'Identity' (518) General Discussion

[bluealien]

Dreadful pile of crap. Keller can only do bug eyed and smirky. Again another total waste of an episode.

The rest of the team look bored out of their minds. Maybe they've just given up on the crap they get dished out almost every week.


2/10

[Giantevilhead]

Even if Neeva is better than Ronon, she's not in her own body. She's in Keller's body and seems very unlikely that Keller can outrun Ronon.

[Giantevilhead]

When Rodney and Sheppard were discussing how to shut the device down, they forgot that when Vala took over Daniel's body in "Crusade," the link was severed when Tomin shot the device.

Why was Rodney so excited about Janus's personal cloaking device? The Goa'uld, Asgard, and Sodan all have personal cloaking devices and they have access to both the Asgard and Sodan ones.

Their unwillingness or inability to use advanced technology is getting really annoying. They use Ancient medical scanners but still rely on primitive earth surgical tools. They're fine with using Goa'uld, Asgard, and Ancient technology when it comes to killing people, they need to use some of that advanced technology to save people.

[Womble]

Is it just me, or did Zelenka become the first person in the world to get a stabbing wound from a pair of pliers?

Couldn't they have Neeva use a screwdriver, a pair of scissors- something sharp, y'know?

[Anon]

I dont know, i was watching it, then i fell asleep at 8:45 (long week).

[Lahela]

Maybe Ronon simply couldn't be bothered putting in the effort to save Keller (or her body) yet again

[AutumnDream]

Haha, wow. This show remains completely irrelevant to its premise 'till the very end. Great job rehashing a stupid idea from SG1, however.

"Sooo, slot 18 is open. Should we do a story about Atlantis... or a trite sci-fi romp we have seen at least a dozen times before?" ~ Atlantis writer's room.

Welp, at least Jewel Staite is really pretty. Looking at her is always nice, but I can just go rewatch Firefly for that, and a superior experience all-around.

[Callie]

When Rodney first finds Neeva/Jen and takes her earwig out, he says something that sounds like, "Come on, it's ?Tinsel? Day." I think he was referring to some sort of special food day in the Mess Hall. Did anyone catch what he really said?

[Anubis-]

I dont know, i was watching it, then i fell asleep at 8:45 (long week).

Really? What you do ewhen you wake up?

[Crazedwraith]

You know the thread title is a massive spoiler that gets shown up on the main page whenever the thread is the top of the forum...

All I can say, not having seen the episode, is that I hope Zelenka survived the stabbing.

[dannster]

I thought that too!!!!!!!! And they weren't just small pliers, but massive ones!!!!!

Maybe if they were fired from a bullet? But from a skinny girl like that? It'd be like stabbing you with something liiiiike *thinks of large blunt objects* wii mote???

[AlphaBlu]

Schnitzel day.

BYE

[Agent_Dark]

lol at carl binder as keller's dad

[g.o.d]

what a piece of crap with bored actors this episode was

[JackHarkness_Hot]

I thought the execution of this episode wasn't as bad as I first thought it would be. Though this was a Keller episode, there wasn't a total heavy element of her that spoils her character, so that was a nice change compared to earlier episodes of Season 5 where she would be doing things, that is in reality outside her boundaries.

Jewel performed well when she pleaded her innocence and the magistrate ignored her pleas but anywho, it was nice to see the Ancient communications terminal again, though would have been cool if the device exploded when Ronan shot at it. Would have been bittersweet lol, but it didn't.

IMO, Neeva died, I doubt she had a hidden gun and took it out in time for her to shoot at the guy.