Gateworld Virtual Fleet 4.0 - Discussion thread

[puddlejumperOZ]

Andromeda 4 (DavidT)
Valkyrie 5 (Killman)
Jager 2 (Locutes)
Heroine 5 (PJOZ)
Agean 2 (Immhotep)
CL-318 1 (Guppy)

bradley (1/1), Immhotep (2/2), Fugiman (1/1), RogueRanger (1/1), PJOZ (2/2) Crazy Tom (1/1) Marilynrose (1/1), Thekillman(2/2), locutes (2/2) Davidtourniquet(2/2) Guppy(2/2), Lt. Col. Mcoy (1/1) Princess Awinita(1/1)

Jack is the the last to vote.

[Princess Awinita]

The cruiser/escort ships the ones we were talking about....lots

refresh my memory, isn't that also the ship type we've been debating about over size requirements? also Admiral you never answered my question about the transports, read up about..... 8 posts I just watched that episode on Tudou, Homecoming I think it was.

First Prime (of Anubis): As for the rest of you, you will be publicly executed
Jack: Does it HAVE to be Public?
First Prime: I could kill you now
Jack: Public is fine

Jack is silly on and off camera

[Davidtourniquet]

Andromeda 4 (DavidT)
Valkyrie 5 (Killman)
Jager 2 (Locutes)
Heroine 5 (PJOZ)
Agean 2 (Immhotep)
CL-318 1 (Guppy)

bradley (1/1), Immhotep (2/2), Fugiman (1/1), RogueRanger (1/1), PJOZ (2/2) Crazy Tom (1/1) Marilynrose (1/1), Thekillman(2/2), locutes (2/2) Davidtourniquet(2/2) Guppy(2/2), Lt. Col. Mcoy (1/1) Princess Awinita(1/1)

Jack is the the last to vote. I chnaged mine to 6 but was I counted as voting for my own without my knowing it?

Yes because you are obviously going to vote for your own with one of your votes, that's the whole reason why the submitters have two votes

[puddlejumperOZ]

refresh my memory, isn't that also the ship type we've been debating about over size requirements? also Admiral you never answered my question about the transports, read up about..... 8 posts I just watched that episode on Tudou, Homecoming I think it was.

First Prime (of Anubis): As for the rest of you, you will be publicly executed
Jack: Does it HAVE to be Public?
First Prime: I could kill you now
Jack: Public is fine

Jack is silly on and off camera

I gave the humvee as a size calculation nothing more. By the time era of the fleet the humvee will be replaced

[Princess Awinita]

I gave the humvee as a size calculation nothing more. By the time era of the fleet the humvee will be replaced

That's a bummer, my adopted brother wants to get a Hummer, but not one of the remakes, "the jeeps on steroids" as he calls them.

[puddlejumperOZ]

Yes because you are obviously going to vote for your own with one of your votes, that's the whole reason why the submitters have two votes

I edited it Dave, when I tallied the count. so Jack holds the controlling vote....tension builds What happens if we have a 3 way tie?

[puddlejumperOZ]

That's a bummer, my adopted brother wants to get a Hummer, but not one of the remakes, "the jeeps on steroids" as he calls them.

Plastic crap....any wonder GM sold them to China, it was bringing their reputation down

[Davidtourniquet]

It'll go to a second round, personally I think it should anyway since 14 votes at the moment are in only 3 specs (yes I know mine's one behind, but there are enoug people that want it to win).

[guppy338]

then we pick a non involed party not on this forem to see who is best my opinion

[puddlejumperOZ]

then we pick a non involed party not on this forem to see who is best my opinion

We wait for the last voter and then see what happens after that. Picking a non involved party could be complicated because 1/ you could end up with the "friend" vote or 2/ we won't get anyone interested enough to care and they'll just pick one randomly.

[Davidtourniquet]

It's easier to do a second round of voting. Maybe alternative vote, but we've gotta wait for the referendum on that in the UK (sorry political joke).

[thekillman]

i already dislike the vote for PJOZ of what he has done before.

i mean seriously, can we cut the fanclub crap? i don't have one and i don't need one and i don't want one. vote for what you think fits your vision of the class, and vote for what fits, not for a person, no matter their reputation

[Davidtourniquet]

This is what I fear is happening. Which is why I keep asking people to explain why they voted for a particular set of specs.

[RogueRanger]

i already dislike the vote for PJOZ of what he has done before.

i mean seriously, can we cut the fanclub crap? i don't have one and i don't need one and i don't want one. vote for what you think fits your vision of the class, and vote for what fits, not for a person, no matter their reputation

What has he done????? He has the best ship by far, I voted for that nothing else. Killman you have a thing against PJ and always have, get over it please. And if he has a fanclub, what of it, he didn't create it himself.

My reasons for voting for the Heroine class.
1/ It was the most balanced or the entries
2/ It has the far less "uber" factor
3/ It is the most realistic
4/ It is the one that you could imagine most in all practicality being built in the not to distant future
5/ It has all the atributes you need for a ship of that class

[Davidtourniquet]

So rogue ranger what is it about PJOZ that is soo good, as I pointed out, you can't put these AC401 support ships in the cruiser because it'll take up too much space. I've not nothing against PJOZ at all, but what I've noticed and I'm sure a few others have as well is that it's the same group of people voting for his ship that have been with him in fan fictions on here.

Take one example in the battleship vote: "I've worked with PJOZs ship so I'll vote for it". The same went with the fighter vote, his fanclub didn't like the fact that he didn't win the fighter vote, but drew with mine, so they tried to fix the vote.

So why was it less "uber"?
Why was it more realistic?
How does it have all the attributes of that class? (going back to support craft, the fact it has them, takes it out of the cruiser class straight away)

If you really think that you need to go back and relook at the definition of a cruiser.