S8 DVD Audio Commentaries (Region 2 German)

[sgeureka]

Yep all the other episodes in the R1 Boxset have audio commentary and hopefully it wont be too long before MGM/Sony start a replacement scheme so us in R2 land can get our missing audio commentaries on 'Its Good to be King' and 'Citizen Joe'

Can you say who is doing the commentaries for those two episodes on R1?

[IndianaJones00]

Afraid I cant, I only know those episodes have commentary on the Region 1 set because I saw a picture of the case and it listed 'Audio Commentary for Each Episode' on the side for Disc 4.

[tsaxlady]

It's Good To Be King - Paul Mullie & Jim Menard

Citzen Joe - Andy Mikita & Damian Kindler

[NowIWillDestroyAbydos]

Here's an updated commentary list (originally posted by sgeureka (minus the bolding, it was a waste of time))
SG-1
401 - Small Victories - MW, JMe, JT
402 - The Other Side - PDL, JT
403 - Upgrades - MW, JMe, JT
404 - Crossroads - PDL, JT
405 - Divide And Conquer - MW, JMe, JT
406 - Window Of Opportunity - PDL, JT
407 - Watergate - MW, JMe, JT
408 - The First Ones - PDL
409 - Scorched Earth - MW, JMe, JT
410 - Beneath the Surface - PDL, JT
411 - Point Of No Return - WG, JMe, JM, PM
412 - Tangent - PDL, JT
413 - The Curse - AM, JT, PW
414 - The Serpent's Venom - MW, JMe, JT
415 - Chain Reaction - MW, JMe, JT
416 - 2010 - AM, PW, JT
417 - Absolute Power - PDL, RCC
418 - The Light - AM, PW, JT
419 - Prodigy - PDL, JM, PM
420 - Entity - AL, JT
421 - Double Jeopardy - MS, JT
422 - Exodus - JM, JMe, JT
501 - Enemies - MW, JT
502 - Treshold - PDL, CJ, JT
503 - Ascension - MW, AT, JT
504 - The Fifth Man - PDL, JM, PM
505 - Red Sky - MW, AT, JT
506 - The Rite Of Passage - PDL, JT
507 - Beast Of Burden - MW, JMe, JT
508 - The Tomb - PDL, JM, PM
509 - Between Two Fires - WG, JMe, JT
510 - 2001 - PDL, JM, JT
511 - Desperate Messures - WG, JMe, JT
512 - Wormhole X-Treme! - PDL, JM, JT
513 - Proving Ground - AM, PM, JMe, JT
514 - 48 Hours - PW, AW
515 - Summit - MW, JM, JT
516 - Last Stand - MW, RCC, JT
517 - Fail Safe - AM, PM, JMe, JT
518 - The Warrior - PDL, DS
519 - Menace - MW, JT
520 - The Sentinel - PDL, GJ
521 - Meridian - WW, JMe
522 - Revelations - MW, JM, PM, JT
601 - Redemption, Part 1 - MW, JT
602 - Redemption, Part 2 - MW, JT
603 - Descent - PDL, PW, GJ
604 - Frozen - MW, JT
605 - Nightwalkers - PDL, PW
606 - Abyss - MW, CJ, JT
607 - Shadow Play - PDL, PW
608 - The Other Guys - MW, CJ, JT
609 - Allegiance - PDL, GJ, JT
610 - Cure - AM, DK, JMe
611 - Prometheus - PW, AW, RD
612 - Unnatural Selection - AM, JMe
613 - Sight Unseen - PW, AW, RD
614 - Smoke And Mirrors - PDL, GJ, JT
615 - Paradise Lost - MGr, RCC
616 - Metamorphosis - PDL, JT
617 - Disclosure - DSD, JM, PM
618 - Forsaken - AM, DK
619 - The Changeling - MW, CJ
620 - Memento - PDL, DK
621 - Prophecy - WW, PW, RD
622 - Full Circle - MW, JMe
701 - Fallen - MW, MS, JMe
702 - Homecoming - MW, MS, JMe
703 - Fragile Balance - PDL, DK
704 - Orpheus - PDL, PW
705 - Revisions - MW, MS, JMe
706 - Lifeboat - PDL, PW
707 - Enemy Mine - PDL, GJ
708 - Space Race - AM, JMe, DK
709 - Avenger 2.0 - MW, AT
710 - Birthright - PW, JMe, MD, RD
711 - Evolution, Part 1 - PDL, GJ
712 - Evolution, Part 2 - PDL, AT
713 - Grace - PW, JMe, WW, MD
714 - Fall-Out - MW, PM, JT
715 - Chimera - WW, PW, DK
716 - Death Knell - PDL, AT
717 - Heroes, Part 1 - AM, AW
718 - Heroes, Part 2 - AM, RCC, AW
719 - Resurrection - AT, WW
720 - Inauguration - PW, MGr
721 - Lost City, Part 1 - MW, AT, RCC
722 - Lost City, Part 2 - MW, AT, RCC
801 - New Order, Part 1 - [D - AM, GJ]
802 - New Order, Part 2 - [D - AM, GJ]
803 - Lockdown - [D - WW, JMe]
804 - Zero Hour - [D - PW, JL]
805 - Icon - [D - PW, JL]
806 - Avatar - [D - MW, CJ]
807 - Affinity - [D - PDL, DS]
808 - Covenant - [D - MW, AT]
809 - Sacrifices - [D - AM, DK]
810 - Endgame - [D - PDL, DS]
811 - Gemini - [D - WW, JMe]
812 - Prometheus Unbound - [D - AM, DK, CBl]
813 - It's Good To Be King – [PM, JMe]
814 - Full Alert - [D - AM, PM]
815 - Citizen Joe – [D - AM, DK]
816 - Reckoning, Part 1 - [D - PDL, GJ]
817 - Reckoning, Part 2 - [D - PDL, GJ]
818 - Threads - none
819 - Moebius, Part 1 - [D - PDL, GJ]
820 - Moebius, Part 2 - [D - PDL, GJ]

SGA
101 - Rising, Part 1 - [R1 - MW, JF]
101 - Rising, Part 2 - [R1 - MW, JF]
106 - Childhood's End - MG, RL, RSF
110 - The Storm - MG, MW, DH
111 - The Eye - MG, MW, DH
112 - The Defiant One - MW, DS
113 - Hot Zone - MW, MG, RL, RSF, PMc
118 - The Gift - PDL, GJ
119 - The Siege Part 1 - MG, MW, DH
120 - The Siege Part 2 - MG, MW, JF, DH

Key:
AL - Andy Lee (director, editor)
AM - Andy Mikita (director)
AT - Amanda Tapping ("Carter")
AW - Andy Wilson
BW - Brad Wright (creator)
CBl - Claudia Black ("Vala")
CJ - Christopher Judge ("Teal'c")
RD - Rick Dean (chief lighting technican)
DK - Damian Kindler (writer)
DS - Dan Shea (stunt coordinator, "Siler")
DSD - Don S. Davis ("Hammond")
GJ - Gary Jones ("Walter Harriman")
JF - Joe Flannigan ("Sheppard")
JL - John G. Lenic (producer)
JM - Joseph Mallozzi (writer)
JMe - Jim Menard (Director of Photography)
JT - James Tichenor (VisFX producer)
MD - Mark Davidson (set decorator)
MGr - Michael Greenburg (producer)
MS - Michael Shanks ("Daniel")
MW - Martin Wood (director)
PDL - Peter DeLuise (director, writer)
PM - Paul Mullie (writer)
PW - Peter Woeste (director, Director of Photography)
RCC - Robert C. Cooper (writer, producer)
RD - Robert Davidson (set decorator)
WG - William Gereghty (director)
WW - Will Waring (director, camera)

[sgeureka]

According to http://www.dvdcompare.net/comparisons/film.php?fid=8173, there are the following Audio Commentaries on the Dutch Atlantis S1 DVD box sets (none on German DVD sets ):

101 - Rising, Part 1 - MW, JF
102 - Rising, Part 2 - MW, JF
106 - Childhood's End - MG, RL, RSF
110 - The Storm - MG, MW, DH
111 - The Eye - MG, MW, DH
112 - The Defiant One - MW, DS
113 - Hot Zone - MW, MG, RL, RSF, PMc
118 - The Gift - PDL, GJ
119 - The Siege Part 1 - MG, MW, DH
120 - The Siege Part 2 - MG, MW, JF, DH

A complete list is here.

[NowIWillDestroyAbydos]

According to http://www.dvdcompare.net/comparisons/film.php?fid=8173, there are the following Audio Commentaries on the Dutch Atlantis S1 DVD box sets (none on German DVD sets ):

101 - Rising, Part 1 - MW, JF
102 - Rising, Part 2 - MW, JF
106 - Childhood's End - MG, RL, RF
110 - The Storm - MG, MW, DH
111 - The Eye - MG, MW, DH
112 - The Defiant One - MW, DS
113 - Hot Zone - MW, MG, RL, RF, PMc
118 - The Gift - PDL, GJ
119 - The Siege Part 1 - MG, MW, DH
120 - The Siege Part 2 - MG, MW, JF, DH

A complete list is here.

Sweet, and thanks

[IndianaJones00]

I was the one who listed the Dutch set on DVDCompare

[kiya]

i remember a website which have the commentary transcript, but i can't find it again. does anyone know where to get dvd commentary transcript for those who cannot afford to get the dvds.

[sgeureka]

i remember a website which have the commentary transcript, but i can't find it again. does anyone know where to get dvd commentary transcript for those who cannot afford to get the dvds.

http://www.scifigate.net/commentaries.php does have a lot of commentaries.