What character should go?

[Falcon Horus]

Relativity aside (13 votes for Teyla is wrong too) Keller having 40+ is okay by me.

[Integrabyte]

Relativity aside (13 votes for Teyla is wrong too) Keller having 40+ is okay by me.

Don't let that put you down . Had Carter been in S5, the poll would have a different outcome .

[Falcon Horus]

Don't let that put you down . Had Carter been in S5, the poll would have a different outcome .

Probably... though I think Keller would still have scored way high.

[Integrabyte]

Probably... though I think Keller would still have scored way high.

She is popular . We all love her

[Jumper_One]

Don't let that put you down . Had Carter been in S5, the poll would have a different outcome .

I don't think so

[Cautious Explorer]

I don't think so

Carter would have had my vote.

Keller would have still been recurring -- not regular. That keeps her in second place.

[Linda06]

I like Carter.....She was good in S4!

[Torri012]

I like Carter.....She was good in S4!

yeah, she was a nice good replacement for Weir but still not .. you know .. she just wasnt Elizabeth

[Linda06]

yeah, she was a nice good replacement for Weir but still not .. you know .. she just wasnt Elizabeth

Yeah....I liked Weir too......It's hard to get mad when you like one person then the person that comes in to replace the other person you like them too

[Cautious Explorer]

TPTB didn't seem to know what to do with Carter. She was just there -- like the potted plants in the background -- for the most part. I got the feeling AT didn't know what to do with Carter either. She just didn't fit in.

I'm glad she's gone. She was a major irritant to me. I didn't like the character when she was there, but at the same time I felt the lack of leadership on Atlantis when a command character wasn't written in.

I'm glad she's gone. Now if we could just get rid of Keller and get a real doctor, there might be some hope for the show.

[Rac80]

Actually they both annoy me with the whining. It's just that Keller annoys me a lot more.

Who voted for Lorne? He hasn't done anything wrong. Neither did Zelenka Poor guy wanted to give Keller a compliment and ended up a perv.

What is the difference between sexual harrassment and flirting? Whether or not you like the guy/gal doing the flirting!

Carson and Larrin should go!

[Reiko]

Who voted for Lorne? He hasn't done anything wrong. Neither did Zelenka Poor guy wanted to give Keller a compliment and ended up a perv.

» Lorne and Zelenka are guilty of no crime.

» Keller still must go

[Arica12]

TPTB didn't seem to know what to do with Carter. She was just there -- like the potted plants in the background -- for the most part. I got the feeling AT didn't know what to do with Carter either. She just didn't fit in.

I'm glad she's gone. She was a major irritant to me. I didn't like the character when she was there, but at the same time I felt the lack of leadership on Atlantis when a command character wasn't written in.

I'm glad she's gone. Now if we could just get rid of Keller and get a real doctor, there might be some hope for the show.

I liked Carter...or rather I liked the potential Carter showed.

Keller however is the little cuckoo in the nest, stealing time and focus from all the others but contributing nothing in return.

She has to go.

[Integrabyte]

Rodney has 3 votes. I was guesstimating more .

[Achaja]

I chose Teyla, but I like her very much. It's just that she didn't show or didn't have an opportunity to show something BIG in SGA 4.