The All Time Ranking Game

[Celsius]

17. Deadman's Switch - 225 points
Highest Ranking - 3
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 14.06

I actually thought this episode was fairly well loved, but maybe Season 3 is just that good!

[dipsofjazz]

19. Demons - 259 points
Highest Ranking - 4
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 16.18

And with one less point is Demons, which does similarly unspectacularly.

I found these four bottom episodes just kind of 'meh' episodes. Yes, they had good bits, but not enough for me to give them a higher position. It's interesting to see that I'm not the only person that thinks this.

[Celsius]

16. Fair Game - 218 points
Highest Ranking - 5
Lowest Ranking - 20
Average Score - 13.62

Another surprise for me is seeing Fair Game so low, I don't love it, but I thought a lot of people did!

[Anubis69]

woohoo! I got a lowest ranking for A Hundred Days. Uh oh, I hope no one's reading this.

Sheeit! I was gonna brag about that but I see I'm tied with Freeman. Poo.

Another surprise for me is seeing Fair Game so low, I don't love it, but I thought a lot of people did!

I deemed it high(est ) as I enjoyed the Jack/Thor banter. Among other things i'm too tired to remember. (I think i just really love Asgard episodes...)

[Thunderstorm]

Seth: Not at the top of my list but it's got a great Jack line
"So help me, if I wake up and I'm singing soprano."

Demons: They didn't call it the Dark Ages because it was dark

I am surprised this one is that low too.

*raises hand for the lone top ten ranking* I obviously don't know what a good episode of Stargate is.

I liked New Ground too. It almost made the top ten. I ranked it #11.

18. A Hundred Days - 256 points
Highest Ranking - 2
Lowest Ranking - 20
Average Score - 16

Unfortunately not everyone shares ainty's enthusiasm for A Hundred Days, which I didn't hate, but didn't love either.

I suprised myself with my rank of this ep. Except for the very end and ignoring some people's interpretation of a couple scenes, it was a pretty good ep.

17. Deadman's Switch - 225 points
Highest Ranking - 3
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 14.06

I actually thought this episode was fairly well loved, but maybe Season 3 is just that good!

That 22 would be me. It wasn't a terrible ep but easily the worst of S3 for me.

[Celsius]

15. Past and Present - 205 points
Highest Ranking - 1
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 12.81

The scores ranged across the board for Past and Present, but the lower rankings drag it down, which is a shame imo cause I think it's rather underrated.

[Naonak]

17. Deadman's Switch - 225 points
Highest Ranking - 3
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 14.06

I actually thought this episode was fairly well loved, but maybe Season 3 is just that good!

I love it! Aris Boch is great.
Some really good lines, too.

[aintright]

I love it! Aris Boch is great.
Some really good lines, too.

yes, yes, yes!!!

my personal fave --- it is a well used aintyism


Col. O'Neill: Can't blame a girl for trying


then ....


Aris Boch: Captain? You must have some medical training.
Maj. Carter: Actually, I'm a… major now.
Aris Boch: Oh, well how very important. I'll inform the galaxy. Can you get over here now and help me, Major?


and ...



Aris Boch: Dr. Jackson is right. There is something you can do.
Col. O'Neill: Let's hear it.
Aris Boch: Well, you help me capture a Goa'uld, and I'll let you go.
Col. O'Neill: He's worth that much?
Aris Boch: Twice as much as all of you put together.
Col. O'Neill: Twice?
Dr. Jackson: Twice.
Aris Boch: What, you're gonna argue


then there is the little banter between jack/danny looking for the magic word to open the door .... couldn't find that one and dashing to work .... will have to pull out the dvd and look for it later!!!


teehee!!

[Celsius]

14. Pretense - 191 points
Highest Ranking - 7
Lowest Ranking - 19
Average Score - 11.93

Fairly average scoring for Pretense, not many extreme highs or lows.

[Naonak]

Aris Boch: Captain? You must have some medical training.
Maj. Carter: Actually, I'm a… major now.
Aris Boch: Oh, well how very important. I'll inform the galaxy. Can you get over here now and help me, Major?

I like the bit leading up to that, too:

Aris: Dr Jackson. If you don't mind... treating my wound.
Daniel: I'm an archaeologist.
Aris: I know, but you're also a doctor.
Daniel: ... Of archaeology.

Why did I only rank this 11th? Guess there's too many good eps in S3...

[warmbeachbrat]

15. Past and Present - 205 points
Highest Ranking - 1
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 12.81

The scores ranged across the board for Past and Present, but the lower rankings drag it down, which is a shame imo cause I think it's rather underrated.

*sigh* This is my favorite of season three--with Learning Curve very, very close behind. I'm not sure why people don't like it. There's lots of angst, a rather different storyline, and not necessarily a happy, tied-up-in-a-bow ending. I'm not a huge Daniel fan, but I thought this was a very good Daniel episode.

[cshawzye]

*sigh* This is my favorite of season three--with Learning Curve very, very close behind. I'm not sure why people don't like it. There's lots of angst, a rather different storyline, and not necessarily a happy, tied-up-in-a-bow ending. I'm not a huge Daniel fan, but I thought this was a very good Daniel episode.

For me, it wasn't that I didn't like "Past and Present" it was that I liked some of the episodes a bit better. Season Three was such a stellar season that it was really hard to rank them. "Past and Present" was a good episodes, no doubt, but for me it wasn't as good as say "Forever In A Day" or "Point of View." I have to say though that I am surprised that it's at 15. I would've thought it would've been higher up the scale.

[Celsius]

13. Urgo - 173 points
Highest Ranking - 2
Lowest Ranking - 22
Average Score - 10.81

Although not as controversial as some, it appears people either love or hate Urgo, leading it to a middle ranking.

[Missster.Freeman]

LOL! Yet another of my choices gets to scrape the barrel. After all this time I don't really know how I'd take this episode if I were to watch it again. Maybe I would appreciate it more, maybe not. I've a feeling that Urgo would get under my skin and annoy the hell out of me again.

[Celsius]

12. Shades of Grey - 169 points
Highest Ranking - 1
Lowest Ranking - 20
Average Score - 10.56

Wow, I was expecting this to be much higher, but there were a fair few not too flattering scores for Shades of Grey.