Asgard Lost Tribe involved?

[PG15]

Yeah me too; Evil!Thor's reveal was one of the coolest scenes in the whole show IMHO.

[kymeric]

Because it was a stupid attempt to shoehorn in a species that we'd seen before, and completely undermines the fact that the species committed mass euthanasia.

In concept it works fine. In practice, it was terrible, although the writers of the show can take a lot of credit for the poor nature of the season in general.

But the presence of a violent subset of asgard is consistent with the real world mythology of the Asgard. The Aesir and the Vanir, hate it if u want but Loki couldnt have been the ONLY one like him. I would further speculate that the Wraith are the Frost Giants of myth, and the Bifrost (the rainbow bridge connecting worlds) is the Asgard word for stargates.

[Goauld System Lord]

I'd honestly rather they not. I thought it was a mistake to bring them in in the first place.

Personally, I agree with thevarrior. While I loved Thor and the Asgard on SG-1 (and Atlantis), the Asgard died in the series finale of SG-1. Let them rest in peace. It was bad enough they brought the Replicators over to Atlantis from SG-1, they had to bring "evil" Asgard as well. And to make matters worst, the show got cancelled before they were able to expand on that storyline!

Now if they want to bring over a Nox...

[Mongoletsi]

Personally, I agree with thevarrior. While I loved Thor and the Asgard on SG-1 (and Atlantis), the Asgard died in the series finale of SG-1. Let them rest in peace. It was bad enough they brought the Replicators over to Atlantis from SG-1, they had to bring "evil" Asgard as well. And to make matters worst, the show got cancelled before they were able to expand on that storyline!

Now if they want to bring over a Nox...

First of all; why would the Nox have any interest in attacking the "5th Race's" base? They're devout pacifists, and really like us.

Secondly; aaaaaaargh my eyes!

Thirdly; is that the right way to use an apostrophe inside quotes?

[Mongoletsi]

Evil!Thor's

An Asgard who isn't Thor who is also evil?

[Replicator Todd]

I think the Lost Tribe Asgard are the most dangerous threat in SGA so far besides the Replicators, i'd love to see them in Stargate Universe! But I don't see how.

[StarCapnRa]

I'd honestly rather they not. I thought it was a mistake to bring them in in the first place.

The Asgard decided that they were a dead-end, handed off their technology to Stargate Command, and killed themselves in the series' finale Unending. Would you dishonor that by having them crop up again and again? Simply to satisfy your desires?

(In that case, "Gatie" is an insult.)

[Quadhelix]

I think the Lost Tribe Asgard are the most dangerous threat in SGA so far besides the Replicators, i'd love to see them in Stargate Universe! But I don't see how.

Not really: the so-called "lost tribe" of Asgard is little more than a group of intergalactic refugees. They lack just about everything that made the Asgard powerful. The original members of the lost tribe most like consisted, in large part, of biologists, doctors, and cloning technicians. They lacked the large infrastructure base of the Ida Asgard, as well as the physicists and engineers. Nearly every technological development made by the mainstream Asgard over the past 10,000 years would have been unavailable to the rogue Asgard, and perhaps many of the developments made before that.

The only reason that the rogue Asgard were a threat was because they had found a way to activate the Attero device, which was destroyed at the end of "The Lost Tribe." Their ships were defeated by a single Traveler vessel, despite the fact that the Travelers were outnumbered, and the Daedalus would have likely wiped the floor with them if its weapons were still working. In contrast, a BC-304 would still have trouble against even a small group of Hiveships.

[Mongoletsi]

Question; how much contact was there between the Ida Asgard, and the Pegasus Asgard? There was obviously some, as the Pegasus fellas knew what was going on in Ida.

[jelgate]

Question; how much contact was there between the Ida Asgard, and the Pegasus Asgard? There was obviously some, as the Pegasus fellas knew what was going on in Ida.

None. I don't know where you get this information. If the Pegasus Asgard told the Ida Asgard about their intentions in the Pegasus their is a chance the Ida Asgard would try to stop them

[Mongoletsi]

Indeed. I interpretted the Pegasus Asgard's comments as meaning they knew about Loki, and the demise of their bretheren. This may not be the case.

[Replicator Todd]

Indeed. I interpretted the Pegasus Asgard's comments as meaning they knew about Loki, and the demise of their bretheren. This may not be the case.

I do not remember that, but they did know that their race would die out eventually by cloning...

[Stargate Steve]

I don't think we'll see them in SGU, I'm betting they will pop up in the 2nd Atlantis movie. Yes, I believe there will be more than one SGA movie.