Carter or Mckay?

[NakedJehutyV2]

who be smarter?


CARTER OWNS mckay in everyway possible. plus she's not cocky and she's hot.

[Agent_Dark]

Take a look down below at the similiar threads

[Pazuzu]

In my opinion Mckay rules. The only reason carter was better then him is that she was far more familiar with the alien tech than him. He was used to think like a normal scientist from earth and he wasn't thinking outside the box.
Yes he's cocky but we've seen more than in one ocasion that he really is a good guy. He doesn't have a choice; that's just the way he is.

[Samuel J. Tilden]

McKay. He's actually a human being who admits his mistakes. It takes smarts to make mistakes every now and then (and integrity to own up to them). Sam Carter lacks these qualities.

[newtrekker]

IMO, Sam is smarter. I lost faith in McKay after the Trinity incident.

[da_hippie]

Well, they're both much smarter than me, so I can't really compare. However, Carter can hold her own in the field, which is an area where Mckay seriously lacks.

[The Signal]

Carter is a little smarter, she isnt cocky about it and she figures things out in an instant whereas McKay is so damn arrogant (Trinity: Tha Ancients made the mistake. WHAT???) he cant see his mistakes.

[1DanielForMe]

McKay. He's actually a human being who admits his mistakes. It takes smarts to make mistakes every now and then (and integrity to own up to them). Sam Carter lacks these qualities.

As far as I'm concerned, it's the other way around.

[Gate Gal 1984]

McKay. He's actually a human being who admits his mistakes. It takes smarts to make mistakes every now and then (and integrity to own up to them). Sam Carter lacks these qualities.

Sam Carter kicks Rodney Mckays behind!!!

Mckay only admits his mistakes when forced to confront them, he tries to avoid any situation that makes him wrong and if he is wrong he vehlmently denies it until he has too and his mistake is ramming him in the face.

I think there is an ep in season two where they are aboard the Deadelus and Mckay makes a mistake and cant admit that he is wrong. I think it nearly costs them their lives. I'm pretty sure this is where the Asgard version of Mckay is introduced aka Hermiod.

Feel free to correct me if I am wrong about the episode info, unfortunately I am only remembering what I have read on Gateworld as Channel 7 has not yet aired Season 2 of Atlantis in Australia yet.

But my opinion of Mckay still stands the man doesnt like to be wrong, but then again who does eh?

[Nem2k]

Carter...she has scientific as well as military intelligence

and shes damn beyowtiful

[ShadowMaat]

There are already three or four threads about this. The easiest one to find is right in the related links section: http://forum.gateworld.net/showthread.php?t=18146

Another is McKay vs Sam: http://forum.gateworld.net/showthread.php?t=9458

[Eoin]

IMO Carter is smarter than Mckay, Their Two extremely smart people but i think Carter is just a small bit ahead, we have seen this a few times, where Carter out smarts Mckay.

I dont really care who is smarter, all i care is that the two of them are super genious's

[Erised]

who be smarter?


CARTER OWNS mckay in everyway possible. plus she's not cocky and she's hot.

Well, I'd choose McKay just because he cracks me up.
But Sam is so smart and she's a girl and I don't think there are a lot of girls astro physysists (that's what I was told anyway) So Sam!
But I don't know.. haha McKay is so funny!