Carson vs. Keller

[Arica12]

why do you assume that Keller will be a regular in s5? she's in 11 eps in s4, that's enough. there's no need to make her a regular

KELLER

REGULAR?????????

Are you trying to give me nightmares?

[Jumper_One]

IMO TPTB could easily over do it with characters like Keller... I agree there is no need to make her a regular

KELLER

REGULAR?????????

Are you trying to give me nightmares?

nope. I'm just replying to xx_luvSheppard_xx who thinks Keller will be a regular in s5 which makes no sense to me

[Killdeer]

No, she should definitely be not be a regular. I know she's coming back, but I'm hoping she doesn't have as much of a presence next year as she did last year. After Quarantine, I'm a little fed up. And Trio is probably going to push me over the edge.

[Arica12]

nope. I'm just replying to xx_luvSheppard_xx who thinks Keller will be a regular in s5 which makes no sense to me

Oh good I can stop breathing into this paper bag then

[Jumper_One]

No, she should definitely be not be a regular. I know she's coming back, but I'm hoping she doesn't have as much of a presence next year as she did last year. After Quarantine, I'm a little fed up. And Trio is probably going to push me over the edge.

Quarantine was a fun ep and I'm really looking forward to Trio. not because of Keller but it should be hilarious. I think Keller will be in at least 8 eps next season which would make sense if Beckett's gonna be a recurring character. if however he's only back as a guest for 3-4 eps then we'll see her in at least as much eps as this season imo

Oh good I can stop breathing into this paper bag then

stay calm

[Integrabyte]

Oh good I can stop breathing into this paper bag then

Only if the shock has passed

[Killdeer]

Quarantine was a fun ep and I'm really looking forward to Trio. not because of Keller but it should be hilarious. I think Keller will be in at least 8 eps next season which would make sense if Beckett's gonna be a recurring character. if however he's only back as a guest for 3-4 eps then we'll see her in at least as much eps as this season imo

I found the whole Ronon/Keller thing in Quarantine excruciating. No more of that please.

[Arica12]

Only if the shock has passed

Not really, but I'm hoping that Vodka I just pouired will help.

*Keller a Regular*

Better make that a double

[Integrabyte]

Double bottle

[SG13-NightOps]

I don't need TPTB to tell me what to like...

exactly! Just because that interview says a brain surgeon sees Keller as believable and that gives her "the stamp of approval" doesn't mean we should say "Ok, well HE says she is great I guess I should like her to."

Where in that interview or in my post did either myself or PM imply that you had to like her?

It was simply supporting the answer to the question "Is that brain surgery?"

According to an actual brain surgeon, it is.

Trying not to sound too nasty, but some people need to get a grip. No one is forcing you to like her. Don't ask the question if you are going to twist the answer into something it isn't.

[Chezlee]

I found the whole Ronon/Keller thing in Quarantine excruciating. No more of that please.

yep! Though as much as I hate to admit it I think that Jumper One is probably right Keller will be back in not as many eps and Beckett guest stars. I dont think that the Carson fanbase is lucky enough to have him back on a more permanent basis because its just not very concievable with the way things are going.

[justhere1971]

I found the whole Ronon/Keller thing in Quarantine excruciating. No more of that please.

Yes please keep that behind the scene. I don't need to see my dinner again.

[Chezlee]

Yes please keep that behind the scene. I don't need to see my dinner again.

Yeah we need to patent Anti-Keller/Ronon barf bags

[Guest]

Yes please keep that behind the scene. I don't need to see my dinner again.

Yeah we need to patent Anti-Keller/Ronon barf bags

LMAO! I'm definately feeling the dislike for Keller here

[Chezlee]

LMAO! I'm definately feeling the dislike for Keller here

Well safe to say dislike for the ship