Season 1 Best Episode Tournament

[LoneStar1836]

Round 4

Poisoning the Well
The Gift
Underground

Aww... Sanctuary is gone.

[Naeara]

Underground
Hot Zone
The Gift

[Mio]

So much hate for 'Home'.....We learned so much about stuff in that episode...How Pegasus Stargates work, a good deal about each character. Plus, if you even try to tell me that those scenes with the switching back and forth between Real McKay & Fake Weir, and Real Weir & Fake McKay (With the lab coat! ) weren't spectacularly done, you're nuts.

The Defiant One
The Gift
The Brotherhood

[berenikee]

Underground
The Defiant One
Hide and Seek

[gooner_diva]

Round 4
Hide and Seek
The Gift
Home

[Qtyled]

The Gift
Thirty-Eight Minutes
Poisoning the Well

[Bozo]

Hi!
Hide and Seek
Suspicion
Home

[TheWarrior]

Hi!
Hide and Seek
Suspicion
Home

Bozo, you may wish to remove Suspicion from your list of least favourite episodes as it is no longer available to be voted off.

Check out Celsius latest post with the remaining episodes available to be voted off.

[Celsius]

Hide and Seek - 14
Thirty-Eight Minutes - 1
Poisoning the Well - 9
Underground - 7
Home - 11
The Defiant One - 6
Hot Zone - 6
The Brotherhood - 4
Letters From Pegasus - 1
The Gift - 12
The Seige, part 1 - 1

Hide and Seek is gone!

Rising, part 1
Rising, part 2
Thirty-Eight Minutes
Poisoning the Well
Underground
Home
The Storm
The Eye
The Defiant One
Hot Zone
Before I Sleep
The Brotherhood
Letters From Pegasus
The Gift
The Seige, part 1
The Seige, part 2

My votes:

Poisoning the Well (enjoyable, but the "cure that turns out to have a deadly side effect" has all been seen before)
The Brotherhood
The Defiant One

Get voting!

[GatetheWay]

The Gift
Poisoning the Well
Home

[starfox]

Letters From Pegasus
Underground
Home

[TheWarrior]

Poisoning the Well
Home
Hot Zone

[Naeara]

Round 5

Underground
Hot Zone
The Gift

[PG15]

Poisoning the Well
Underground
The Gift

[jonno]

Round 5

The Gift
The Defiant One
Home