Originally posted by Asgard-VA
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Solitudes (117)
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by KorbenDirewolfScientists are generally trained to ASSUME that if one thing doesn't work, other similar things won't work.
I'm not saying I would have thought to dial another planet, at that time, I'm just saying I doubt her training would lead her to make such an assumption, rather I think she was so focused on getting back to EARTH that it never entered her mind to try another planet.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ZoidmanIt's hard to tell, all we see is his hand through the ice. Sam says he's a serpent guard.
This now leads me into my next question on goa'uld visitations to earth. If the Jaffa in Antartica is a serpent guard (one of Apophis's goons) and this gate was lost before the folks at Giza threw Ra out and buried the gate, doesn't this imply that Ra gained control of the planet from Apophis? Not that this really matters much, but I don't recall anything mentioned about it in the series (although maybe I blinked and missed it). Anyway, the early goa'uld chronology of events on earth might make for an interesting story at some point.There is nothing cruvas with me.
Comment
-
Hammond is to blame for Sam not trying another address; she has hypothermia as an excuse.
He should have, as part of a risk assessment, have considered the possibility that an SG team might urgently need to leave a planet where they are under fire from hostiles, but not want to come to the SGC, or not be able to. If the Jaffa chasing them had shot and damaged the GDO, if the Earth gate was in use at the time of the emergency, or if the DHD didn't have the right symbols then they ought to have a 'spare' address, possibly the Alpha site, possibly an empty and harmless planet, where they could regroup and sit tight until they can contact Earth or Earth come to find them.
Or if they needed to get out fast but they were themselves a danger to the SGC due to some contagion. Like in Bane, when the bugs were chasing them, it would have made more sense for them to dial a 'spare' planet.
Not really Hammond's finest hour. But Solitudes was such a great story that I'll forgive him. Just.
Madeleine
Comment
-
Originally posted by Madeleine_WHammond is to blame for Sam not trying another address; she has hypothermia as an excuse.
He should have, as part of a risk assessment, have considered the possibility that an SG team might urgently need to leave a planet where they are under fire from hostiles, but not want to come to the SGC, or not be able to. If the Jaffa chasing them had shot and damaged the GDO, if the Earth gate was in use at the time of the emergency, or if the DHD didn't have the right symbols then they ought to have a 'spare' address, possibly the Alpha site, possibly an empty and harmless planet, where they could regroup and sit tight until they can contact Earth or Earth come to find them.
Or if they needed to get out fast but they were themselves a danger to the SGC due to some contagion. Like in Bane, when the bugs were chasing them, it would have made more sense for them to dial a 'spare' planet.
Not really Hammond's finest hour. But Solitudes was such a great story that I'll forgive him. Just.
Moving right along... I *loved* this episode, one of the best lines... ok, 2 of the best lines came out of this episode:
Jack: It's my sidearm I swear
------------------------------
Daniel to Teal'C: And what would happen if you dialed your own telephone?... Bad example...
Comment
-
Originally posted by Asgard-VAThank you for the great detective work!
This now leads me into my next question on goa'uld visitations to earth. If the Jaffa in Antartica is a serpent guard (one of Apophis's goons) and this gate was lost before the folks at Giza threw Ra out and buried the gate, doesn't this imply that Ra gained control of the planet from Apophis? Not that this really matters much, but I don't recall anything mentioned about it in the series (although maybe I blinked and missed it). Anyway, the early goa'uld chronology of events on earth might make for an interesting story at some point.
[Speculation]
It's possible Apophis brought slaves from Earth long before Ra came to Egypt. The Antarctic gate is one of the first made (if not the first). It's located in the Ancient's territory, which suggest it was protected by an Ancient goa'uld killer or some other defense weaponry.
Then the gate was probably banned for that reason, which is why Ra brought the Egypt gate.
[/Speculation]
Comment
-
Originally posted by bcmilcoI don't think that's necessarily true. I'm a "computer scientist" and part of my training and eperience has tought me to try ever possibility no matter how unlikely it is to work. (Especially if it's a Microsoft product )The opinions of KorbenDirewolf do not necessrily represent the opinions of other male U.S. residents between the ages of 18 and 25.
Comment
-
Originally posted by omnianThere was one thing I didn't get about this episode......
If dialling Earth on the second gate didn't work then why didn't Carter simply try another address? To be sure that it wasn't just Earth that couldn't be gated to?sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by SamInChicagoA great episode even with the lack of hat. :rolleyes
I know Jack had several serious injuries,...but at least he had the sense to keep his head warm at all costs !!
I mean,if Sam had been following basic survival training,she'd have kept her helmet on.
(I'm assuming that the helmet was fully lined,btw.No sense in keeping it on, if there was no insulation against the extreme cold .)
Conclusion:The Director made her do it !
(This also (perhaps) answers the more important question, about why she didn't try a safe address, to see if she and Jack could Gate there ! )The place to "Gate" to during Outages for updates and info:
Comment
-
Possibly ! I know Daniel was the Address expert, but I know that if I was expected to risk my neck on a regular basis,by going through the Gate,I'd make sure I had a safe place memorised (or written down) in case of emergency !
Having stated that,"Solitudes" would have been a pointless episode, if there'd been no real risk factor ! (I enjoyed the episode regardless. )The place to "Gate" to during Outages for updates and info:
Comment
Comment