'Remnants' (515) General Discussion

[TragicComedy]

I though it was a pretty good episode. Not exactly what I expected, it really kept me thinking. Loved the ending and the little help the AI gave Woolsey. Looking forward to the next episode! Until then... *grabs season 3 and runs to the TV*

Any reason Season 3 specifically or just a fave?

[Quinn Mallory]

One of the better standalone episode of SGA in the history of the series, imho. You get the classic Stargate feel with a nice blend of character based tension and action. Even though it was fairly easy to figure out that they were all hallucinating (particularly after that somewhat over the top amputation), I enjoyed the overall pacing of this one.

[Shan Bruce Lee]

It was a good episode. I probably would've liked it more if it didn't follow last week's episode. I liked the Shep/Kolya story best... why is Shep always hanging from a ledge or cliff? lol

[jelgate]

It was a good episode. I probably would've liked it more if it didn't follow last week's episode. I liked the Shep/Kolya story best... why is Shep always hanging from a ledge or cliff? lol

Because without it the Shep whumpers would attack Bridge Studios

[Lythisrose]

adn the audio is just as frakked up on the second airing

When I watched the audio was just fine, perhaps it's a cable company thing?

[Ruffles]

Because without it the Shep whumpers would attack Bridge Studios

Pfft. Shows you what you know. Variety is the name of the game for us.

[jelgate]

Pfft. Shows you what you know. Variety is the name of the game for us.

I'm baffled that whumpers know what variety is

[Mercury973]

I am pretty harsh on my reviews of SGA since it's my favorite show. I was simply blown away by this one. I laughed, I was worried, I was concerned. I didn't see the ending coming. I was enthralled. I cheered. Wonderful wonderful episode. PARRISH IS BACK!!!!! Weee! CHUCK IS BACK!!!!
Ok, maybe I'm pretty simple, but I really did love this one.

[jelgate]

I am pretty harsh on my reviews of SGA since it's my favorite show.?* I was simply blown away by this one.?* I laughed, I was worried, I was concerned.?* I didn't see the ending coming.?* I was enthralled. I cheered.?* Wonderful wonderful episode.?*?* PARRISH IS BACK!!!!!?* Weee!?* CHUCK IS BACK!!!! Ok, maybe I'm pretty simple, but I really did love this one.

Don't you mean Chet

[TragicComedy]

I am pretty harsh on my reviews of SGA since it's my favorite show. I was simply blown away by this one. I laughed, I was worried, I was concerned. I didn't see the ending coming. I was enthralled. I cheered. Wonderful wonderful episode. PARRISH IS BACK!!!!! Weee! CHUCK IS BACK!!!!
Ok, maybe I'm pretty simple, but I really did love this one.

That's funny. I'm just the opposite. Because I love SGA I'm pretty protective of it and when people criticize an episode to death, I just want to say, "Noooo! Stop!" lol

Not that I don't find flaws with the show at all, I don't know - I guess I just like to accept the show as it is for the most part.

[Mercury973]

Don't you mean Chet

I loved that! I'll have to have him sign his autograph "Chet" at P4.

That's funny. I'm just the opposite. Because I love SGA I'm pretty protective of it and when people criticize an episode to death, I just want to say, "Noooo! Stop!" lol

Not that I don't find flaws with the show at all, I don't know - I guess I just like to accept the show as it is for the most part.

Besides The Shrine, this is the only S5 episode that I felt like cheering when it was over. Well, and I'm pretty sure next one will be thumbs up from me. Wonder why???

[TragicComedy]

Besides The Shrine, this is the only S5 episode that I felt like cheering when it was over. Well, and I'm pretty sure next one will be thumbs up from me. Wonder why???

Oh God! The Shrine is the episode that all other Stargate Atlantis episodes bow down to. Pure gold. Loved every single second of that epi.

[WickedWater]

To Vala M,

If anyone calls this episode predictable I am going to scream my head off !

You had to know something was wrong when they bandaged Sheps nub, why would Kolya care if it was bandaged, he wouldn't.

[SerenaSerenity]

You had to know something was wrong when they bandaged Sheps nub, why would Kolya care if it was bandaged, he wouldn't.

I don't know. I mean, if you want information out of someone, you want them to live. To go through a massive amount of pain till they break and spill their guts. If Sheppard bled to death, then it would be indeed pointless to get the information that he wanted. I could be wrong, but that's what I automatically assumed with the bandaged nub. Not that he cared, but he needed him to live long enough to get the said information. *nod nod* I was of course wrong. LOL

That's just my opinion though. *smiles* Nothing against what anyone else thinks. Just what I thought when I saw it.

[TragicComedy]

Yeah my only problem with the nub was that there was no blood on it. You chop somebody's hand off, I don't care how well you wrap it, there will be blood.