You seem to be missing the point of your own topic here:
Bringing Daniel over to Atlantis for *even one episode* in Season 4 (as that is what we area talking about as all other seasons are already filmed and done with) would, for many people, feel like too much SG1 interference in SGA because Season 4 will already have a major SG1 character in the form of Carter in it for over half of the series!!
How many other ways can people make this point? You cannot separate the issue of Carter being in the show from the issue of Daniel's possible appearance in the show and the perception of SG1 intrusion into the show. You cannot posit the inclusion of Daniel into *even one episode* of Season 4 without setting that concept against the background of the FACT that there will already be a heavy SG1 presence in Season 4 in the form of Carter.
As I previously mentioned in, I believe, this very thread - in DS9 they didn't then proceed to have further TNG characters guest star in DS9 whilst Worf was already there as a major character. As it was, I believe there was discontent in the Trek fandom at the time about Worf's transplant to DS9. If, for example, fans of Data had at the time suggested that he could/should appear in a couple of DS9 episodes too, I'm sure many people would have been unhappy with that and would have felt that that would be too much TNG intrusion into DS9 (and, dare I say it, a little selfish on the part of the Data fans).
Bringing Daniel over to Atlantis for *even one episode* in Season 4 (as that is what we area talking about as all other seasons are already filmed and done with) would, for many people, feel like too much SG1 interference in SGA because Season 4 will already have a major SG1 character in the form of Carter in it for over half of the series!!
How many other ways can people make this point? You cannot separate the issue of Carter being in the show from the issue of Daniel's possible appearance in the show and the perception of SG1 intrusion into the show. You cannot posit the inclusion of Daniel into *even one episode* of Season 4 without setting that concept against the background of the FACT that there will already be a heavy SG1 presence in Season 4 in the form of Carter.
Originally posted by Daniel Jackson
View Post
Comment