couldn’t she go off world anymore? Haven’t other non military scientist been able to go off world when they needed them?
Wow - post number 2,400.
Sig courtesy of RepliCartertje
Comment
Comment