Announcement

**the fifth man** · 16 July 2006, 01:27 PM

Originally posted by AGateFan

Show is arleady ruined.

Couldn't disagree more. IMO, this show has just opened up a whole lot of new possibilities for itself.

**Mitchell82** · 16 July 2006, 01:33 PM

This show is in no need of saving. I have been an avid fan of Stargate since "Children of the Gods" premired on Showtime. I love seasons 1-8 and do miss RDA, however I was skeptical when season 9 started but soon fell in love with BB as Cam, I found that he has some of the same wit as RDA but in a different way. I loved CB guest staring in season 9 and I am very happy that she is on full time now. TPTB have brought this show in a new dierection and I for one am very pleased with what they did in season 9 and season 10 is going to rock IMO. Stargate has a lot of life left in it.

Sheppard: Opporation that will most likely end badly is now underway!

**the fifth man** · 16 July 2006, 01:56 PM

Originally posted by Mitchell82

This show is in no need of saving. I have been an avid fan of Stargate since "Children of the Gods" premired on Showtime. I love seasons 1-8 and do miss RDA, however I was skeptical when season 9 started but soon fell in love with BB as Cam, I found that he has some of the same wit as RDA but in a different way. I loved CB guest staring in season 9 and I am very happy that she is on full time now. TPTB have brought this show in a new dierection and I for one am very pleased with what they did in season 9 and season 10 is going to rock IMO. Stargate has a lot of life left in it.

Sheppard: Opporation that will most likely end badly is now underway!

I've been a fan since the beginning too, and I totally agree with you. This show needs no saving. And it does have a lot of potential life left in it.

As for Season 9, I wasn't skeptical at all though, even in the beginning. As a huge fan of Farscape too, I knew Ben and Claudia would do fine jobs in their new roles.

**The.Prior.of.The.Ori** · 16 July 2006, 02:06 PM

Originally posted by the fifth man

I've been a fan since the beginning too, and I totally agree with you. This show needs no saving. And it does have a lot of potential life left in it.

As for Season 9, I wasn't skeptical at all though, even in the beginning. As a huge fan of Farscape too, I knew Ben and Claudia would do fine jobs in their new roles.

i remember at the beginning last season they did a behind the scenes look and ben and claudia were sitting for an itnerview and CB says" i hope we dont screw up this show also" in a joking manner, they have actually made it a lot better than it was IMHO

**GhostPoet** · 16 July 2006, 02:08 PM

Originally posted by Jimbo-DR

In the next episode we open with the Ori decending on earth, kicking our asses, and then POOF. Jack wakes up in his cottage bed.

"oh god, had a few to many last night. what a nightmare."

Jack still in command, no more Ori, and we get on with our lives. Just having Jack back could save the show.

The show doesn't need saving. It's time you move on and stop thinking Jack is the show. He's NOT.

**McDork** · 16 July 2006, 02:11 PM

Originally posted by GhostPoet

It's time you move on and stop thinking Jack is the show. He's NOT.

I dont think many people are going to, or are willing to even listen. But i couldnt agree more. Theres only so many times a thing can be funny, Jacks time was up.

I love Cam, and i adore Vala, im hoping for great things from season 10

**The.Prior.of.The.Ori** · 16 July 2006, 02:14 PM

Originally posted by the fifth man

Couldn't disagree more. IMO, this show has just opened up a whole lot of new possibilities for itself.

i couldnt agree more.. the show has a lot more possibilities for story lines than ever. and with the possibility of actually meeting the furlings, that will only add more yet again

**AGateFan** · 16 July 2006, 02:20 PM

Originally posted by Jimbo-DR

In the next episode we open with the Ori decending on earth, kicking our asses, and then POOF. Jack wakes up in his cottage bed.

"oh god, had a few to many last night. what a nightmare."

Jack still in command, no more Ori, and we get on with our lives. Just having Jack back could save the show.

Well, I personally am going with the "this universe is just a VR version that Felger made up" theory. If RDA has no desire to come back then we can just have the new base commander ... could even be Landry... ordering Dr Lee to get his az out of the chair so they can let the new guy ... could be mitchell... get some training in before his first offworld mission on SG-6.

Of course the show is ruined is my opinion just as the show is not ruined is other peoples opinion. Just as the dream sequence is a good idea is a persons opinion just as the dream sequence will ruin the show is someones opinion. Just as Feldger is an fool is some peoples opinion.....oh wait...ok that one is fact.... but still everyone has their opinions and the thread starters opinion is just as valid as anyone elses.

