Cut the Green one... (Ripple Effect)

[freyr's mother]

The black SG-1 weren't evil. They were just desperate jerks.

The one I was most disappointed in though, was Daniel.

Maybe he had second thoughts about morality issues before they set out on the mission.

[PG15]

Has the ask joe thread opened back up, because i don't remember hearing this anywhere?

It was mentioned in the "In the Making" section of Ripple Effect.

[freyr's mother]

It was mentioned in the "In the Making" section of Ripple Effect.

Really? Where can I find this?

[PG15]

http://www.gateworld.net/sg1/s9/making/913.shtml

[All hail the USAF]

I don't think the Black Sg-1 should be so demonized...they were just trying to save their own Earth

[the fifth man]

I still think we may see this come into play this season at some point. TPTB have relatively good memories. But, Black Mitchell could have just been messing with our Mitchell. We'll find out soon enough, I guess.

[star47]

My question would be if it does come up is what would Mitchell do? Would he cut the green wire as "Black" Mitchell said, or would he wonder if "Black" Mitchell was mad that their plan got thwarted, and he gave them false info. That would be quite a dilemma, since the wrong decision, to trust or not to trust, could be a disaster.

[the fifth man]

My question would be if it does come up is what would Mitchell do? Would he cut the green wire as "Black" Mitchell said, or would he wonder if "Black" Mitchell was mad that their plan got thwarted, and he gave them false info. That would be quite a dilemma, since the wrong decision, to trust or not to trust, could be a disaster.

If I were Mitchell, I'd listen to Black Mitchell and cut the green one. I don't think the Black SG-1 were evil, just desperate. I can't see that Mitchell blatantly trying to screw everyone over.

[Pitry]

The black SG-1 weren't evil. They were just desperate jerks.

The one I was most disappointed in though, was Daniel.

The "In the Making" bit said thre was a scene where black Daniel was arguing with Mitchell on whether they shoudl go through with it or not and generally unhappy with the mission, and got cut due to time constraits.
I'm doing my best to pretend that scene made it to the final cut.

[Avatar28]

If I were Mitchell, I'd listen to Black Mitchell and cut the green one. I don't think the Black SG-1 were evil, just desperate. I can't see that Mitchell blatantly trying to screw everyone over.

I agree completely. They were desperate and doing what they felt they had to do to save their planet. I don't think even Mitchell was entirely comfortable with it but he still did what he felt he had to. He's still Mitchell though and I don't think he would lie like that to be vindictive. After all, what would it accomplish except possibly give the Ori an advantage in yet another dimension.

[The Signal]

*revives thread*

Looks like we will fnd out tomorrow, if it truly is to do with counterstrike. If I were them, I would definately cut the green on, its never the green one and it deserves its time in the spotlight

[the fifth man]

*revives thread*

Looks like we will fnd out tomorrow, if it truly is to do with counterstrike. If I were them, I would definately cut the green on, its never the green one and it deserves its time in the spotlight

That is true, if they were ever to show it, tomorrow night's ep would be the one. If that is the case, I'd definitely take the advice of the alternate Mitchell. I guess we'll all see.

[Mitchell82]

That is true, if they were ever to show it, tomorrow night's ep would be the one. If that is the case, I'd definitely take the advice of the alternate Mitchell. I guess we'll all see.

I wonder what we would have to cut?

[tommiekins]

That is true, if they were ever to show it, tomorrow night's ep would be the one. If that is the case, I'd definitely take the advice of the alternate Mitchell. I guess we'll all see.

Yeah I think I would probably follow his advice as well if I needed to. I mean if you think about it too much you'll just end up not cutting it out of fear of what might happen, you just have to get down to it! Also if its a bomb, then you're not really going to have long to regret your decision are you!

[full.infinity]

Yeah I think I would probably follow his advice as well if I needed to. I mean if you think about it too much you'll just end up not cutting it out of fear of what might happen, you just have to get down to it! Also if its a bomb, then you're not really going to have long to regret your decision are you!

The one thing I would worry about would be if it's green in alterMitchell's universe but not in our Mitchell's.