Sunday (317)

[TennisMennis]

this was a great episode

I completely agree, but I "REALLY" hated saying goodbye to Carson, especially now knowing he didn't want to leave. I'm sure the decision was made to replace him with someone who might bring in more viewers, but I don't think it worked.

[mrscopterdoc]

One of the most saddest episodes ever. Carson is dearly missed and I still don't understand why he left the show.

[Falcon Horus]

One of the most saddest episodes ever. Carson is dearly missed and I still don't understand why he left the show.

Because Paul McGillion was booted out. It wasn't his choice to leave.

[mrscopterdoc]

Well, that just sucks and makes it even worse. What is wrong with these people getting rid of good charactors? *pouts*

[jelgate]

Well, that just sucks and makes it even worse. What is wrong with these people getting rid of good charactors? *pouts*

What is a good character to you is dead weight to someone else.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

Well, that just sucks and makes it even worse. What is wrong with these people getting rid of good charactors? *pouts*

I know it confuses me Why they would ask him to leave but then bring him back ! He is a great character and everyone who watches stargate would agree... Killing him off only made the show a bit better though ! it brought a serious side that i never seen coming ! great episode really enjoyed it had to watch it again last night

[Falcon Horus]

They didn't ask Paul McGillion about killing off Beckett, they just did and they regretted that act, and brought in the clone.

[maneth]

Oh dear, it was in its way a good episode but I hated to see the end of Carson.

[Atlantis4Life]

What is a good character to you is dead weight to someone else.

Hey! No talking about Keller in this thread.

Oh dear, it was in its way a good episode but I hated to see the end of Carson.

So true, my friend. So true... Beckett was the BEST!!!

[jelgate]

Hey! No talking about Keller in this thread.





So true, my friend. So true... Beckett was the BEST!!!

Since Keller didn't appear until a few episodes later its quite apparent I wasn't talking about her.

[Tiptronic]

I was wondering why this topic had the mosts posts.. Its pretty obvious now that I just saw which episode this was. Incredibly heartbreaking episode, I'm pretty sure its the most heartbreaking episode of SGA...

Thank you Paul McGillion for the incredibly great acting.

[mrscopterdoc]

They didn't ask Paul McGillion about killing off Beckett, they just did and they regretted that act, and brought in the clone.

well that sucks.

[mathpiglet]

It was terrible to lose Carson, but it's still a good episode.

Do we ever see Mike, the scientist who had lunch with Elizabeth?

I hope Dr. Hewston got a lovely send off as well. I felt bad for her...she doesn't even appear to have a first name.

[Falcon Horus]

Do we ever see Mike, the scientist who had lunch with Elizabeth?

Never mentioned again.

I hope Dr. Hewston got a lovely send off as well. I felt bad for her...she doesn't even appear to have a first name.

Never heard from her again either - much like almost everyone who happened to be the red shirt of any SGA episode.

[mathpiglet]

Spoiler:

Not surprising we don't see Dr. Hewston anymore since she exploded.