Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[Guest]

Well it gave "The Kindred Part 2" a solid 1.3 live Rating. So maybe we can get that for GitM, remember the 5th episode for Season 4 pulled a 1.0!

I hope it does have a good effect on the ratings but I still think it was a bad idea giving away a major plot point like that (both 'The Kindred' and 'Ghost in the machine' trailers).

[jelgate]

I did the ultimate eyeroll. I already knew about it but the poor people who don't read spoilers

[Briangate78]

I did the ultimate eyeroll. I already knew about it but the poor people who don't read spoilers

I hope it does have a good effect on the ratings but I still think it was a bad idea giving away a major plot point like that (both 'The Kindred' and 'Ghost in the machine' trailers).

A real shocker would be if Torri Higginson shows up like in the last minute to say goodbye or something. Now that would be an amazing ending.

[Guest]

A real shocker would be if Torri Higginson shows up like in the last minute to say goodbye or something. Now that would be an amazing ending.

Yup that would definitely be somewhere between amazing and shocking.

[GoSpikey]

Yes you do. You have to like everything Stargate

Er, Jelly? You typed in my quote...

So SCI FI strikes again with their wonderful promotion.

Spoiler:

So do you guys think FRAN is really Weir?

You think that...

Spoiler:

the 'I'm Weir' part, if I remember correctly, was bad? How about the 'we're putting Atlantis back into the ocean' thing? I don't know if we knew from the spoilers, because I sure didn't - I don't think I read much of the spoilers for this ep, because it's Replicator related...

I did the ultimate eyeroll. I already knew about it but the poor people who don't read spoilers

*Points to her tag above. I didn't know that part yet.*

Briangate

A real shocker would be if Torri Higginson shows up like in the last minute to say goodbye or something. Now that would be an amazing ending.

Yup that would definitely be somewhere between amazing and shocking.

No, there wouldn't be a shock at all. They'd have shown it in the promo.

[Briangate78]

Yup that would definitely be somewhere between amazing and shocking.

I think there is a chance. We have not heard a peep from Torri at all, so who knows. She has to feel that wanted to be able to return. Sometimes you gotta think of your fans. No offense to Torri, but I am a Weir fan not a Torri fan. I have no interest in her other works but I am sure she is just as great.

Er, Jelly? You typed in my quote...



You think that...

Spoiler:

the 'I'm Weir' part, if I remember correctly, was bad? How about the 'we're putting Atlantis back into the ocean' thing? I don't know if we knew from the spoilers, because I sure didn't - I don't think I read much of the spoilers for this ep, because it's Replicator related...

*Points to her tag above. I didn't know that part yet.*





No, there wouldn't be a shock at all. They'd have shown it in the promo.

LOL, yeah the promos have gotten that bad.

[jelgate]

MGM always has the supperior promos

[Briangate78]

MGM always has the supperior promos

Yeah I like the MGM promos.

[Shan Bruce Lee]

Yeah I like the MGM promos.

They should just run those instead of making two from different companies.

[The TARDIS]

So SCI FI strikes again with their wonderful promotion.

Spoiler:

So do you guys think FRAN is really Weir?

Hey, Atleast it wasn't as bad as what Space did.

"This episode of Stargate Atlantis (First Strike) brought to you by Atlantis Season 4 on DVD. Join Amanda Tapping as she crosses over to lead Atlantis in it's greatest struggle yet! *Shows a montage of scenes from S4*"

"Returns to First Strike, and Weir"

...

...

[Platschu]

I think this season became the whumper's heaven (Linzi, where are you? ). They should rename the show to ER:Atlantis.

[jelgate]

Hey, At least it wasn't as bad as what Space did.

"This episode of Stargate Atlantis (First Strike) brought to you by Atlantis Season 4 on DVD. Join Amanda Tapping as she crosses over to lead Atlantis in it's greatest struggle yet! *Shows a montage of scenes from S4*"

"Returns to First Strike, and Weir"

...

...

Apparently SciFi doesn't do the worst promos on the planet. Now I just want to hear how bad Australia is. Where are you jonos?

[jonos101]

Apparently SciFi doesn't do the worst promos on the planet. Now I just want to hear how bad Australia is. Where are you jonos?

You called?

[jelgate]

How bad are the Stargate promos in Australia? We have SciFi giving away major plot points and Space (Canada) promoting AT in S4 DVD during the S3 finale.

[jonos101]

How bad are the Stargate promos in Australia? We have SciFi giving away major plot points and Space (Canada) promoting AT in S4 DVD during the S3 finale.

I don't really know because I don't watch it on TV, they're only up to season 2 of Atlantis, I just watch my DVDs. But from what I've seen they don't give away major plot points.