What character should go?

[GateGipsy]

You forgot the 'in my opinion' part of that post

[Rac80]

Aye me too but after watching S & R i've given him a temporary reprieve.....I just hope he's like this the rest of S5 and doesn't revert back to S4 Rodney!

Me too! I do not want to see a replay of his part in quarantine. it made me cringe for him and poor Katie!

[Integrabyte]

84 is my new favourite number

[Lenas]

84 is my new favourite number

85 someone

She was written poorly because her sole purpose was to fill in Beckett's spot

Could be, but I think her sole purpose was to attract the male characters (as well as the male viewers,) setting her up in ridiculous "romantic" situations
Any doctor in the infirmary could have taken the job, should have taken the job, so we could have a real doctor in Atlantis - she never wanted the position from the beginning anyway!

[elliecat]

85 someone




Could be, but I think her sole purpose was to attract the male characters (as well as the male viewers,) setting her up in ridiculous "romantic" situations
Any doctor in the infirmary could have taken the job, should have taken the job, so we could have a real doctor in Atlantis - she never wanted the position from the beginning anyway!

I would love to make it 85 but I already voted for her.

Those are good reasons why she should go. It wouldn't be very hard to replace her. And, like you said, she didn't want the position anyway so why not bring in someone who wants the job?! (cough*Carson*cough). If not Carson then i'm sure there are other doctors more willing to come to Atlantis.

[g.o.d]

I would love to make it 85 but I already voted for her.

Those are good reasons why she should go. It wouldn't be very hard to replace her. And, like you said, she didn't want the position anyway so why not bring in someone who wants the job?! (cough*Carson*cough). If not Carson then i'm sure there are other doctors more willing to come to Atlantis.

Dr. Who

[Linda06]

Me too! I do not want to see a replay of his part in quarantine. it made me cringe for him and poor Katie!

Oh i know......He was bloody aweful in quarantine.........No wonder Katie dumped his sorry ass....She saw the real McKay....I just wish she gagged him with something to shut him up for 5 minutes!

[elliecat]

Dr. Who

Much better!

[Reiko]

» Hee, Dr. Who - yes! Or House, who I guess could be called the complete opposite of Keller

[GateGipsy]

House and McKay. Now that would make an interesting pairing.

[jelgate]

Dr. Who

Please no. That would prevent me from ever watching SGA again

[g.o.d]

or Doctor Cottle from BSG

[Alipeeps]

House and McKay. Now that would make an interesting pairing.

You mean you haven't already read the numerous House/SGA crossover fanfics?

[Ltcolshepjumper]

85 someone




Could be, but I think her sole purpose was to attract the male characters (as well as the male viewers,) setting her up in ridiculous "romantic" situations
Any doctor in the infirmary could have taken the job, should have taken the job, so we could have a real doctor in Atlantis - she never wanted the position from the beginning anyway!

Nah. I think the relationships were an attempt to make her character more interesting.

[Ltcolshepjumper]

You forgot the 'in my opinion' part of that post

It's implied. There are many people who "forget" to put that in.