Heal or hurt SG-1 ONLY characters - NEW GAME

[Chelle DB]

Healam
Hurt: Vala

Is this right? How bazzar! Seems like fun though - Cheers!

[ReganX]

I tried counting up the votes cast since the last recap. I think I made a mistake somewhere along the way; somebody was healed when they should have been hurt, so maybe somebody would like to recount.

As near as I can tell, the changes are as follows

Sam Carter: +19 (21 healing points, 2 hurting points)
Jack O'Neill: +15 (19 healing points, 4 hurting points)
Daniel Jackson: +2 (4 healing points, 2 hurting)
Janet Fraiser: +15 (17 healing points, 2 hurting points)
Teal'c: +2 (3 healing points, 1 hurting point)
Jonas Quinn: +3 (6 healing points, 3 hurting points)
Thor: +7 (7 healing points, 0 hurting points)
Bra'tac: No change
George Hammond: +2 (2 healing points, 0 hurting points)
Sgt. Walter Harriman: +2 (2 healing points, 0 hurting points)
Sgt. Siler: No change
Gen. Jacob Carter/Selmak: No change
Kvasir: +2 (2 healing points, 0 hurting points)
Oma Desala: -2 (0 healing points, 2 hurting points)
Ba'al: -1 (2 healing points, 3 hurting points)
Prometheus (the ship): No change
Dr Bill Lee: -1 (0 healing points, 1 hurting point)
Col. Chekov: -1 (0 healing points, 1 hurting point)
Carolyn Lam: -9 (1 healing point, 10 hurting points)
Hank Landry: -4 (0 healing points, 4 hurting points)
Apophis: -4 (2 healing points, 6 hurting points)
Dr. Felger: -9 (0 healing points, 9 hurting points)
Richard Woolsey: -7 (1 healing point, 8 hurting points)
Vala Mal Doran: -14 (13 healing points, 27 hurting points)
Anubis: -13 (0 healing points, 13 hurting points)

Which would make the current scores

Sam Carter 138
Jack O'Neill 114
Janet Frasier 75
Daniel Jackson 68
Teal'c 53
Jonas Quinn 51
Thor 48
George Hammond 42
Bra'tac 39
Sgt. Walter Harriman 39
Kvasir 33
Sgt. Siler 33
Gen. Jacob Carter/Selmak 32
Oma Desala 28
Ba'al 27
Prometheus (the ship) 27
Dr. Bill Lee 25
Col. Chekov 23
Apophis 13
Hank Landry 13
Carolyn Lam 10
Richard Woolsey 3
Dr. Felger 2
Anubis -11
Vala Mal Doran -12

Vala and Anubis should both be well and truly out and Vala reached zero first.

[Rodan5757]

Heal: Jackson
Hurt: Woolsey

[AdrianneP]

Which would make the current scores

Sam Carter 138
Jack O'Neill 114
Janet Frasier 75
Daniel Jackson 68
Teal'c 53
Jonas Quinn 51
Thor 48
George Hammond 42
Bra'tac 39
Sgt. Walter Harriman 39
Kvasir 33
Sgt. Siler 33
Gen. Jacob Carter/Selmak 32
Oma Desala 28
Ba'al 27
Prometheus (the ship) 27
Dr. Bill Lee 25
Col. Chekov 23
Apophis 13
Hank Landry 13
Carolyn Lam 10
Richard Woolsey 3
Dr. Felger 2
Anubis -11
Vala Mal Doran -12

Vala and Anubis should both be well and truly out and Vala reached zero first.

Thanks for picking this up
I'll play now.

Is it still basically the same as the Heal/Hurt SGA, with two votes a day?

V1:
Heal: Jack
Hurt: Apophis

V2:
Heal: Janet
Hurt: Sam

Adrianne

[ReganX]

Is it still basically the same as the Heal/Hurt SGA, with two votes a day?

As far as I know, the rules haven't changed. It's still two votes per person per day, the first counting for two points, the second for one and you can't use both votes to heal or to hurt the same character.

I don't know if my count is 100% accurate, so a second pair of eyes would be a good idea.

When Formerhost comes back, she'll be able to clarify the rules.

[Rodan5757]

Heal: Jack
Hurt: Apophis

[scarimor]

heal Janet Fraiser
hurt Oma Desala

heal George Hammond
hurt Thor

[jonno]

OK - with those results, i'll play again.

Resumption Day (whatever that is )

Vote 1
Heal Thor
Hurt Felger

Vote 2
Heal Walter!
Hurt Woolsey

[ReganX]

Does anyone want to tackle a recount? One character benefitted and was healed when they should have been hurt, but I honestly don't know who.

Should we wait for a recount, or stick with the results we've got?

[DEM]

I can do a recount, but you'll have to allow me a couple of hours.

I already had started one from the very beginning, and I can attest to the fact that scoring this game is a nightmare -- very error-prone.

[ReganX]

I can do a recount, but you'll have to allow me a couple of hours.

I already had started one from the very beginning, and I can attest to the fact that scoring this game is a nightmare -- very error-prone.

One thing I think I may have made a mistake with is when people didn't label their votes as Day X, Vote 1 or Day X, Vote 2. Some one point votes could have been counted as two pointers.

It's definitely easier to count up if it is done regularly. There is less likelihood of a mistake if you count at least once a day, preferably more.

[Skydiver]

do the re-coutners want me to temporarily close this thread, to stop more votes from being added until they can come to a 'new' tally?

i can do that. shut it down for a few hours then re-open it with the new total and the game can commence

[ReganX]

do the re-coutners want me to temporarily close this thread, to stop more votes from being added until they can come to a 'new' tally?

i can do that. shut it down for a few hours then re-open it with the new total and the game can commence

If we're picking up after Formerhost's last count and accepting that as accurate, I don't think that's necessary. I checked the time of Formerhost's last count and counted any votes after that, and only votes cast after my recap was posted have not yet been counted.

If we're doing a full recount from the first vote, we'd probably be better off tackling it one page or one day at a time from the beginning, in which case a pause might be a good idea.

[DEM]

I would appreciate a pause, please, if'n you don't mind. Thanks!

[RealmOfX]

I have a count for the first six days if ya want them. A total and daily breakdown - yes I'm a geek a bored geek. I'm just heading off to bed I'll find them and post 'em in the morning.

RoX