4 Great Races Vs. 4 Great Evils

[Wraith named Michael]

I not sure if this has been done before, but what if the the 4 Great Races

(Asguard, Nox, Furling, and Ancient) joined forces against the 4 Great Evils (Goa'uld, Wraith, Ori, and Replicator)? Who would win?

[Anthony]

Well... the Ancients were destroyed by the Wraith, and the Asgard... I won't give too much detail.

But with the forces combined, I'd say the good guys

[jaffa_shol'va]

I don’t think that’s a fair match up. Your using four good races one of we have never seen before, they were together at one time but never fought against all the villains you had put on the evil side.

Here are my teams
On the good side you have:
The Alterans, Nox, Asguard, Tau'ri, Jaffa, Tok'ra, Tollan, Furlings, and most important the Crystal life forms (just for fun)
And on the Evil side we have:
The Ori, Goa'uld, Wraith, Replicators, Asurans, Genii, Lucian Alliance

What would happen if these guys fought?
Who would lead each group? What cool technology would they make? Who would win?

[Asgard4eva]

Furlings had a Utopian community that was destroyed by Goauld, they sound powerful but way too pacifist like the Nox.

[Rudy Pena]

I don’t think that’s a fair match up. Your using four good races one of we have never seen before, they were together at one time but never fought against all the villains you had put on the evil side.

Here are my teams
On the good side you have:
The Alterans, Nox, Asguard, Tau'ri, Jaffa, Tok'ra, Tollan, Furlings, and most important the Crystal life forms (just for fun)
And on the Evil side we have:
The Ori, Goa'uld, Wraith, Replicators, Asurans, Genii, Lucian Alliance

What would happen if these guys fought?
Who would lead each group? What cool technology would they make? Who would win?

They are dead. The Genii, Lucian Alliance are dead with one Asgard or Alteran ship. The Wraith are dead with 2-4 Asgard ships.

[paulschapman]

Well... the Ancients were destroyed by the Wraith, and the Asgard were destroyed by replicators...

But with the forces combined, I'd say the good guys

I'm not so sure the Asgard were. The decline in the Asgard civilisation was down to the cloning process they used. The DNA declined over time so that constant cloning would eventually lead to a dead end

[Rudy Pena]

I'm not so sure the Asgard were. The decline in the Asgard civilisation was down to the cloning process they used. The DNA declined over time so that constant cloning would eventually lead to a dead end

Spoiler:

They are dead, they committed mass sucide in Unending.

[SG-25CSAR]

Actually, he is kind off correct. The war with the Replicators caused the Asgard a lot of damage. They almost lost there whole population to the war. That very war caused a huge amount of resources dedicated to the wat and not solving thier cloneing problem.
Then...

Spoiler:

...They were left with only one world and a unsolved problem, to make matters worse, there are enemies like Baal that could get thier sticky little hands on thier tech. So they had no choice but to end it. And all cause of the war with the replicators

[Rudy Pena]

Actually, he is kind off correct. The war with the Replicators caused the Asgard a lot of damage. They almost lost there whole population to the war. That very war caused a huge amount of resources dedicated to the wat and not solving thier cloneing problem.
Then...

Spoiler:

...They were left with only one world and a unsolved problem, to make matters worse, there are enemies like Baal that could get thier sticky little hands on thier tech. So they had no choice but to end it. And all cause of the war with the replicators

How can Ba'al get to the Asgard(Ida) Galaxy without help from earth as we are the only people who know where the Ida Galaxy is at. So unless Ba'al invades the SGC and get the cordintes(spelling) from our computer, I dont see Ba'al getting the to the Asgard Galaxy.

[SG-25CSAR]

Um...yeah, it wouldn't be the first time someone tried to get into the SGC and almost got what they wanted. I am betting that information from Anubis' mind prode on Thor includes the Asgard terratory. Not only them, but what if the SGC gets into another Foothold problem? The Asgard can't just take those risks, they said it themselves.

[monkey_man132]

Here are my teams
On the good side you have:
The Alterans, Nox, Asguard, Tau'ri, Jaffa, Tok'ra, Tollan, Furlings, and most important the Crystal life forms (just for fun)
And on the Evil side we have:
The Ori, Goa'uld, Wraith, Replicators, Asurans, Genii, Lucian Alliance

What would happen if these guys fought?
Who would lead each group? What cool technology would they make? Who would win?

The Asgard/Tau'ri/Alterans could kill the Wraith, Genii, and Lucian Alliance. The Alterans and Ori could fight long time because drones work against Ori mother ships and eventually Asgard would help them with beam weapons which work even better. Tau'ri, Asgard, and Alterans could combine against replicators which wouldn't be that hard to fight with the Alterans since they made the anti replicator weapon in the first place. As for the Goa'uld they may be difficult because of larger numbers but since most of the good guys are far more advanced they shouldn't be difficult.

The Nox wouldn't help us (pacifists), and we've never met the Furlings and we don't know they crystal lifeforms intentions at all.Tollan can defeat Goa'uld with Ion cannons unless they are Anubis modified ones. Jaffa would just help out as much as possible.




In conclusion: The good guys collectively are more advanced and have an advantage against bad guys. I think I've got them all. A lot depends on where the fighting will be though, since the Goa'uld can't cross galaxies, and some don't even have star ships.

[1DanielForMe]

Ignoring whether the races are still around or not, the main thing I'm considering is that the Nox, and possibly the Furlings, would not fight. While they may offer defenses, the fight itself would be two against four. Still, in term of ultimate conflict, good always conquers bad, so the good would win.

Well... the Ancients were destroyed by the Wraith, and the Asgard... I won't give too much detail.

But with the forces combined, I'd say the good guys

Right. That doesn't make sense to me, but I suppose if this is a spoiler about "Unending", it will become clear tomorrow evening. If it's a spoiler for "Ark of Truth" or even "Continuum", I'll find out after seeing which ever one of those this concerns.

[Icedragon]

Id say the evils.

Wraith have numbers, Ori are cheating, the replicaters handled both Goa'uld and asgard, give the them the goauld as well.

Also the Nox wont fight, they'd even stop the greats killing the evils.

[Nylon]

Does anyone else think its funny that the ancients created the wraith, ori and the replicators, they were also largely responsible for the advancement of the Goa'uld?

[Rudy Pena]

Does anyone else think its funny that the ancients created the wraith, ori and the replicators, they were also largely responsible for the advancement of the Goa'uld?

The Ancients did not create the Ori. They were once one great race, then they broke apart because the Ori wanted to share their knowledge and have people worship them and the Ancients were more into science and all that stuff so the Ancients leave their home galaxy to find a new home. They eventually found the MW and made it their home.