'Malice' (208) General Discussion

[the fifth man]

I thought of Koyla as well! Too bad Simeon isn't likely to come back. A good bad guy just like Koyla.

Simeon was a good bad guy like Kolya. And like Kolya, he got what he deserved.

[Galileo_Galilee]

You know, the easy thing to do would be to mine the gate and platform. THis could do a couple of things, let people explode as the step on to the ramp, and known down the gate to render it useless.

He'd be safe.

[morbosfist]

Since you brought up SGA, oh man, Major Davis is going to kill me. But this episode reminded a little bit of "The Eye" when Sheppard went on a killing spree when he thought Weir was dead. Kolya = Simeon all the way! Robert Davi and Robert Knepper are best in these bad guy roles.

Yeah, they're both great bad guys. Simeon plays the role a lot more threatening, though. With Koyla, you knew he was a bad guy, and you could take his threats seriously, but he was more aloof about it (at least, that's the best way I can describe it). With Simeon, he's a lot darker, deadlier, especially in his way of making people suffer by leaving them alive.

[Replicator Todd]

Simeon was a good bad guy like Kolya. And like Kolya, he got what he deserved.

Yes, thats one way to put it! But I love good bad guys....or villains in general.

[Briangate78]

Simeon was a good bad guy like Kolya. And like Kolya, he got what he deserved.

Sheppard killed him by shooting him as well. Which was fueled with revenge from what he did to his team and himself.

Yeah, they're both great bad guys. Simeon plays the role a lot more threatening, though. With Koyla, you knew he was a bad guy, and you could take his threats seriously, but he was more aloof about it (at least, that's the best way I can describe it). With Simeon, he's a lot darker, deadlier, especially in his way of making people suffer by leaving them alive.

What Kolya did to Sheppard in "Common Ground" was up there with Simeon. So I think they both were the same level of darkness. Difference is SGU is a darker show, so it gets amplified because of that, and that can be good or bad. Rush and Eli's emotions certainly fueled the episode. On top of that Simeon's little speech to Rush.

[the fifth man]

Sheppard killed him by shooting him as well. Which was fueled with revenge from what he did to his team and himself.



What Kolya did to Sheppard in "Common Ground" was up there with Simeon. So I think they both were the same level of darkness. Difference is SGU is a darker show, so it gets amplified because of that, and that can be good or bad. Rush and Eli's emotions certainly fueled the episode. On top of that Simeon's little speech to Rush.

When I heard Simeon talk to Rush like that, I knew for sure that Rush wasn't going to let him live.

[Briangate78]

When I heard Simeon talk to Rush like that, I knew for sure that Rush wasn't going to let him live.

It was almost like Scott approved of him killing Simeon in the end. Which obviously he knew he did. He could of killed Greer if that bullet was a little more over.

Like Varro said, leave him behind don't pursue him, he is too dangerous.

[Vanek26]

When I heard Simeon talk to Rush like that, I knew for sure that Rush wasn't going to let him live.

Yeah that was the end of Simeon

[highboom]

this episode was epicness wrapped in a tootsie roll and smothered in bacon...

was anyone else kinda hoping that eli was going to go commando on simeon there?

[GateroomGuard]

So for someone who hasn't seen the episode and won't until Hulu puts it up in 30 days. What was Simeons kill count, from the live discussion you'd think he killed the entire crew. I heard something about Park, James, Greer, and a bunch of other background characters getting blown up or shot.

[jelgate]

So for someone who hasn't seen the episode and won't until Hulu puts it up in 30 days. What was Simeons kill count, from the live discussion you'd think he killed the entire crew. I heard something about Park, James, Greer, and a bunch of other background characters getting blown up or shot.

4 people plus Ginn/Perry

[GateroomGuard]

4 people plus Ginn/Perry

Anyone we've seen before die or just redshirts we've never seen before? Anyone seriously wounded too?

[zainea13]

only complaint is that I wish Rush would have said to Simeon something like:

"Anything you tell me would be a lie!"

or

"I don't want to hear your lies."

or

"You've said enough."

some epic line that refuted Simeon. Because otherwise I feel like that goes against Rush's new leaf that he has turned.

[Pharaoh Atem]

best ep of the series

[O'Neil]

Good to see that Rush took care of business. I would have REALLY hated to see a storyline where they tried to get info from Simeon, only to unravel more problems.