VOTE! How would you rate 'Epilogue?'

[Skydiver]

I think the difference is that there are people explaining why they gave it a 10 in these threads, while I'm yet to see anyone even admit to giving an episode a 1 let alone offering any sort of reasoning for it.

i'd say, yeah, so???

Honestly, to play the devil's advocate here...someone says 'i gave it a one because.....' they stand a very good chance of being verbally set up on for bragging about giving it a one, or being too negative or whatever.

Personally? I think it's pretty dang petty and silly to spend your time going around knocking down polls on a show you don't like out of....whatever their motiavation is. but it's their time to spend that way and we don't have a rule against it so.....move on and ignore them.

statistically, their handful of votes really do nothing for the overall rating of an episode.

[Dilithium]

I’m either too new a member here or the poll is closed for voting. As I stated earlier I would otherwise give it a 10 because the episode showed us what could happen to the crew if they eventually settled on a planet somewhere. In doing so the episode rounded out many of the characters and we got deeper glimpses into their personalities. It would have been interesting to have seen an older Rush and what his contributions might have been.

[chrono trigger]

one problem sgu has had all along is the women are all defined by their relationships with men (or without men as in Camille's case)- this episode just continued that attitude. a woman is more than her personal relationships with a man. merely how I veiwed the ep.

i agree i personally feel sgu has lacked a woman who could be considered a role model like sam/janet and elizabeth.

[carmencatalina]

i agree i personally feel sgu has lacked a woman who could be considered a role model like sam/janet and elizabeth.

I disagree. While imperfect (as all SGU characters are), I think Camille Wray could easily be considered a role model. In my mind, she has "stepped up to the plate" over the last 2 seasons, growing to be a good advisor and even maybe friend to Col. Young, and someone you can depend on.

[Perelandra]

I disagree. While imperfect (as all SGU characters are), I think Camille Wray could easily be considered a role model. In my mind, she has "stepped up to the plate" over the last 2 seasons, growing to be a good advisor and even maybe friend to Col. Young, and someone you can depend on.

I second that.

[Lahela]

I second that.

Thirded. She's an outstanding character. Although I also think that Park, Chloe and (to a lesser extent) TJ and James have also become much stronger than they were at first. Not to mention the minor female characters like Palmer (for her one ep) and Barnes.

[carmencatalina]

Chloe has surprised me, and that is a good thing in a fictional character!

[Dilithium]

I disagree. While imperfect (as all SGU characters are), I think Camille Wray could easily be considered a role model. In my mind, she has "stepped up to the plate" over the last 2 seasons, growing to be a good advisor and even maybe friend to Col. Young, and someone you can depend on.

My only beef with Camille is that she is HR and I’m not a big fan of Human Resources in general. I get a kick when her “let’s negotiate rather than fight” methods have backfired and caused major foul-ups. She does portray the maddening HR mindset well though.

[Lianne]

My favourite episode of all SGU season 1 and 2.

AMAZING

[xxxevilgrinxxx]

a big NINE!

[General Jumper One]

I disagree. While imperfect (as all SGU characters are), I think Camille Wray could easily be considered a role model. In my mind, she has "stepped up to the plate" over the last 2 seasons, growing to be a good advisor and even maybe friend to Col. Young, and someone you can depend on.

this

[LordRush]

This was one of the better episodes

[Skiznot]

you must admit that all along sgu has had a difficult time with their female characters!

I don't agree. I think it's funny how some people think Chloe has just been following Matt around when if you really watch you'll see that He is the one doing the following. I guess some assume that just because he carries a gun, he's doing the leading. Chloe has proven her independence early on; she had no fear of going against Wray and defending young. And she even went against Scott to do what she thought was right. Wray may have been a little paranoid that the ship would become a military state just like Rush was paranoid that someone would take his personal crusade away from him. Park stands along side any of the scientists with her command of planetary science. TJ has always been willing to take charge when necessary. I've never define any of these characters based on male counterparts but that's the way my momma raised me.

[erotavlas]

10! Best episode yet

[LtColCarter]

10! Best episode yet

I concur!