Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

SG1 Best Episode Tournament - Seasons 1 through 7 overall

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Round 39:

    The Nox
    Hathor
    Holiday
    Urgo
    The Other Side
    Watergate
    The Tomb (let's BURY it!)
    Need



    I don't HAVE to always say anything, but I'm just soooo opinionated. Stargate fans are pretty thin on the ground around here, so when I get a chance to talk about it, well, I just take it!
    While I'm not an overt Sam/Jack shipper, I like romance and happy endings as much as the next person, so I don't mind seeing it. On the other hand, it wouldn't totally ruin Stargate for me if they don't wind up together (I'd be disappointed, but not crushed). That said, I've never been to either the ship or anti-ship threads. From reading some of the threads on the forum, I see that passions run high on both fronts. I can understand that; I have some things that would cause me to turn my back on Stargate (with sorrow), and I hope the show never goes there--anyway, where was I? Oh yeah--it's interesting to read both perspectives on the Sam/Jack ship and see where I agree and disagree, but I'm glad I'm not quite as invested in it, since the show has a definite point of view on the S/J shippiness.


    Katrine, re: The Other Side; Jack's reaction seemed a bit mean-spirited to me--as if he were more angry at being deceived than at what they were actually doing (of course what they were doing was horribly wrong--but did that make Jack as mad or was he even angrier that he was somehow misled by them). I wonder if he might have made a more reasoned action, if he had had time to think about it. At least, that's the impression I came away with--it's been a while since I've seen that episode, so I could be remembering it incorrectly.
    Last edited by warmbeachbrat; 27 July 2005, 12:34 PM. Reason: TRYING to clarify...

    I am so blessed! Cherriey made this cool sig; scarimor made this great Dr. Lee smilie and Spudster made another neat one Dr. Lee RULES!

    Myn's fabulous twilight bark smilie:

    Comment


      Round 39:

      The Enemy Within
      Fire and Water
      Tin Man
      Message in a Bottle
      Holiday
      Learning Curve
      Urgo
      Entity

      Comment


        Orpheus
        The Warrior
        Message in a Bottle
        New Ground
        The Light
        Entity
        Rite of Passage
        Metamorphosis

        Comment


          Resurrection
          Forever in a Day
          Out of Mind
          Divide and Conquer
          Message in a Bottle
          The Warrior
          Proving Ground
          Revisions

          5th Season of Supernatural Premiering September 10th!
          Spoiler:

          Comment


            Round 39

            Metamorphosis
            Divide and Conquer
            Entity
            Desperate Measures
            Learning Curve
            Chain Reaction
            Frozen
            Proving Ground

            Comment


              Resurrection
              Point of no return
              Watergate
              Frozen
              5th Man
              The Changeling
              Metamorphosis
              Hathor



              just curious, how long does it take to tally up the votes, calculate the stats, and post results/update the thread each round?

              Comment


                Round 39:

                The Warrior
                New Ground
                The Fifth Man
                Resurrection
                Hathor
                Show and Tell
                Desperate Measures
                Forever in a day
                ComTraya!!

                Comment


                  Round #39

                  The First Ones
                  Metamorphosis
                  Show and Tell
                  Fire and Water
                  The Enemy Within
                  Holiday
                  Summit
                  The Warrior
                  sig by PM

                  Comment


                    The Enemy Within
                    Tin Man
                    Out Of Mind
                    Learning Curve
                    Beneath the Surface
                    The Warrior
                    Frozen
                    Revisions

                    Comment


                      Round 39
                      Message in a Bottle
                      The Enemy Within
                      Entity
                      Prophecy
                      Divide and Conquer
                      The Warrior
                      Desperate Measures
                      Hathor

                      Katerine: I am neither a shipper nor anti-shipper (I don't count Sam/Thor 'cause thats purely for insane fun). I am completely neutral on the Sam/Jack issue. I guess I don't fit into your scheme at all...where is my demographic??! I NEVER visit either the pro- or anti-ship threads, but I DO thunk for fun. I don't think I let that color my decisions on ep quality, though. A poor Daniel-centric ep is still a poor ep...I wouldn't (and haven't) voted to keep one in just because it focused on Daniel. Are you certain the shippers (or anti-shippers) are using only their ship preferences as their guidelines?

                      Comment


                        Round 39

                        1. Prometheus
                        2. Show and Tell
                        3. Learning Curve
                        4. Frozen
                        5. Metamorphosis
                        6. Urgo
                        7. Prophecy
                        8. Watergate

                        Katerine, just because you're recognizing/not recognizing names in certain threads doesn't mean we're not a diverse set. I came to Gateworld's Forums for "Ask Joe", stuck around for the tournament, and lurk but don't post at other threads. In fact, I discovered your tournament by a comment in a completely different fan forum!

                        For your "demographic purposes". I'm a Daniel fan (see name/avatar), friendship/team fan, and anti-J/S shipper (though not a rabid one by any means). Like Seshat, I try not to let my preferences color my voting, though if it's episodes of equal quality, one Teal'c centric and one Daniel centric, my personal bias may well sway me.

                        Comment


                          Round 39

                          The Summit
                          The First Ones
                          Last Stand
                          Resurrection
                          Cure
                          Orpheus
                          Fire And Water
                          Absolute Power
                          My View From The Peanut Gallery

                          Comment


                            Round 39


                            1. Learning Curve
                            2. Frozen
                            3. Divide and Conquer - they killed off my lovely Martuf!
                            4. The Warrior
                            5. Entity
                            6. Revisions - Most boring episode ever, in my not so humble opinion.
                            7. Metamorphosis
                            8. Prometheus
                            sigpic

                            Comment


                              Round 39:

                              Enigma
                              Show and Tell
                              Forever in a Day
                              Resurrection
                              The Warrior
                              Meridian
                              The Changeling
                              Orpheus

                              @->-4eva Sam and Jack!<3

                              ^ My New Siggy!!! Made by SueKay! ^

                              Comment


                                Round 39:

                                The First Ones
                                New Ground
                                The Warrior
                                Show and Tell
                                Forever in a Day
                                Holiday
                                Proving Ground
                                The Fifth Man
                                -girlgater

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X