Supernatural Hangman

[Jack_O'Neill_fan]

How about I?

[warrior_chic]

S?

[the fifth man]

H ?

[starg8fans]

Yes on all counts.

A: -hat/-i-/the/---/-i-e/---?
B: It's/this/-e----/tea. It/s-e--e-/a----, taste-/--rse.
A: -hat/-i-/it/--?
B: --st/-asse-/ri-ht/--t. A--... --... I/ha-/the/--st/-i-i-, s--er/i-te-se/-rea-. -i-e/a/-a-/a-i-/tri-, ---/----?
A: T-ta---. -/-ea-/--.

: E, T, R, A, I, S, H
:

[warrior_chic]

D?

[starg8fans]

Good choice.

A: -hat/did/the/d--/-i-e/---?
B: It's/this/-e----/tea. It/s-e--ed/a----, tasted/--rse.
A: -hat/did/it/d-?
B: --st/-assed/ri-ht/--t. A-d... --... I/had/the/--st/-i-id, s--er/i-te-se/drea-. -i-e/a/-ad/a-id/tri-, ---/----?
A: T-ta---. -/-ea-/--.

: I, T, S, H, E, A, R, D
:

[warrior_chic]

C?

[LtColCarter]

W?

[starg8fans]

CW? Okay!

A: What/did/the/d-c/-i-e/---?
B: It's/this/-e---w/tea. It/s-e--ed/aw---, tasted/w-rse.
A: What/did/it/d-?
B: --st/-assed/ri-ht/--t. A-d... -h... I/had/the/--st/-i-id, s--er/i-te-se/drea-. -i-e/a/-ad/acid/tri-, ---/---w?
A: T-ta---. I/-ea-/--.

: I, T, S, H, E, A, R, D, C, W
:

Oops, just noticed I forgot an H and an I before...

[LtColCarter]

O?

[warrior_chic]

L?

[starg8fans]

That should be enough for a guess, I think.

A: What/did/the/doc/-i-e/-o-?
B: It's/this/-ellow/tea. It/s-elled/aw--l, tasted/worse.
A: What/did/it/do?
B: --st/-assed/ri-ht/o-t. A-d... -h... I/had/the/-ost/-i-id, s--er/i-te-se/drea-. Li-e/a/-ad/acid/tri-, -o-/--ow?
A: Totall-. I/-ea-/-o.

: I, T, S, H, E, A, R, D, C, W, L, O
:

[warrior_chic]

Just a few more words. N?

[starg8fans]

Hope this will do, cause I gotta hit the sack. Have a dental procedure tomorrow - oh joy...

A: What/did/the/doc/-i-e/-o-?
B: It's/this/-ellow/tea. It/s-elled/aw--l, tasted/worse.
A: What/did/it/do?
B: --st/-assed/ri-ht/o-t. And... -h... I/had/the/-ost/-i-id, s--er/intense/drea-. Li-e/a/-ad/acid/tri-, -o-/-now?
A: Totall-. I/-ean/no.

: O, T, H, E, C, A, R, D, S, W, I, L, T
:

[warrior_chic]

Enjoy the dentist, if that's possible. I think I got it.

Spoiler:

Dean: What did the doc give you?
Dream-murderer (can't remember his name): It's this yellow tea. It smelled awful, tasted worse.
Dean: What did it do?
Freaky Dude: Just passed right out. And... uh... I had the most vivid super intese dream. Like a bad acid trip, you know?
Dean: Totally. I mean no.