**Lord Shiva** · 16 July 2006, 02:21 PM

Originally posted by g8tr

Wow, it's hard to believe some people think the show is better with Mitchell than O'Neill. It's not O'Neill's absence, it's that Mitchell is supposedly so much better than ALL the charcters we've loved for years. He replaced SAM as team leader. Speaks languages like Daniel. Fights better than Teal'c.... etc.
Glad O'Neill will be back a couple of times, but didn't need Mitchell.

He speaks lots of languages like Daniel? Huh, funny, I thought that from Swarm we learned he knows Chinese. Didn't realize that translates to knowing jillions of languages. And last time I checked, Teal'c saved Mitchells butt in Arthur's Mantle, not the other way around.

**Lord Shiva** · 16 July 2006, 02:25 PM

[QUOTE=g8tr]

Originally posted by McDork

No matter what you call it, they replaced an established female commander with a man of less qualifacations. Sam should have demanded her command back, but she's been reduced to an also-ran. Being a female veteran, that really irks me.

Here's a tissue. This whole "Sam's no longer in charge because she's a woman!" issue is just as laughable as the whole "Sheppard's a male dog because they show him googling women" issue. Sam was in charge when they had a 3-man Sg-1 team. She moved on to what her character would move on to, R&D dealing with Ancient Technology and other fun scientist stuff (I seem to recall she's a scientist first and foremost), and just because she comes back, the militart isn't going to go "Oh, sorry Mitchell, we gave you SG-1 but we're going to take it away from you cuz Sam's back!"

**McDork** · 16 July 2006, 02:28 PM

Originally posted by Lord Shiva

Here's a tissue. This whole "Sam's no longer in charge because she's a woman!" issue is just as laughable as the whole "Sheppard's a male dog because they show him googling women" issue. Sam was in charge when they had a 3-man Sg-1 team. She moved on to what her character would move on to, R&D dealing with Ancient Technology and other fun scientist stuff (I seem to recall she's a scientist first and foremost), and just because she comes back, the militart isn't going to go "Oh, sorry Mitchell, we gave you SG-1 but we're going to take it away from you cuz Sam's back!"

Hey!.. you quoted that statement as me..i resent that!

*poke*

**majorsal** · 16 July 2006, 02:31 PM

Originally posted by Jimbo-DR

In the next episode we open with the Ori decending on earth, kicking our asses, and then POOF. Jack wakes up in his cottage bed.

"oh god, had a few to many last night. what a nightmare."

Jack still in command, no more Ori, and we get on with our lives. Just having Jack back could save the show.

I'LL TAKE IT!!!!!!!

sally

**majorsal** · 16 July 2006, 02:41 PM

[QUOTE=Lord Shiva]

Originally posted by g8tr

Here's a tissue. This whole "Sam's no longer in charge because she's a woman!" issue is just as laughable as the whole "Sheppard's a male dog because they show him googling women" issue. Sam was in charge when they had a 3-man Sg-1 team. She moved on to what her character would move on to, R&D dealing with Ancient Technology and other fun scientist stuff (I seem to recall she's a scientist first and foremost), and just because she comes back, the militart isn't going to go "Oh, sorry Mitchell, we gave you SG-1 but we're going to take it away from you cuz Sam's back!"

she's more qualified. try to debunk that.

sally

**kirmit** · 16 July 2006, 02:44 PM

I always thought jack was a great character but was no way the reason why I watched the show, I watched it because the stories were and still are great, in sum respects even better.

I'm all for people having different opinions aswell but i just dont see the point in these S9 and above haters bad mouthin sg-1 every chance they get, you dont like it, dont watch it, simple. It's not like the S9 lovers are goin round sayin 'S9 is great' all the time so why bad mouth it all the time? I personally can't stand Teyla on Atlantis but I'm not moaning about it, I just overlook her and enjoy the rest of the show

**Trek_Girl42** · 16 July 2006, 03:21 PM

I was the ultimate skeptic of season nine before it started- I had just discovered the show and didn't want it to be all different.....who were these new people? Where's Jack? Where are the snake people? Who's this new guy and this new girl? By the end of Origin I was absolutly hooked and had thrown all my pre-conceptions out the window. SG-1 in no way whatsoever needs saving, this new incarantion of the show has made it as strong as it ever has been.

Announcement

Here's a thought to Save SG1(the show)

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment