SG-1: Season 9 Tournament

[poundpuppy29]

This how I ranked them before but I think will change my rank later when I have more time this was in june 2007 I believe

This is hard I loved so many eps from this season. Season 10 will be torture loved it more than 9.

20. The Scourge
19. Ex Deus Machina
18. Off the Grid
17. Stronghold
16. Babylon
15. Collateral Damage
14. Ethon
13. Prototype
12. The Fourth Horseman Pt. 2
11. The Fourth Horseman Pt.1
10. Origin
9. Beachhead
8. Avalon Pt.1
7. The Ties That Bind
6. Avalon Pt.2
5. Crusade
4. Camelot
3. The Powers That Be
2. Ripple Effect
1. Arthur's Mantle

I will do a new ranking later when I have more time I have changed my mind on the top 5

[Killdeer]

Out of curiosity though...how would everyone rank the episodes if it were up to you?

-Stef

Avalon Pt 1 - Very good
Avalon Pt 2 - Very good up until Daniel and Vala went to the Ori galaxy
Origin - ok
The Ties That Bind - Pretty good
The Powers That Be - Very good
Beachhead - Some of it I liked, some of it I disliked.
Ex Deus Machina - Hated it.
Babylon - Pretty good
Prototype - Pretty good
Fourth Horseman I & II - Hated Orlin, enjoyed the rest of it.
Collateral Damage - OK
Ripple Effect - OK, was a disappointment
Stronghold - OK, not so great
Ethon - Mostly hated it (Daniel's comment was good).
Off The Grid - OK
The Scourge - OK
Arthur's Mantle - pretty good, didn't like that they killed the Sodan off.
Crusade - OK
Camelot - Very good.

[madaboutdanny]

From 1 to 10

Avalon Pt 1 - 7...too slow at the beginning
Avalon Pt 2 - 9
Origin - 9
The Ties That Bind - 8
The Powers That Be - 8
Beachhead - 7 with this Vala left....and I prefer her to Sam
Ex Deus Machina -0
Babylon - 0
Prototype - 9
Fourth Horseman I & II - 6
Collateral Damage - 0 Too much Cam for me...
Ripple Effect - 8
Stronghold - 0
Ethon - 10 I love Jared Kane and Daniel comment about his never give up
Off The Grid - 6....Cam was very annoying...
The Scourge - 7
Arthur's Mantle - 8 I like D/S and, I can't believe myself...I like even just Sam in this...
Crusade - 0...I hate Tomin
Camelot - 10 I loved Daniel/Cam in this ep

[Celsius]

Hmm...

1. Camelot
2. Avalon, part 2
3. Beachhead
4. Collateral Damage
5. Ripple Effect
6. Ethon
7. Origin
8. Prototype
9. Arthur's Mantle
10. The Powers That Be
11. Avalon, part 1
12. Ex Deus Machina
13. Stronghold
14. The Fourth Horseman, part 2
15. Off the Grid
16. The Ties That Bind
17. Crusade
18. The Fourth Horseman, part 1
19. The Scourge
20. Babylon

I have major issues with everything after the top 10 though.

[jasminaGo]

Episodes I liked

Ripple Effect
Camelot


Episodes I can stand, but not really like

The Fourth Horseman, part 1
Beachhead
The Scourge
The Fourth Horseman, part 2
Arthur's Mantle
Off the Grid


Episodes I wish I can forget

Avalon, part 2
Collateral Damage
Ethon
Origin
The Powers That Be
Avalon, part 1
Ex Deus Machina
Stronghold
The Ties That Bind
Crusade
Babylon
Prototype

[Stef]

Episodes I liked

Ripple Effect
Camelot


Episodes I can stand, but not really like

The Fourth Horseman, part 1
Beachhead
The Scourge
The Fourth Horseman, part 2
Arthur's Mantle
Off the Grid


Episodes I wish I can forget

Avalon, part 2
Collateral Damage
Ethon
Origin
The Powers That Be
Avalon, part 1
Ex Deus Machina
Stronghold
The Ties That Bind
Crusade
Babylon
Prototype

WOW! You really don't like this season...I have to ask, in all honesty, why did you play a Season 9 game if you hate and/or could care less about 90% of the episodes? I mean, it must have been hard to pick anything that wasn't your top 2 I had a hard enough time picking episodes and I like the majority of the season

-Stef

[Ladyinred]

WOW! You really don't like this season...I have to ask, in all honesty, why did you play a Season 9 game if you hate and/or could care less about 90% of the episodes? I mean, it must have been hard to pick anything that wasn't your top 2 I had a hard enough time picking episodes and I like the majority of the season

-Stef

[snip] I love at least 1/2 of season 9, like 3/4 of the remaining half and dislike perhaps 2 episodes. And my favourite episodes are exactly these jasminaGo hates.

[jasminaGo]

WOW! You really don't like this season...I have to ask, in all honesty, why did you play a Season 9 game if you hate and/or could care less about 90% of the episodes? I mean, it must have been hard to pick anything that wasn't your top 2 I had a hard enough time picking episodes and I like the majority of the season

-Stef

I played the game cause I wanted one of those two episodes to win, but it didn't happen. And choose all the others mostly as a lesser evil or depending on Sam's role in that episode and how much I liked what she did there. Now, if it was S4 tournament I probably would have had the same problem as you.

[Stef]

I played the game cause I wanted one of those two episodes to win, but it didn't happen. And choose all the others mostly as a lesser evil or depending on Sam's role in that episode and how much I liked what she did there. Now, if it was S4 tournament I probably would have had the same problem as you.

Ah, well...Camelot got third and Ripple Effect came in...what...fifth? So I'm sure your vote helped them out (much to my chagrin since I'm not a huge RE person ). Well, if there were a Season 4 game again our roles would probably be reversed. Not that I don't like Season 4, I just don't quite love as many episodes as I would like

-Stef