Originally posted by BlankDots
View Post
I agree with Jimbo.
In several episodes we have seen the lack of power by the ships in StarGate when to actual TNT equivalence. When the ships attack the earth and various other planets the firepower demonstrated is a Joke.
I couldn't understand what your link Mister Oragahn about Kelowna was about. I read it and didn't understand it.
But it is a fact that Hat'aks do jack to a planet. In one of the episodes i remember Hatak's firing at the planet surface from orbit. The hits were NOT visible at all from orbit. If it was indeed 200megatons per shot, this would be CLEARLY visible from space. Also when they attack earth, it takes them days to take over the planet.
If they had 200 megaton shot guns. THey fire say 60 shots per minute. 40 ships. Thats what 2400 shots per minute. That would easily take out earth and all its centres in one minute.
People have said that earth is capable of self destruction. With its current arsenal of sub 50 megaton warheads this is possible.
The TNT equivalnce attributed to ha'taks just don't stack up.
This is compared to ISD which is said to at least be capable of some planetary destruction by itself.
Your quote about the girl seeing the forests begining to burn is significant. To see forests burning from space is significant. Especially when seeing a hatak shoot at the surface of a planet seems to do nothing.
You cant say daedy can beat an ISD or vice versa. You have to prove that stargate weapons are just as effective against ISD shields as turbolasers are in SW universe.
One of the SSD's has a laser which supposedly has the firepower 2/3rds of the death stars main laser.
If a ISD is even 1000th the size of a SSD, it should have 1000th the firepower/energy output. It begs to ask the question how powerful 2/3000th of a death star beam is. I'd say pretty powerful.
In several episodes we have seen the lack of power by the ships in StarGate when to actual TNT equivalence. When the ships attack the earth and various other planets the firepower demonstrated is a Joke.
I couldn't understand what your link Mister Oragahn about Kelowna was about. I read it and didn't understand it.
But it is a fact that Hat'aks do jack to a planet. In one of the episodes i remember Hatak's firing at the planet surface from orbit. The hits were NOT visible at all from orbit. If it was indeed 200megatons per shot, this would be CLEARLY visible from space. Also when they attack earth, it takes them days to take over the planet.
If they had 200 megaton shot guns. THey fire say 60 shots per minute. 40 ships. Thats what 2400 shots per minute. That would easily take out earth and all its centres in one minute.
People have said that earth is capable of self destruction. With its current arsenal of sub 50 megaton warheads this is possible.
The TNT equivalnce attributed to ha'taks just don't stack up.
This is compared to ISD which is said to at least be capable of some planetary destruction by itself.
Your quote about the girl seeing the forests begining to burn is significant. To see forests burning from space is significant. Especially when seeing a hatak shoot at the surface of a planet seems to do nothing.
You cant say daedy can beat an ISD or vice versa. You have to prove that stargate weapons are just as effective against ISD shields as turbolasers are in SW universe.
One of the SSD's has a laser which supposedly has the firepower 2/3rds of the death stars main laser.
If a ISD is even 1000th the size of a SSD, it should have 1000th the firepower/energy output. It begs to ask the question how powerful 2/3000th of a death star beam is. I'd say pretty powerful.
You may want to reconsider your claims.
Comment