Stargate Civil War

[Harry the Hippo Gutterman]

Who would win in a Stargate Civil War, O'Neill fans or Mitchell Fans?

[Jedi_Master_Bra'tac]

O'neill fans as there is more of them

[Harry the Hippo Gutterman]

But O'neil fans tend to be older and Geriatric like O'neill himself. I mean whats the next mission through the stargate? To find Orthopedic shoes? Or some Ben Gay?

[Jedi_Master_Bra'tac]

yeah but o'neill fans will be backed by macguver fans, i can't imagine they would be many farscape fans (being cancled after one season and all)

[theStormWeaver]

I have no doubts that the O'Neill fans would win.

[zpm!!]

i think i would kill myself then to choose over them and mckay and sam,

ronan and teal'c, well i would say teal'c

[Harry the Hippo Gutterman]

yeah but o'neill fans will be backed by macguver fans, i can't imagine they would be many farscape fans (being cancled after one season and all)

Farscape went on for 4 seasons and a movie. Also at least in Farscape they actually designed real aliens unlike in Star Trek where they have a little thumb shaped widget on their foreheads to denote they were aliens. "Look at me someone left a turd on my brow I'm from a different planet"

[Jedi_Master_Bra'tac]

Farscape went on for 4 seasons and a movie. Also at least in Farscape they actually designed real aliens unlike in Star Trek where they have a little thumb shaped widget on their foreheads to denote they were aliens. "Look at me someone left a turd on my brow I'm from a different planet"

who said anything about star trek?

[YodaMate]

Of course, both RDA and Jack have the advantage of been around longer to accrue a more numerous and rabid fanbase than etiher Mitchell or Ben Browder

Just pointing out that there was certainly more than one season of Farscape (i think there were 4 plus the movie special). Now it would be interesting if general Farscape fans and SG-1 fans had it out

EDIT : Ah, so slow ! There are now 4 more posts than since i clicked reply. Oh well.

[Harry the Hippo Gutterman]

who said anything about star trek?

I did. You quoted it in your reply remember? Lay off the weed dude.

[Jedi_Master_Bra'tac]

I did. You quoted it in your reply remember? Lay off the weed dude.

ok so maybe i had farscape confused with firefly

[Harry the Hippo Gutterman]

Yes firefly had one season, although now that you mention it I have to start a "who would be Better Nathan Fillion aka Captain Reynolds or Cameron Mitchell aka Ben Browder thread"

[The Signal]

^Ben Browder, no contest. As for O'Neill fans vs Mitchell fans - O'Neill fans, there are more of them for one thing, and they have a much more developed character to back.

[Carl]

O'Neill fans - there are more of them, including 2 much larger fan bases than Mitchell's 2 fanbases. Plus, O'Neill fans are not older.. I'm only 17, so anyone who would like to oppose the might of O'Neill followers.. bring it on!

[Daryl Froggy]

Yes firefly had one season, although now that you mention it I have to start a "who would be Better Nathan Fillion aka Captain Reynolds or Cameron Mitchell aka Ben Browder thread"

Hmm that's interesting you should really make a thread like that.

But I think that Captain Reynolds would win after all while Mitchell would be trying to talk he would just shoot him in the head...well if Mitchell were interfering with Reynolds mission at the time.