What character should go?

[Madeleine]

Uh huh. Really. I can delve into a million deep reasons why I love Carson. It seems most people cannot for Keller. Can you?

If you cannot, I suggest you re-evaluate chararacterization.

Reiko, please let's not get into the whole "I like my character for more reasons than you like your character" thing. It's not something you can know, since you're not psychic. And if you're going to ignore / discount all the reasons the Keller fans have posted for why they like her, then that's not terribly respectful.

Cheers.

[fuchsia]

If you don't like Keller please come and join in the anti-keller thread, I would hate to feel that you were scared just because you don't like Beckett! We all have different opinions about who we like and don't like, I personally love Beckett but wouldn't hold it against you if you didn't. (I wouldn't mention that you don't like him on the anti-keller thread tho, just keep it to Keller bashing!)

Thanks, mate!

I may just hop over and put in my 'two penorth' as we Northerners say.

[Pajus]

I have found my old thread!
Here it is...

http://forum.gateworld.net/showthread.php?t=53535

All it says is 'closed', and I didn't get a pm either.

(There used to be a cute little padlock, too.)

Jackie, the thread contains a few of my issues with the character... I tried to be fair and not vindictive. How does it come across to you?

Try to talk to a moderator and tell him/her that there was no Anti-Carson thread before. Last time I heard, pro and anti character threads were still allowed (of cours I may be wrong).

Are you suggesting that the anti-keller thread is pro-beckett???

Cos that would straighten things out a lot wouldn't it....

Anti-Carson talk is off-topic on the anti-Keller thread. That's all I was trying to say

[Skydiver]

guys, the topic is 'which character should go'

not

how much GW sucks
how much other fans suck

or any of the other things you've been going on about.

Let's keep it on topic please

[Jackie]

back on topic....

McKay should go! Followed by Woosley.

Nope, I won't even give the character a chance cause I already know he will be another McKay. *shivers*

[ShadowMaat]

I say wipe them all out and start over from scratch. I'm sure fans wouldn't mind. Maybe keep Zelenka and Lorne, just to act as a bridge between the old and new. lol

[Jackie]

I say wipe them all out and start over from scratch. I'm sure fans wouldn't mind. Maybe keep Zelenka and Lorne, just to act as a bridge between the old and new. lol

LMAO...I actually like that idea.

Zelenka should stay for sure!!

[Pajus]

I say wipe them all out and start over from scratch. I'm sure fans wouldn't mind. Maybe keep Zelenka and Lorne, just to act as a bridge between the old and new. lol

LMAO...I actually like that idea.

Zelenka should stay for sure!!

Make Keller go away with McKay. Radek is a far better chioce for the lead team anyway considering the facts at hand

[Jackie]

I think Zelenka could replace McKay on the team. He's far more interesting than McKay...and a bit more grouchy.

Maybe there should be a "Zelenka for McKay's job" thread?

I haven't come across a single poster who doesn't like Zelenka so far.

[PG15]

Nah, Stargate needs the snark. Zelenka's awesome, but IMHO a lot of it is attributed to him working alongside and bantering with McKay.

[g.o.d]

LMAO...I actually like that idea.

Zelenka should stay for sure!!

I have a bad feeling that S5 will be his last season

[Falcon Horus]

I have a bad feeling that S5 will be his last season

NOOOOOO!!! Don't give them any ideas!

[Klenotka]

I have a bad feeling that S5 will be his last season

I have a bad(?) feeling that S5 will be the last anyway. I am not sure why, it´s just a gut feeling.

[g.o.d]

NOOOOOO!!! Don't give them any ideas!

it's not an idea

wait for mid-season partner

[SpelCzech]

Long Live Radek!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
: