worst season 5 SGA episode

[mr_kennedy]

inquisition this episode sucked, i usually dont like recap episodes anyway

this had filler written all over it

[Matkin21]

BS was BS...

[Linda06]

BS was BS...

[Col.Foley]

Unending > EatG.



Indeed it was but, which parts were enjoyable?

The ambush.

inquisition this episode sucked, i usually dont like recap episodes anyway

this had filler written all over it

So did Whispers for that matter.

BS was BS...

Lies!

[mr_kennedy]

The ambush.

So did Whispers for that matter.

Lies!

LIES

ok but it wasnt a recap episode

[Col.Foley]

LIES

ok but it wasnt a recap episode

Well......unless you mean a recap of certain things having to do with michael.

[pisces27]

I have to say for me it was Brainstorm.

[Klenotka]

Inquisition! That is the title I tried to remember. I hated it. The only good part about it was Woolsey. I don´t like recap episodes (there are not any in other shows, just SG tptb don´t understand how pointless those episodes are). I especially hated Sheppard in this one. If I were the jury I would execute him just for being so damn arogant.

[Mitchell82]

That it was. But apprently a lot of folks still liked it and they even thought EAtg was better. So there is hope.

I'm one of them. I thought it was great but believe EATG will be better.

[Mitchell82]

Well it wasn't IMHO (I can't say why as I am not allowed to... so stop making me want to! )

Just remember that is your opinion. Many loved it.

[silvercomet]

I would have said Brain Storm but David Hewlett was hawt! lol

Yeah, he was the only reason why I watched this episode at all. I really loved the scene where he explained that it was his work/paper.

But all in all there was too much McKeller for me, so it's still my worst episode.

The next one would be Tracker. Even McKay didn't make this episode better for me. However compaired to Brain Strom = less McKeller. And the guest star was great.

Just remember that is your opinion. Many loved it.

I'm really a little confused with all the 'New Vision talk'. She wrote 'IMHO', so it's obvious that it's her opinion and others needn't to share it, isn't it?

[Mitchell82]

I'm really a little confused with all the 'New Vision talk'. She wrote 'IMHO', so it's obvious that it's her opinion and others needn't to share it, isn't it?

Well yeah but some people around here (I should have put this in to make it clear I was being a bit sarcasstic) Forget that opinion doe not make fact.

[the wraithwaxer]

THE SEED!
It just generally sucked. The writing wasn't that good and it did nothing major for any of the characters. I just plain didn't like it. There should have been more.

[Mitchell82]

THE SEED!
It just generally sucked. The writing wasn't that good and it did nothing major for any of the characters. I just plain didn't like it. There should have been more.

I know the majority didn't like it but it did have character development, a great guest star and more information about the Wraith. COuld it have been better? Sure but it wasn't awful.

[silvercomet]

Well yeah but some people around here (I should have put this in to make it clear I was being a bit sarcasstic) Forget that opinion doe not make fact.

Ah yes, I thought so. I even wanted to add something like that in my post, but the word 'sarcastic' didn't come to my mind. And I was afraid the sentence 'are you serious' could have been a bit ambiguous. It's not so easy in a forum.

I know the majority didn't like it but it did have character development, a great guest star and more information about the Wraith. COuld it have been better? Sure but it wasn't awful.

You are right. However, I didn't like it. And I really don't know why. No special reason. Just my first feeling. Maybe this is the kind of episode which I'll enjoy when I watch it a few times more. That happens sometimes.