Originally posted by NoobTau'ri
View Post
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wemYg...eature=related
Watch from 6:21 to 6:56
So what? It takes only one drone to pierce through the shield and each Aurora carries hundreds. 2 drones can take out a Ha'tak if it hits critical system. If it's a one-on-one fight, then the Aurora can shoot all of it's drones. It is impossible to shoot down all of them, and you know that they will perfurate the shield, no matter how powerful it is. The Asgard beam can perfurate the shield of a regular Aurora, but we don't know if it can perfurate the shield of an Aurora powered with a ZPM, so I give it to the Aurora.
Wrong. It can wipe out specific species with some adjustments. This is why Adria destroyed the Dakara weapon, to stop it from wiping out all priors.
You know what's canon? That the Ancients are far more advanced than the Asgard. That's canon. It is you who is arguing with canon, not me. As for the Ancients not being that great, I disagree. They seeded Human lives on countless galaxies, created technology that awes other highly advanced species and then ultimately transcended our plain of existence altogether. I think they are pretty darn awesome.
And you think I would get upset over this? I have a brother with leukemia who looks like a Wraith just fed on him, and you think that this debate bothers me? You have to be really shallow to believe that I will get so upset over an internet discussion about who's better between two fictional races.
You keep saying that I'm losing. I am losing just because you say so? Maybe you should get some of your board friends to post saying that I'm losing to you, because you have no credibility saying that I'm losing when you're the only one saying that.
And I'm losing what exactly? This is not mathematics where there is a clear cut solution for a problem and you can prove someone wrong without a shadow of a doubt. This is a subjective speculation based on what we believe would happen. The only absolutes we have are facts from canon, and that's it. One of the facts from canon is that the Asgard themselves regarded the Ancients as scientifically superior to themselves, and the Ancients are said in canon to be "the most advanced race that ever existed", so I guess that ends the discussion right there. As for who is militarilly stronger, there are no clear asnwer becasue there are way too many "ifs", "ands" and "buts". I believe that the Ancients are stronger because their most powerful shields and weapons are more powerful than the Asgard's, but the Asgard's most powerful ships apparently are more powerful than the most powerful Ancient ship we've seen so far, so neither me or you are right, as we're both speculating.
My exapmle of how the Asgard tech in terms of military tech is better is that the Deddy and the Apollo creamed the Replicators Auroras
That pretty much shows us that Asgard tech is more then enough to take those ships down. They even fought one on one and still beat them
From BAMSR
SHEPPARD: How's it going out there?
CALDWELL: Splitting us up was a good call. The Daedalus has downed another three ships.
SHEPPARD: Ellis got another two – that brings us to seven. That's not bad at all
SHEPPARD: How's it going out there?
CALDWELL: Splitting us up was a good call. The Daedalus has downed another three ships.
SHEPPARD: Ellis got another two – that brings us to seven. That's not bad at all
Comment